TLDR
Upscale New Zealand cuisine with acclaimed tasting menus, incl. vegan options. A Michelin-starred gem for special occasions, praised for value despite being pricey.
Reddit Sentiment for THE MUSKET ROOM(based on 27 Reddit opinions)
Details
The Musket Room is a highly recommended New Zealand-cuisine restaurant in Manhattan, often lauded for its tasting menus that cater to both vegetarians and meat-eaters [27], [28]. It's considered a great spot for special occasions and offers an elevated, fine-dining experience that is particularly noted for its value, even for a Michelin-starred establishment [2], [5], [24], [11], [30]. While generally praised for its unique flavors, such as the Ora King Salmon with Dashi Butter [26], some diners have found the experience forgettable [8] or have encountered issues with cancellation policies [21].
Food Overview
The Musket Room is celebrated for its New Zealand and New American cuisine, particularly its tasting menus that are adaptable for both vegetarians and meat-eaters [27], [28]. Dishes like the Ora King Salmon with Dashi Butter have been highlighted as exceptional [26]. While many find the food to be of high quality and uniquely flavored, one review found the overall experience forgettable compared to other establishments [8]. The restaurant is also noted for potentially having vegan or vegetarian options, though it's advised to call ahead [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Ora King Salmon with Dashi Butter has been highlighted as an exceptional dish with a magical sauce and crunchy topping. The treviso and matcha dessert have also been praised for their unique and fresh flavors [26]."
Caveats
One user reported a significant issue with a high $150 cancellation fee and poor resolution after experiencing food poisoning, ultimately declining a rebooking [21]. Another user expressed a negative personal opinion of the restaurant [23]. It is also noted as being an expensive option [29].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE MUSKET ROOM
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Favorite Fine Dining Under 200 Not Incl Gratuity
"This commenter states that the Musket Room 'sucks' and recommends other options from the list instead."
NegativeFrom post: Favorite Fine Dining Under 200 Not Incl Gratuity
"The Musket Room is listed as a borderline fine dining option under $200."
NeutralFrom post: Spacious Restaurants Anywhere In Manhattan Or
"The Musket Room is suggested as an upscale dining option that likely offers more space and better seating arrangements."
NeutralFrom post: Fine Dining Recommendation For A Carnivore And
"The Musket Room offers tasting menus for both omnivores and vegetarians, providing excellent food in a luxe casual setting, though it is noted as expensive."
PositiveFrom post: Fine Dining Recommendation For A Carnivore And
"The Musket Room was mentioned as a restaurant with tasting menus suitable for both vegetarians and meat-eaters."
PositiveFrom post: The Unemployment Dining Tour
"Commenter listed Musket Room as a restaurant to visit."
NeutralFrom post: Any Recs For A Clemente Bar Style Tasting Menu
"The commenter suggested The Musket Room as a restaurant that fits the criteria for an elevated, vegetarian-friendly tasting menu without being stuffy."
PositiveFrom post: 10 Days In Nyc
"Despite visiting the day after The Musket Room lost a star, the reviewer found it to be one of their favorite meals. They particularly enjoyed the Ora King Salmon with Dashi Butter for its magical sauce and crunchy topping. The treviso and matcha dessert were also highlights, offering unique and fresh flavors."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Where To Splash Out A Bit
"The Musket Room is included in a list of recommendations for splurging on a meal in NYC, with links to articles about fancy dining."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Recs 150pp Winetip Not Casual Not
"This user suggested the Musket Room as a potential option within the clarified budget, but expressed a negative personal opinion of the restaurant."
NegativeFrom post: Whats With The 24 Hour Cancellation Fees
"A user had a negative experience with a $150 cancellation fee for a reservation. Despite getting food poisoning and attempting to contact the restaurant, they were charged immediately and only offered a refund and apology after contacting their credit card company. They ultimately declined a rebooking."
NegativeFrom post: Posttrip Report Amazing Experience
"The user rated The Musket Room 8.1, indicating a positive experience."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Dinner But Not Too Contemporary
"The Musket Room is suggested as a potentially cheaper option for dining."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations Please
"This is one of the 'fancy spots' recommended for visitors with a flexible budget, suggesting it offers a notable dining experience."
NeutralFrom post: Perhaps A Ignorant Question But Can Anyone
"This commenter recommended Musket Room for the original poster's request."
PositiveFrom post: Latest Inkind Nyc Recs
"The Musket Room is recommended and is participating in restaurant week."
PositiveFrom post: What Is Your Favorite Romantic Restaurant In
"This user had a really nice dinner with their wife at The Musket Room."
PositiveFrom post: Which Of These Four Michelin Starred Restaurants
"This user suggests The Musket Room and inquires about the type of gift card mentioned."
PositiveFrom post: Which Of These Four Michelin Starred Restaurants
"This commenter found The Musket Room to be forgettable, unlike Oiji Mi and Yingtao which they enjoyed."
NegativeFrom post: Restaurants With Veganvegetarian Options
"Musket Room is an upscale restaurant that may have a vegan or vegetarian menu, but it is advised to call ahead to confirm."
Neutral