Next.js logo

BROTHER PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (718) 442-2332

Address: 750 PORT RICHMOND AVENUE 10302

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Staten Island's once top-tier pizza, now a solid contender with classic Italian-American vibes. A must-try for slice lovers.

Reddit Sentiment for BROTHER PIZZA(based on 3 Reddit opinions)

33% Positive33% Neutral33% Negative

Tags

italian 2pizza 2View All

Neighborhoods

Port Richmond

Details

While once lauded as the best pizza on Staten Island, this establishment has seen a decline in quality according to some patrons. However, it remains a strong contender and a must-try for pizza enthusiasts on the island. The cozy atmosphere and classic Italian-American offerings make it a spot worth considering for a satisfying slice.

Food Overview

This restaurant primarily serves pizza, drawing from Italian and Italian-American culinary traditions. While some patrons feel the quality has dipped from its peak, it's still frequently recommended as a top pizza spot on Staten Island.

Highlights / Recommended

"Pizza is the signature offering, and it's frequently recommended, though with a note that quality may have varied over time."

Customer Sentiment

Customer feedback is mixed, with some lamenting a perceived decline in quality from its past reputation, while others still recommend it as a great pizza option on Staten Island.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About BROTHER PIZZA

Solo dining or takeout - Staten Island must tries
This post highlights Brothers as a recommended pizza option for those exploring dining or takeout choices in Staten Island.
Best hidden gem pizza spots on Staten Island
Brothers is mentioned as a pizza place that should be considered among the best hidden gems for pizza on Staten Island.
fave slice in each borough
A commenter suggests that while Brothers used to be the best pizza on Staten Island, its quality has unfortunately declined over time.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Hidden Gem Pizza Spots On Staten Island

"Brothers is suggested as a pizza place that should be considered among the best on Staten Island."

Neutral
Sep 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Solo Dining Or Takeout Staten Island Must Tries

"This user recommends Brothers as a great pizza option in Staten Island."

Positive
Aug 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Fave Slice In Each Borough

"Believes Brothers used to be the best pizza on Staten Island but has declined in quality over time."

Negative
Apr 3, 2025View Comment →

More in Port Richmond

See all

More italian in NYC

See all