Old-school Italian-American institution serving massive portions & a fun, social vibe.
Step back in time at this classic, old-school Italian-American institution in Brooklyn, a true neighborhood gem from the 70s. Known for its incredibly generous portions that ensure leftovers, this family-run spot offers a nostalgic dining experience with a lively owner at the helm. Don't miss their standout homemade cheesecake to round off a hearty meal.
This Italian-American restaurant is celebrated for its classic dishes and extraordinarily large portion sizes, with highlights including fried calamari, parmigiana dishes, and a standout homemade cheesecake. While generally well-received for its traditional offerings, one diner had a negative experience with the service.
"The homemade cheesecake is highlighted as a phenomenal and highly recommended dessert. Dishes like fried calamari and parmigiana are also noted for their generous portions."
Customers praise the classic, nostalgic atmosphere and exceptionally generous portions. However, one review noted a lapse in service quality.
Important Note
One review mentioned a negative experience with the service.
"The commenter recommends Ortabello, located a bit further away on Bay Parkway, as being worth the trip for the food."
Positive"The commenter recommends Ortabello, located a bit further away on Bay Parkway, as being worth the trip for the food."
Positive"This user recommended Ortobello in Bay Ridge for good old-school Italian food."
Positive"Ortobello's in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is described as a classic red sauce place with a family-run atmosphere, where the kids serve the parents who cook."
Positive"Ortobello's in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is described as a classic red sauce place with a family-run atmosphere, where the kids serve the parents who cook."
Positive"Ortobello's in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is recommended and accessible via the F train."
Positive"Ortobello's in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is recommended and accessible via the F train."
Positive"Ortobello's in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is described as a unique hole-in-the-wall institution from the 70s, with a social and fun owner named Andy."
Positive"Ortobello's in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, is described as a unique hole-in-the-wall institution from the 70s, with a social and fun owner named Andy."
Positive"Ortobello is a popular place, but the user found their service to be lacking."
Negative"The commenter suggests Ortobello's located at 65th Street & Bay Parkway in Brooklyn."
Neutral"Recommends Ortobello's in Brooklyn as one of three notable Italian restaurants for those willing to travel deeper into the borough."
Positive"Author lists Ortobello’s as a suggestion for linguine and clams in response to the original poster's craving."
Positive
