Unique Italian sandwiches w/ stellar execution. Standout Dom G. & Prosciutto Cotto. Worth traveling for.
Will Hartman reviews Carmenta's, a Bushwick spot serving simple and delicious Italian sandwiches like the standout Dom G. and Prosciutto Cotto.
This Brooklyn spot is a casual Italian sandwich shop renowned for its simple yet incredibly delicious creations. With a focus on quality ingredients and expert preparation, they offer a range of standout sandwiches that are definitely worth the trip. Whether you're in the mood for a classic or something with a unique twist, the sandwiches here are crafted to impress.
This Italian sandwich shop is celebrated for its simple yet outstanding sandwiches. The Dom G. sandwich, featuring fried eggplant, peppers, and ricotta, is a must-try. Other highly recommended options include the Prosciutto Cotto and the Jose Special with meatballs and eggplant. While the Chicken Parm is good, it's considered less remarkable than their other specialties.
"The Dom G. sandwich with fried eggplant, ricotta, and peppers, and the Prosciutto Cotto sandwich are highly recommended. The Jose Special with meatballs and eggplant is also a substantial and flavorful choice."
Customers highly praise the unique and delicious Italian sandwiches, with several specific items being frequently recommended.
Important Note
The dine-in seating is limited, making it more of a takeout-friendly spot. Some find the chicken parm less impressive than their other signature items.
"The Dom G sandwich at Carmentas in Bushwick is highly praised, featuring ricotta, fried eggplant, mint, and roasted peppers."
Positive"This commenter recommends Carmenta's."
Positive"This commenter recommends Carmenta's."
Positive"The author highly recommends Carmentas in Bushwick for their spicy vodka pasta, expressing that they miss it after moving away."
Positive"This user loves Carmenta's and thinks it's worth trying, even if it's not exactly what the original poster is looking for."
Positive"This user stated that Carmenta's has the best chicken parm hero they've ever had."
Positive"The user recommended the chicken cutlet arugula pesto sandwich at Carmenta's in Bushwick."
Positive"Carmenta's in Bushwick was recommended."
Positive"This user highlights the Turkey and Salsa Verde Sandwich from Carmenta's in Bushwick, describing it as having sliced smoked turkey, salsa verde, mayo, red onion, and fried shallots."
Positive"Carmentas is recommended for its "ridic parms" (ridiculous parmigiana sandwiches) if the user is looking for something sandwich-y."
Positive"The user recommended Carmeneta's in Bushwick as a great spot for Italian sandwiches that aren't the classic Italian."
Positive"The user suggests that getting seats should be manageable, potentially with a wait during busy times."
Neutral
