Next.js logo

GRIMALDIS PIZZERIA

Last Updated: 24 days ago

Phone: (718) 858-4300

Address: 1 FRONT STREET 11201

TLDR

Classic coal-fired pizza, a Dumbo institution now a national chain. Some say it's lost its char, others still call it great.

Sentiment Overview(Based on 9 Reddit comments)

22% Positive22% Neutral33% Negative

Tags

italian 8pizza 3american 3pizza 9View All

Neighborhoods

DUMBO

Recent Articles

Grimaldi's
neutral

Willa Moore reviews Grimaldi's, a Dumbo pizza landmark that has since become a franchised chain. While it may have lost some of its original charm and signature char, it still offers a taste of history.

Willa Moore Mar 6, 2025
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

This Dumbo pizza landmark, once a celebrated spot, has evolved into a franchised chain with numerous locations nationwide. While it still offers a taste of history with its classic coal-fired pizza, some critics feel it has lost its original charm and signature char, becoming more corporate. Despite these changes, it remains a popular destination, particularly for tourists, though some suggest visiting during off-peak hours for a potentially better experience.

Food Overview

The restaurant is known for its coal-fired pizza, with a traditional pie featuring ample mozzarella and a flavorful tomato sauce. However, some find the pizza lacks a signature char and can be underdone. It's often compared to Juliana's Pizza, with a historical connection to its founder.

Highlights / Recommended

"The traditional pie is mentioned, featuring good mozzarella and a flavorful tomato sauce."

Customer Sentiment

Customers have mixed feelings about this establishment. While some praise its pizza as great and recommend it, others view it as overrated, a tourist trap with poor service, and have even cited ethical concerns regarding wage theft and worker treatment.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

A user strongly advises against visiting due to alleged wage theft and poor treatment of workers. Another commenter echoed this sentiment, also mentioning a 'C' health score.
One user considers this pizzeria overrated, labeling it a tourist trap with declining quality and poor service compared to its past. Another commenter agreed it was good but not worth a long wait.
A user recommends the pizzeria near the Brooklyn Bridge for its great pizza.
This establishment is mentioned as a place that may have improved over time.

Recent Mentions

From post: Whats One Food Spot In Nyc Thats Actually Gotten

"Grimaldi's is mentioned as a place that has potentially improved."

Neutral
Jul 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Pizza Recommendations Near Dumbobrooklyn Bridge

"The commenter warns against eating at Grimaldi's, citing previous valid criticisms from the thread and the restaurant's 'C' health score."

Negative
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Pizza Recommendations Near Dumbobrooklyn Bridge

"The commenter strongly advises against going to Grimaldi's due to the restaurant's history of wage theft and poor treatment of workers."

Negative
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Favorite Sitin Restaurant Only Pizza Spots For

"The user simply recommends Grimaldis."

Positive
May 16, 2025View Comment →

From post: Looking For Food In Nyc

"Recommends Grimaldi's near the Brooklyn Bridge for great pizza."

Positive
Apr 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc

"The commenter found Grimaldi's good but would never endure the 2-hour wait again."

Neutral
Feb 27, 2025View Comment →

From post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc

"This user considers Grimaldi's overrated, stating it used to be good but became a tourist trap with poor service."

Negative
Feb 27, 2025View Comment →