Next.js logo

MALAI ICE CREAM

Updated

Phone: (347) 889-5789

Address: 268 SMITH STREET 11231

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Unique South Asian-inspired, eggless ice cream. Must-try flavors like masala chai & pistachio soft serve.

Reddit Sentiment for MALAI ICE CREAM(based on 12 Reddit opinions)

67% Positive17% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

indian 5south asian 2desserts 2ice cream 8soft serve 2pistachio 2View All

Neighborhoods

Carroll Gardens

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
The Best Ice Cream Shops in New York City

Malai Ice Cream in Cobble Hill specializes in eggless ice creams featuring South Asian flavors like masala chai, Turkish coffee, rose, and baklava. What began as a stand at Hester Street Fair has grown into a popular scoop shop with a dozen unique flavors.

The Infatuation • May 6, 2026
Read More →
Eater
Mentioned In
The Best Restaurants in Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn

Neha Talreja, Bryan Kim, Willa Moore & Will Hartman • Date unknown
Read More →
Infatuation

Details

Malai Ice Cream in Brooklyn is celebrated for its distinctive eggless ice creams featuring South Asian-inspired flavors. Originally a stand at Hester Street Fair, it has blossomed into a beloved scoop shop offering about a dozen unique options. Highlights include popular choices like masala chai, Turkish coffee, rose, and baklava, with many praising the creative and delicious combinations [1], [2].

Food Overview

Malai specializes in eggless ice creams with South Asian flavors, offering unique options like masala chai, Turkish coffee, rose, and baklava [1], [2]. Their pistachio soft serve is a frequently mentioned favorite, often hailed as the best in the city [1], [2]. Other praised items include a rose ice cream with cinnamon almonds and a vanilla saffron flavor described as superior to store-bought options [1], [3]. Ice cream cakes are also noted as visually appealing and recommended [1], [4].

Highlights / Recommended

"The pistachio soft serve is a highly recommended favorite, with the cardamom-mango swirl and rose ice cream with cinnamon almonds also receiving praise. Vanilla saffron is noted as being exceptionally good."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • •pistachio soft serve(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise Malai for its unique and delicious ice cream flavors, with many highlighting the exceptional quality of their soft serve and inventive combinations like rose with cinnamon almonds.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MALAI ICE CREAM

Best ice cream in the city (not gelato)
This post mentions Malai in Cobble Hill as a good ice cream spot, although the commenter notes they don't typically carry maple walnut.
Hani's soft serve
Malai in Brooklyn is highly recommended for its soft serve, with pistachio being a favorite flavor. The soft serve is noted to have flavors similar to their hard ice cream. Another commenter found their cardamom soft serve and mango sorbet swirl to be amazing.
Soft Serve in NYC
The author considers Malai's pistachio soft serve their favorite in the city. They also mention the saffron flavor is good but pistachio is preferred.
Rose flavored gelato
A commenter mentioned Malai has a rose ice cream with cinnamon almonds, which another user expressed excitement about trying.
Which ice cream places have the best top tier?
This user recommended Malai in Brooklyn for their vanilla saffron ice cream, stating it's so good it will ruin grocery store ice cream.
Ice Cream Cake in NYC
The user expressed a strong desire to try Malai's ice cream cakes, noting that they look amazing.
Ice Cream Cake
Malai was listed as a recommendation for ice cream cakes in NYC.
Looking for unique dessert spots in NYC with interesting flavors
Malai Ice Cream is listed as a recommendation for interesting flavored ice cream.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Looking For Unique Dessert Spots In Nyc With

"Malai Ice Cream is listed as a recommendation for interesting flavored ice cream."

Neutral
Jun 25, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Bagelsbreakfast Near Barclays My Wife Put Me

"Malai Ice Cream is recommended for its unique flavors and late hours, located on Smith Street near Smith St. Bagels."

Positive
May 24, 2026View Comment →

From post: Ice Cream Cake

"Malai was listed as a recommendation for ice cream cakes in NYC."

Neutral
Jan 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Ice Cream Cake In Nyc

"The user expressed a strong desire to try Malai's ice cream cakes, noting that they look amazing."

Positive
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Which Ice Cream Places Have The Best Top Tier

"This user recommended Malai in Brooklyn for their vanilla saffron ice cream, stating it's so good it will ruin grocery store ice cream."

Positive
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Soft Serve In Nyc

"The author considers Malai's pistachio soft serve their favorite in the city, also mentioning the saffron flavor is good but pistachio is preferred."

Positive
Aug 11, 2025View Comment →

From post: Rose Flavored Gelato

"The commenter mentioned that Malai has a rose ice cream with cinnamon almonds. Another user expressed excitement about this suggestion."

Positive
Jul 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hanis Soft Serve

"The commenter agrees with the recommendation for Malai, noting that their soft serve swirl, specifically cardamom and mango sorbet, was amazing."

Positive
Jul 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Hanis Soft Serve

"Malai in Brooklyn is highly recommended for its soft serve, with pistachio being a favorite flavor. The soft serve is noted to have flavors similar to their hard ice cream."

Positive
Jul 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Ice Cream In The City Not Gelato

"Malai in Cobble Hill is mentioned as a good ice cream spot, though it's noted that they wouldn't typically have maple walnut."

Positive
Jul 8, 2025View Comment →