TLDR
Elevated pub grub, known for surprisingly good burgers & fries. A solid option for casual bites and drinks.
Details
This American pub offers a familiar yet satisfying dining experience, with many patrons praising its elevated pub fare. It's noted for having better-than-average food, even drawing comparisons favorably to some London pubs. The atmosphere is often described as suitable for after-work gatherings or casual get-togethers.
Food Overview
The food at this establishment is primarily characterized as American pub fare. Standout items frequently mentioned and recommended include their fries and burgers. While many find the quality to be better than expected for a pub, a few users feel it doesn't quite reach the highest culinary standards available in the city.
Highlights / Recommended
"The fries and burgers are frequently highlighted as must-try items. The beer list is also noted as a positive aspect."
Customer Sentiment
Customer feedback is generally positive, with many highlighting the quality of the pub food, particularly the fries and burgers, as being above average. However, there are some dissenting opinions suggesting it might not meet the expectations of those seeking truly exceptional culinary experiences.
Caveats
One user expressed that this establishment's pub food is subpar and a disservice to recommend to visitors seeking a true NYC culinary experience, suggesting better options are readily available.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE ELGIN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Flatbush Recommendations 8 People
"This establishment has a large table in the back that can accommodate a party of about 25 people."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Near Radio City Music Hall
"A user recommended The Elgin as a moderately priced pub, highlighting its great fries and decent burger, along with a good beer list."
PositiveFrom post: Food Recommendations For First Timers
"This establishment was mentioned as a potential dinner option for first-time visitors to NYC, located near Hell's Kitchen/Hudson Yards. The user is considering it among other places."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For First Timers
"The writer criticizes the suggestion of The Elgin for someone visiting NYC from the UK, stating that the pub food is subpar compared to options available in NYC. They believe it's a disservice to recommend such a place when better culinary experiences are easily accessible."
NegativeFrom post: Recommendations For First Timers
"The Elgin is about as good as pub food can be, and Stout NYC is comparable. The writer has had the pub food there a fair amount after work and found the food to be better than average. They also mentioned that the food is better than a lot of pubs in London."
Positive