NYC's go-to for perfectly crafted bagels. Known for its excellent bread, especially with salmon, though some debates exist on whether it tops the city's elite.
This East Village bagel shop is a popular spot, known for its delicious and fresh bagels. While some praise its traditional New York style, others find it to be a bit hit-or-miss compared to other renowned bagel establishments. It's particularly noted for its well-made bread and options like the salmon cream cheese, though some find the toppings could be improved.
This establishment offers classic New York-style bagels, with a particular highlight being the quality of the bread itself. The salmon on everything bagel is frequently mentioned, with some finding it superior to other options. However, there are dissenting opinions suggesting that while the bagels are good, they might be considered 'meh' or overrated by some compared to other city favorites.
"The salmon on everything bagel is frequently mentioned as a standout. The tomato bagel sandwich has also been highlighted as surprisingly good."
Customer feedback is mixed, with many appreciating the quality of the bagels, particularly the bread. However, some reviews suggest that while good, it may not stand out amongst the best in NYC.
Important Note
Some users feel that Apollo Bagels are overrated and that there are many superior alternatives for authentic New York bagels. They are also noted as not being a traditional NYC style bagel by some.
"This commenter recommends Apollo Bagels for breakfast."
Positive"Apollo was mentioned in relation to sourdough."
Neutral"The commenter agrees that Ess-a-Bagel is a good alternative, and recommends any of the mentioned alternatives over Apollo."
Negative"The commenter strongly advises against Apollo Bagels, suggesting there are many superior options for authentic New York bagels."
Negative"The commenter finds Apollo Bagels to be acceptable."
Neutral"This user recommends Apollo bagels, calling them glorious and stating they freeze and deliver well."
Positive"Apollo delivers and their bagels freeze well, though they are noted as not being a traditional NYC style."
Positive"This user suggested that a 'bougier' option like Apollo Bagels might be willing to rent out their space for an event."
Neutral"Apollo Bagels is listed as overrated and not worth the wait by the reviewer."
Negative"Apollo is listed as a suggestion for a bagel joint."
Positive"Apollo is listed as a Chinese bakery option."
Neutral"The author expressed that Apollo Bagels was a questionable pick on a list of best bagels in NYC."
Negative"This commenter plans to try Apollo Bagels for breakfast based on the previous discussion."
Neutral"The author noted they personally prefer the crunchier, less doughy bread style of Apollo Bagels."
Positive"The author tried the salmon on everything bagel for comparison with Bagel Pub. They preferred Apollo's bread but found Bagel Pub's toppings better."
Positive"The tomato bagel sandwich from Apollo Bagels was surprisingly good."
Positive"This commenter negatively remarked that while the original poster went to Apollo Bagels, they should have avoided it and perhaps chosen L'Industrie instead."
Negative"The author listed Apollo Bagels with cream cheese, tomato, and smoked salmon as one of their favorites from their NYC trip."
Positive"The author recommends Apollo Bagels in the East Village for bagels."
Positive"Mentions Apollo Bagels as a good option for bagels that freeze well."
Positive
