Italian marketplace with standout gelato, artisanal ricotta, and delicious tiramisu. Great for browsing and casual bites.
Eataly offers a vibrant Italian marketplace experience with a diverse range of food items and culinary delights. It's a place where you can wander and discover a variety of Italian groceries, from artisanal cheeses to freshly made pasta. Customers often highlight the gelato as a must-try, with mentions of unique flavors and a generally positive reception. The market also features specialty items like sheep's milk ricotta and a selection of nut butters, with specific recommendations for flavors like wildflower honey almond butter. For those seeking a more substantial meal, the pasta dishes, such as the agnolotti with ramps, have garnered praise. The tiramisu is another popular dessert item. While many enjoy Eataly for its atmosphere and offerings, some suggest it's more of a pleasant browse than a primary dining destination, though their weekday lunch specials are noted as a decent option.
Eataly is an Italian marketplace offering a variety of food items. Customers frequently recommend their gelato, praising unique flavors, and also suggest trying their sheep's milk ricotta and various nut butters. Pasta dishes, particularly the agnolotti with ramps, have also received positive mentions. For desserts, tiramisu is highly recommended. One user noted that the milk-flavored ice creams can be too sweet and not sufficiently milky.
"Highly recommended items include gelato, sheep's milk ricotta, tiramisu, and pasta dishes like agnolotti with ramps. Various nut butters are also praised."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Eataly, appreciating its marketplace atmosphere and the quality of its Italian offerings. Specific recommendations include gelato, various nut butters, sheep's milk ricotta, pasta dishes like agnolotti with ramps, and tiramisu. Some find it a pleasant place to browse and enjoy a casual meal or dessert, though not necessarily a destination for a special trip.
Important Note
One user found the milk-flavored ice creams to be too sweet and not milky enough.
"Seconds the recommendation for Eataly's tiramisu, describing it as delicious."
Positive"Recommends Eataly for takeout tiramisu."
Positive"Suggests Amalfi on the rooftop at Eataly near the 23rd st N/R/W stop as an alternative."
Positive"Eataly's milk flavored ice creams are too sweet and not milky enough."
Negative"Eataly served a great pasta dish featuring ramps a few years ago."
Positive"The agnolotti at the pasta bar at Eataly in Flatiron is recommended."
Positive"Will have Italian Easter desserts on the menu."
Positive"Suggests having Espresso and Gelato at Eataly."
Positive"Recommends Eataly, especially the sheep's milk ricotta."
Positive"User enjoys Eataly Flatiron, finds it fun to walk around when nearby, and notes they have a decent weekday lunch special, but wouldn't make a special trip for it."
Neutral"Recommends Eataly for Big Spoon nut butters, mentioning cool flavors like carrot cake and bourbon pecan. Highly recommends the wildflower honey almond butter on apples."
Positive"The commenter saw rabbit meat at Eataly during their last visit."
Neutral"[Eataly](https://maps.app.goo.gl/XHuXMV1JNvVkA1rVA) is a cool Italian Marketplace...To be honest I always like walking through but the only thing I've ever brought is their gelato lol."
Neutral
