TLDR
Intimate speakeasy-style cocktail bar with no menus; bartenders craft bespoke drinks based on your flavor profile.
Chloe Brennan visits Attaboy, a legendary speakeasy from the alumni of Milk & Honey, praising its custom-made cocktails and secretive atmosphere.
Details
A premier speakeasy in the Lower East Side, this establishment honors the legacy of Milk & Honey by offering a bespoke, menu-free cocktail experience [1]. Patrons enjoy an intimate atmosphere where expert bartenders craft personalized drinks tailored to individual preferences [2], [3]. Known for its inventive spirit, it is famously the birthplace of the iconic Penicillin cocktail [1], [4].
Caveats
The bar does not serve food, and potential guests should be prepared for a discreet, buzzer-only entrance and occasional wait times [1]. Additionally, some visitors have found the pricing for mocktails to be quite high [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ATTABOY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: My Manhattan Bar Pilgrimage Vol Iii June 2729
"The reviewer had a poor experience, finding the bartender uncreative and focused solely on speed rather than crafting interesting drinks."
NegativeFrom post: My Manhattan Bar Pilgrimage Vol Iii June 2729
"The user agrees this is the platonic ideal of a cocktail bar, noting they have a massive database of recipes and bartenders who create personalized drinks."
PositiveFrom post: My Manhattan Bar Pilgrimage Vol Iii June 2729
"The visitor considers this their favorite bar for two consecutive years, citing intimate atmosphere, exceptional craft, and a huge database of cocktail recipes."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Recommendations For Cocktailfocused
"Located close to Double Chicken Please in the Lower East Side."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Best Gingerforward Food Or Drink Youve
"Recommends trying the Penicillin cocktail at Attaboy, where the drink was invented, and also suggests ordering the spiciest Dark N' Stormy there."
Positive