TLDR
An elite, menu-less speakeasy crafting bespoke cocktails in an intimate, secretive setting. A legendary destination where expert bartenders design drinks on the fly based on your taste.
Chloe Brennan visits Attaboy, a legendary speakeasy from the alumni of Milk & Honey, praising its custom-made cocktails and secretive atmosphere.
Details
An elite speakeasy founded by alumni of Milk & Honey, this destination is renowned for its personalized cocktail service and secretive, intimate atmosphere [1]. There are no menus here; instead, expert bartenders craft custom libations tailored to your specific preferences [1]. Guests should be prepared for a hidden entrance and a potentially exclusive vibe that cements its status as a top-tier cocktail destination in the city [1].
Food Overview
This establishment is strictly a cocktail bar and does not serve food, so guests are encouraged to plan their dining accordingly [1]. The menu features no set offerings, but the signature Penicillin is highly recommended as a must-try classic [1], along with various creative twists on daiquiris [3] and spicy versions of a Dark N' Stormy [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"The original Penicillin cocktail is the standout recommendation [1], though bartenders are skilled at crafting bespoke creations based on individual preference [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •penicillin(2)
Customer Sentiment
Visitors consistently praise the bar as an elite cocktail destination, though some note that costs for non-alcoholic options can be high [2].
Caveats
Guests should note that the bar does not serve food [1] and that mocktail pricing has been cited as expensive by some patrons [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ATTABOY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Recommendations For Cocktailfocused
"Located close to Double Chicken Please in the Lower East Side."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Best Gingerforward Food Or Drink Youve
"Recommends trying the Penicillin cocktail at Attaboy, where the drink was invented, and also suggests ordering the spiciest Dark N' Stormy there."
PositiveFrom post: Best Mocktails In Bkmanhattan That Arent 20 Real
"The commenter mentioned having some good mocktails at Attaboy, but they were priced over $20, which they found unfortunate."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Find A A Great Tradition Daiquiri
"This commenter stated that Attaboy is a place that would give variations on a classic daiquiri."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find A A Great Tradition Daiquiri
"This user clarified a potential typo in 'Attaboy' and suggested it as a place that might offer variations on a classic daiquiri."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find A A Great Tradition Daiquiri
"Attaboy was listed as an 'elite cocktail bar' that would likely serve a great daiquiri."
Positive