Hearty Alsatian fare & extensive European beers. Stellar croque madame & popular brunch. UES classic.
Will Hartman reviews Cafe D’Alsace, an Upper East Side institution offering a taste of French-German Alsatian cuisine, from hearty casseroles to a standout croque madame, complemented by a vast European beer selection. Perfect for casual dinners and brunch.
Cafe D'Alsace, an Upper East Side institution, offers a hearty taste of French-German Alsatian cuisine. It's known for its robust dishes like potato casseroles with sauerkraut and a standout croque madame, complemented by an extensive European beer selection. This classic bistro ambiance makes it a favored spot for casual dinners and brunch, with a history spanning about twenty years.
The restaurant specializes in French-German Alsatian cuisine, with customers praising dishes like the orange duck, beet salad with goat cheese, French onion soup, and a formerly tasty burger. The croque madame is highlighted as stellar. While generally well-regarded, one recent comment suggests a decline in quality since 2022-23, though it's also noted as a solid option.
"Standout dishes include the croque madame, orange duck, beet salad with goat cheese, and French onion soup. Some also recall a previously tasty burger."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Cafe D'Alsace, often recommending it for its good food, ambiance, and value, particularly during Restaurant Week. However, there are some recent criticisms suggesting a decline in quality since 2022-23.
Important Note
There is a recent negative comment suggesting that the restaurant's quality has declined significantly since 2022-23, contrasting with its historical reputation.
"This user stated that they have booked a reservation at Cafe D'Alsace."
Positive"This user also recommended Cafe D'Alsace."
Positive"This user agreed with the recommendation for Cafe D'Alsace."
Positive"This user recommended Cafe D'Alsace."
Positive"Cafe D'Alsace is recommended as a French cuisine option for Restaurant Week in NYC, with the author having visited multiple years."
Neutral"This user commented that Cafe D ’Alsace is a chain restaurant, mediocre at best, and high-priced."
Negative"This user seconded the recommendation for Cafe D ’Alsace."
Positive"This user stated that Cafe D ’Alsace is always a solid option."
Positive"This commenter expressed disappointment with the quality of Cafe d’Alsace, stating it was a former neighborhood favorite but has been horrible since 2022-23."
Negative"Cafe d’Alsace was listed as one of the restaurants on the UES that friends liked, implying a positive experience."
Positive"This commenter mentioned that Cafe d’Alsace previously had a tasty burger."
Positive"The user agrees with the description of Cafe D'Alsace as a great spot with a tasty steak option, not intending to classify it strictly as a steakhouse."
Positive"The user clarifies that Cafe D'Alsace is a favorite restaurant with a tasty steak option, often visited during Restaurant Week, and loves its ambiance and food."
Positive"The commenter questions why Cafe D'Alsace is considered a destination restaurant for steak, suggesting it's more of a local favorite due to its French bistro style."
Neutral"This user notes that Cafe D'Alsace is more of a French bistro with steak options rather than a dedicated steakhouse."
Neutral"The user mentions Cafe D'Alsace as a place they've tried steak, highlighting it as a favorite due to its ambiance and food, often visiting during Restaurant Week."
Positive"This commenter suggested Cafe D’Alsace."
Neutral"Cafe d'Alsace was listed among other places as a breakfast suggestion."
Positive"The commenter notes that the new Cafe d’Alsace location is not the same as the original corner spot, expressing nostalgia for the old one."
Negative"Cafe d’Alsace is recommended as a dining option east of Lexington Avenue, providing more choices."
Positive
