Next.js logo

BAGEL TO SANDWICH

Updated

Phone: (646) 329-6828

Address: 240 WEST 40 STREET 10018

TLDR

Unique bagel sandwiches w/ creative flavors like Oreo & pumpkin spice. A must-try for adventurous eaters!

Reddit Sentiment for BAGEL TO SANDWICH(based on 4 Reddit opinions)

25% Positive50% Neutral25% Negative

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

For a unique take on breakfast and lunch, this spot offers creative bagel sandwiches with unexpected flavors. While some found the plain bagel a bit underwhelming, the adventurous options like Oreo or pumpkin spice bagels are a definite draw for those seeking something different.

Food Overview

This establishment specializes in bagels and sandwiches, with a particular emphasis on unique and creative flavor combinations for their bagels, such as Oreo or pumpkin spice. While these adventurous options are a highlight, some feedback suggests that plainer bagels might be less flavorful.

Highlights / Recommended

"The 'Kiss My Haas' sandwich on a toasted everything bagel is a recommended item. Unique bagel flavors like Oreo and pumpkin spice are also noted."

Customer Sentiment

Customers appreciate the unique and creative bagel sandwich options, though some have found plainer bagels to be less exciting.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About BAGEL TO SANDWICH

This commenter highlighted the restaurant for its unique bagel flavors, specifically mentioning Oreo and pumpkin spice as interesting options.
A favorite sandwich from this restaurant, the 'Kiss My Haas' on a toasted everything bagel, was recommended.
Another user agreed, suggesting this place as an alternative when chocolate chip bagels were discussed.
A reviewer found the plain bagel bland and suggested opting for an everything bagel next time, but still considered it a solid bagel stop.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Chocolate Chip Bagel

"In response to a negative comment about chocolate chip bagels, this user also suggested Bagel to Sandwich."

Neutral
Jan 23, 2026View Comment →

From post: Chocolate Chip Bagel

"This commenter suggested Bagel to Sandwich in midtown as a place that offers unique bagel flavors, such as Oreo or pumpkin spice."

Neutral
Jan 23, 2026View Comment →

From post: What I Ate In Nyc

"The author found the plain bagel bland and wished they had ordered the everything bagel. Overall, it was a solid first stop for bagels."

Negative
Jan 19, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Vegetarian Sandwiches In Nyc

"The user's personal favorite is the "Kiss My Haas" sandwich on a toasted everything bagel from Bagel Hope on the UES."

Positive
Aug 19, 2025View Comment →

More in Midtown

See all