TLDR
Generous sushi portions, esp. omakase. Decent sushi rolls, but fish quality may vary. Reliable Japanese spot.
Reddit Sentiment for OISHI BAY SUSHI(based on 10 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Japanese restaurant offers a generous portion of sushi, particularly in its omakase meal. While the quantity is impressive for the price, customer feedback suggests a potential compromise on fish quality compared to traditional omakase experiences. The sushi rolls themselves, however, have received positive remarks.
Food Overview
The Japanese cuisine here features large portions, especially noticeable in their omakase meals. While the quantity is a significant draw, some diners feel the fish quality doesn't quite meet the expectations of a premium omakase experience. However, the sushi rolls are generally well-received and described as 'pretty good'.
Caveats
The term 'omakase' may not represent a high-end, traditional experience here; it seems to focus more on quantity and value. The quality of fish in the omakase has been questioned by some reviewers.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OISHI BAY SUSHI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"This commenter expressed satisfaction with Oishi Bay, describing it as not fancy but consistently reliable."
PositiveFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"The comment suggests that Oishi Bay's offering looks like a decent nigiri platter and that calling it 'omakase' allows them to sell premium items at a higher price point."
NeutralFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"Replying to a comment about the sushi roll, the author confirmed that the sushi roll itself was pretty good."
PositiveFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"This user commented on the thinness of the rice on the sushi roll, implying it was a positive attribute."
PositiveFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"The commenter states that there is no practical difference between 'Sushi Deluxe' and 'Omakase' at many places nowadays."
NeutralFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"This commenter questions if Oishi Bay, described as a Chinese-owned Japanese takeout spot, truly offers an authentic omakase experience, contrasting it with specialized omakase restaurants."
NeutralFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"This user agrees that the term 'omakase' has lost its meaning and now seems to refer to any sushi platter, as seen in the original post."
NeutralFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"This commenter reflects on the changing meaning of 'omakase' in NYC, suggesting it has shifted from a high-quality, seasonal meal to a more value-driven sushi offering."
NeutralFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"This comment draws an analogy between ordering omakase and soft pasta, emphasizing that it requires many factors to be perfect for the price. The author suggests reserving omakase for specialized restaurants, not typical sushi places where the focus is on standard offerings."
NeutralFrom post: Oishi Bay Murray Hillish
"The author reviewed an omakase meal from Oishi Bay, noting it provided a large quantity of food for the price but questioned the quality of the fish, feeling it was not up to par for an omakase experience."
Negative