Elevated New American in Red Hook. Flawless dishes, cozy vibes, and a standout chocolate cake.
Nestled in Red Hook, this elevated New American spot is hailed as the best opening since Hometown BBQ. Patrons rave about the flawless execution of dishes like the baguette, zucchini flowers, and chicken, with the chocolate cake being a standout dessert. The cozy, relaxing atmosphere makes for a truly enjoyable dining experience.
The cuisine is described as elevated New American with many dishes receiving high praise, including the baguette, zucchini flowers, chicken, and cod. The chocolate cake is a must-try dessert, and the cafe salad, though noted as an expensive appetizer, is also recommended. Some feedback suggests the restaurant can be pricey.
"The baguette, zucchini flowers, chicken, cod, and apricot tart are all described as flawless. The chocolate cake, ordered without usual sauces and with whipped cream on the side, is highly recommended, as is the soup."
Customers largely praise this restaurant, highlighting its flawless dishes and cozy atmosphere, though some have noted it as being on the pricier side.
Important Note
Some reviews indicate that the restaurant can be expensive, with appetizers like a salad priced at $18. One commenter had a negative overall experience.
"Responding to a question about eligibility for Michelin stars, this commenter confirmed that Cafe Kestrel is still eligible."
Neutral"Following a discussion about new additions to the Michelin Guide, the commenter questioned if Cafe Kestrel is still eligible for a star."
Neutral"This commenter believes Cafe Kestrel is at the Bib Gourmand level but is uncertain if it warrants a Michelin star."
Neutral"This commenter had a 'meh' experience at Cafe Kestrel."
Neutral"This is described as a small, elevated New American restaurant and the best opening in Red Hook since Hometown BBQ."
Positive"Cafe Kestrel was recommended as part of a general list of restaurants to try for the user looking for new dining experiences."
Positive"User haribobosses points to Cafe Kestrel's $18 cheapest appetizer (a salad) as another instance of the New York Times reviewing restaurants that are not affordable for most people."
Negative"The user was surprised by the number of restaurants on the list they had visited, specifically mentioning Cafe Kesteral as one of the worst offenders. They found the quality of these restaurants, including Cafe Kesteral, to be generally bad."
Negative"The user recently visited Cafe Kestrel in Red Hook, finding it very chill and delicious. They highly recommend it."
Positive"Recommends Cafe Kestrel in Red Hook, saying it's very worth the trip."
Positive
