Last Updated: 8 days ago
Phone: (718) 625-8052
Address: 379 COLUMBIA STREET 11231
Over 100 yrs of legendary, overstuffed Italian heroes. Unique 'hot salad' & classic charm.
Willa Moore reviews Defonte's, a century-old Italian sandwich shop in Brooklyn, praising its overstuffed sandwiches and classic charm. The article highlights the 'hot salad' and the popular fried eggplant.
A Brooklyn institution for over a century, this Italian sandwich shop is renowned for its generously portioned, classic heroes. Don't miss their unique 'hot salad' – a tangy, crunchy pickled vegetable mix that perfectly complements the rich fillings. With a cash-only policy and a charming atmosphere adorned with celebrity photos, it's a must-visit for authentic, overstuffed sandwiches.
This spot is celebrated for its massive Italian-American sandwiches, particularly those featuring fried eggplant and their signature 'hot salad.' While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive, one reviewer found the steak pizzaiola to be dry and tasteless.
"The 'Steak Pizzaiola' is frequently praised, as are the 'Prosciutto Special', 'Nicky's Special', 'Roast Pork Special', and the 'egg and potato' sandwich. The unique 'hot salad' topping is also highly recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality and generous portions of the sandwiches, often calling the establishment a must-visit and a timeless classic.
Important Note
The location in Red Hook can be a trek to get to, and the establishment is cash-only. Some customers have found certain dishes, like the steak pizzaiola, to be dry and tasteless, though this is a minority opinion.
"This user recommends Defontes for Italian-style hero sandwiches."
Positive"De Fonte is recommended for Italian subs/sandwiches."
Positive"This commenter wonders why Defonte's did not open another Manhattan location after their previous one closed due to construction."
Neutral"This commenter wonders why Defonte's did not open another Manhattan location after their previous one closed due to construction."
Neutral"This commenter states that Defonte's has picnic tables outside."
Neutral"This commenter states that Defonte's has picnic tables outside."
Neutral"This commenter recommends Defontes for sandwiches, suggesting eating them by the water in Red Hook as there is no seating."
Positive"This commenter recommends Defontes for sandwiches, suggesting eating them by the water in Red Hook as there is no seating."
Positive"This commenter mentions Defonte's but notes that seating is limited, suggesting eating elsewhere like a park."
Neutral"This commenter mentions Defonte's but notes that seating is limited, suggesting eating elsewhere like a park."
Neutral"This commenter lists Defonte's as a recommended sandwich spot."
Positive"This commenter lists Defonte's as a recommended sandwich spot."
Positive"Defonte's is listed as one of several New York establishments to consider."
Neutral"Defontes was recommended as a good daytime option in Red Hook for a food crawl."
Positive"The commenter suggests DeFonte's for a sandwich experience similar to Pisillo's."
Positive"This commenter simply suggests 'Defontes in Red Hook'."
Positive"User listed Defonte's among their recommendations for a meatball hero."
Neutral"User also recommends Defonte's in Red Hook for a meatball hero."
Neutral"The commenter clarified that the list is not a ranking but a survey of options, suggesting that while Defontes is known for certain items, it might not be their best sandwich."
Neutral"In response to the Defontes mention, this commenter advises adding the "hot salad" and getting a side of gravy."
Neutral
