Best burger in NYC? Maybe. Stellar vibe & food. Worth the trip.
Red Hook Tavern is a highly-regarded American restaurant in Brooklyn, known for its exceptional burger and lively atmosphere. While many praise it as the best burger in NYC, some find it to be too simple or peppery. The restaurant also offers other notable dishes like kale salad and French onion soup, though some reviews mention inconsistent service and long wait times. Despite some drawbacks, it's considered a worthwhile destination for burger enthusiasts.
The dry-aged burger is the star attraction, frequently described as the best in NYC, juicy, and perfectly cooked [1, 2, 3]. It's typically served with American cheese and raw onions cooked by the patty's heat, complemented by ruffled fries and a pickle [1, 2]. Other well-regarded dishes include the kale salad, French onion soup, and shrimp cocktail [4, 5]. However, some find the burger's pepper crust too strong or the overall flavor lacking [6, 7]. There are also mentions of mediocre fries [8] and some concern about value given the price [9].
"The dry-aged burger is consistently praised as a must-try, often called the best in NYC. Other recommended dishes include the kale salad and the French onion soup."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the burger, often calling it the best in NYC and a must-try. However, some negative feedback points to the burger being too peppery or simple, and there are mentions of long wait times and inconsistent service.
Important Note
Reservations can be difficult to secure, and wait times can be significant, especially on weekends. Some diners have reported negative customer service experiences.
"Considers the Red Hook Tavern burger to be heavenly. Notes it would have been their pick if it were open for lunch on Tuesdays."
Positive"This user states that the burger is the headline at Red Hook Tavern, but not the best thing they make."
Positive"Red Hook Tavern is suggested as the best place in the city for a burger, even over other popular options."
Positive"This establishment is recommended for a juicy burger, contrasting with the smash-style burgers at Au Cheval."
Positive"Commenter suggested Red Hook Tavern for an afternoon burger, followed by a visit to IKEA."
Positive"This commenter frequently thinks about the burger at Red Hook Tavern and considers it the only correct answer for the original poster's request."
Positive"This commenter states that the burger at Red Hook Tavern is incredible."
Positive"This commenter suggests Red Hook Tavern or Hearth for their variety burgers, noting that Red Hook Tavern is not open for lunch."
Positive"This commenter recommends Red Hook Tavern as their top choice for a burger and also suggests an off-menu burger at Corner Bar on Canal Street."
Positive"This commenter initially recommended Hawksmoor or Gramercy Tavern, noting Red Hook Tavern was not open for lunch but later acknowledged it is open Thursday-Sunday."
Positive"This is a recommended spot for an upscale burger and is open for lunch from Thursday to Sunday."
Positive"This commenter clarifies that Red Hook Tavern is open for lunch from Thursday to Sunday."
Positive"The commenter mentions the burger at Red Hook (or Lord's) as a potential choice for their last meal in NYC."
Positive"This user found Red Hook Tavern to be excellent, particularly praising their burger, which they called the best in NYC, and also enjoyed the cavatelli, romaine wedge, and French onion soup."
Positive"The user asked if the burger is as good as people say."
Neutral"The user asked if the burger lives up to its reputation."
Neutral"The user found the burger to look amazing and commented that Red Hook has some of the best spots in Brooklyn."
Positive"The user found the burger visually amazing and commented on Red Hook having excellent restaurants."
Positive"The user stated that the burger at Rag Trader is much better."
Negative"The user claimed the burger at Rag Trader is significantly better."
Negative
