Iconic dry-aged burger, exceptional American tavern fare, and a cozy Brooklyn vibe. A must-try for burger aficionados.
Red Hook Tavern is a Brooklyn-based American tavern celebrated for its exceptional dry-aged burger, often hailed as one of the best in NYC. While the burger is the star, the menu also features other comforting dishes and a well-curated drink selection. Despite its popularity and potential for long waits, many find the experience, including the ambiance and quality of food, to be well worth the visit.
The dry-aged burger is the undisputed star, consistently receiving rave reviews for its flavor and execution. Other notable dishes include French onion soup, wedge salad, and various tavern classics. While most feedback is positive, some reviews suggest that certain other dishes might not reach the same heights as the burger, and there are mixed opinions on value and consistency.
"The dry-aged burger is universally recommended and considered a must-try. Other highly praised items include the French onion soup, wedge salad, fish and chips, and prawns."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant's dry-aged burger, with many calling it the best they've ever had. While some find the experience and food exceptional, a few mention long waits and some criticism regarding specific dishes or service.
Important Note
Getting a table can be difficult, with potential for long wait times, especially on weekends. Some patrons have noted that while the burger is exceptional, other dishes or aspects of the experience may not always match the hype or price point. There are also some reports of inconsistent service.
"Red Hook Tavern was recommended for its burger."
Positive"While not the user's personal favorite, Red Hook Tavern's burger is generally considered good and more casual."
Neutral"The commenter dined alone at the bar of Red Hook Tavern on a Tuesday night, finding the experience splendid."
Positive"This user agrees with the original poster's assessment of Red Hook Tavern's burger and suggests it as a good option for those with similar taste preferences."
Negative"The original poster found the Red Hook burger too simple and the dry-aged meat flavorless, with the uncooked white onion making it worse."
Negative"This user suggested Red Hook Tavern, describing it as small but cozy with lots of wood."
Positive"This commenter considers Red Hook Tavern the top burger."
Positive"The commenter agreed that Red Hook Tavern is their favorite burger in town, praising its perfection."
Positive"The user found Red Hook Tavern's burger incredible but felt it was almost too buttery, which detracted slightly from it."
Positive"The commenter considers Red Hook Tavern a close second favorite burger, noting its dry-aged patty is outstanding."
Positive"The commenter listed Red Hook Tavern among their top 5 burgers."
Positive"The author declared Red Hook Tavern the best burger they had, rating it 10/10 for its unbelievable first bite, juicy patty, crisp bread, and onion pop, calling it perfection with no notes."
Positive"The author questioned grouping Five Guys and Red Hook Tavern in the same category, suggesting it's an unfair comparison for Korean cuisine."
Neutral"This user is adding to the mentions for Red Hook Tavern as a recommendation."
Positive"This user recommends Red Hook Tavern for their wedge salad, noting that while the bacon is a point of contention for some, they personally enjoy the generous portion of bacon on top."
Positive"This user also had a positive experience with the wedge salad at Red Hook Tavern."
Positive"Responding to a divorce joke, this commenter stated 'Nah I rebuke you' and offered a philosophical statement about love and hope."
Neutral"This commenter responded to the 'Tik Tok' remark by saying, 'Agsin with the tik tok. You sound like Andrew Cuomo.'"
Neutral"This commenter suggested getting a reservation at Red Hook Tavern."
Neutral"This commenter reiterated that waiting two hours in line with 'Tik Tok tourists' is a 'long walk off a short Pier'."
Negative
