Legendary dry-aged burger, praised as best in NYC; also known for top-notch French onion soup.
This Brooklyn tavern, with roots in the acclaimed Hometown BBQ, offers a cozy yet lively atmosphere perfect for a night out. It's particularly celebrated for its dry-aged burger, a dish that consistently receives rave reviews for its quality and flavor. Beyond the burger, the menu features comforting classics like a rich French onion soup and a well-executed pork chop.
Red Hook Tavern is renowned for its dry-aged burger, which many consider to be one of the best in NYC. Other highly recommended dishes include the French onion soup and the pork chop. While the burger is a standout, one reviewer found other dishes to be average. Reservations can be difficult to secure.
"The dry-aged burger is a universally acclaimed must-try. The French onion soup and pork chop are also highly recommended."
Customers largely have a very positive sentiment towards Red Hook Tavern, with many praising its burger as exceptional. Some reviews mention a lively atmosphere that can be a bit much for quiet conversation.
Important Note
Reservations can be very difficult to obtain, and some diners have noted that the restaurant can be crowded and noisy.
"This user prefers Red Hook Tavern's burger, calling it a must-try for cheeseburger lovers despite its $32 price tag."
Positive"The author states this tavern serves one of the best burgers in Brooklyn, possibly in the entire city."
Positive"It is noted that getting a reservation at Red Hook Tavern can be very difficult."
Negative"Red Hook Tavern is mentioned as a recommended spot."
Positive"Red Hook Tavern in Brooklyn is recommended for its burger."
Positive"Red Hook Tavern was suggested as a potential venue for the anniversary celebration, matching the desired atmosphere."
Neutral"The burger at Red Hook Tavern was listed as a dish that inspired a return visit."
Positive"This user finds Red Hook Tavern to be overrated."
Negative"This user describes Red Hook Tavern as a great place with special food and beer, enhancing the dining experience."
Positive"This user recently visited Red Hook Tavern and declared it their new top burger choice."
Positive"Red Hook Tavern is listed as a favorite, along with Minetta and Paul's."
Positive"Red Hook Tavern is the commenter's favorite burger spot."
Positive"This commenter advises skipping Red Hook Tavern for a burger, describing the patty as very pepper-crusted and the burger as simply bun, cheese, and meat, which they find not ideal."
Negative"Red Hook Tavern is recommended for a burger."
Neutral"Red Hook Tavern is suggested for its burger, although it's noted as being out of the way. Visiting is described as a fun day trip, potentially combined with brewery and barbecue spots."
Positive"This commenter advises skipping Red Hook Tavern for its burger, citing the strong pepper crust and simple composition."
Negative"Expresses fondness for Red Hook Tavern."
Positive"Includes Red Hook Tavern on a categorized list of restaurants."
Positive"Red Hook Tavern is recommended for an amazing burger as part of an evening in Red Hook."
Positive"Red Hook Tavern was suggested as a place with a good vibe."
Positive
