Brooklyn's go-to for a top-tier, dry-aged burger & classic tavern fare in a cozy, vintage setting.
Red Hook Tavern is a Brooklyn-based American tavern that has garnered significant attention for its exceptional dry-aged burger, often cited as one of the best in New York City. While the burger is the star, the menu also features other well-regarded dishes like French onion soup and fish and chips. The restaurant boasts a cozy, vintage atmosphere, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors.
The restaurant is most famous for its dry-aged burger, which many consider the best in NYC, featuring a juicy patty with American cheese and butter buns. Other highly recommended dishes include French onion soup, fish and chips, and a notable kale salad. Some negative feedback mentions a strong pepper crust on the burger and an instance of poor service with incorrect orders.
"The dry-aged burger is the most highly recommended dish, with many calling it the best in NYC. Other popular recommendations include the French onion soup, fish and chips, and the wedge salad."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Red Hook Tavern, particularly for its widely acclaimed dry-aged burger and cozy atmosphere, though some note difficulties with reservations and occasional service inconsistencies.
Important Note
Reservations can be difficult to secure, and some reviewers have noted issues with service or specific aspects of the burger's preparation, such as an overly peppery crust. The location in Red Hook can also be considered a bit out of the way for some.
"The author questioned grouping Five Guys and Red Hook Tavern in the same category, suggesting it's an unfair comparison for Korean cuisine."
Neutral"This user is adding to the mentions for Red Hook Tavern as a recommendation."
Positive"This user recommends Red Hook Tavern for their wedge salad, noting that while the bacon is a point of contention for some, they personally enjoy the generous portion of bacon on top."
Positive"This user also had a positive experience with the wedge salad at Red Hook Tavern."
Positive"Responding to a divorce joke, this commenter stated 'Nah I rebuke you' and offered a philosophical statement about love and hope."
Neutral"This commenter responded to the 'Tik Tok' remark by saying, 'Agsin with the tik tok. You sound like Andrew Cuomo.'"
Neutral"This commenter suggested getting a reservation at Red Hook Tavern."
Neutral"This commenter reiterated that waiting two hours in line with 'Tik Tok tourists' is a 'long walk off a short Pier'."
Negative"This commenter made a joke about divorcing the original poster's wife."
Neutral"The prawns at Red Hook Tavern are described as 'to die for'."
Positive"The bacon from the wedge salad at Red Hook Tavern was so appealing that the commenter felt compelled to order it."
Positive"The commenter identified Red Hook Tavern as their top choice for a "really good dry aged burger," highlighting it as a unique New York offering."
Positive"This commenter responded to a previous joke about divorce, stating 'I rebuke you'."
Neutral"This commenter made a joke about divorcing the wife due to the beef cooking preference for the burger at Red Hook Tavern."
Neutral"This user recommends Steve's Authentic in Red Hook for Key Lime Pie, suggesting it as a good dessert option after eating at nearby Red Hook Tavern or Hometown BBQ."
Positive"This commenter argued that Red Hook Tavern predates TikTok dominance and is a good neighborhood spot, advising to move on if a long wait is undesirable and suggesting reservations if available."
Positive"This commenter elaborated on 'huge effort' for Red Hook Tavern, citing the long travel to Red Hook, potential wait times of 1.5 hours or more, and calling the burger 'basic' while questioning the support of 'Tik Tok Traps'."
Negative"In response to a 'huge effort' comment, this person questioned the description and later defended Red Hook Tavern against 'Tik Tok trap' accusations, suggesting reservations if wait times are an issue."
Neutral"The pork chop at Red Hook Tavern is recommended as amazing, if available."
Positive"Oysters with pickle juice ice and fish and chips are recommended dishes at Red Hook Tavern."
Positive
