Next.js logo

MIA'S BROOKLYN BAKERY

Updated

Phone: (212) 933-1728

Address: 1573 3 AVENUE 10128

TLDR

Brooklyn's beloved bakery charm, now on the UES. Famous for its decadent Brooklyn Blackout cake & seasonal pies.

Reddit Sentiment for MIA'S BROOKLYN BAKERY(based on 3 Reddit opinions)

67% Positive33% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Neighborhoods

Upper East Side

Details

This Brooklyn-born bakery brings its celebrated sweets to Manhattan's Upper East Side, offering a delightful array of pastries and cakes. Known for its Brooklyn Blackout cake and seasonal pies, it's a go-to spot for dessert lovers seeking classic American baked goods with a touch of artisanal flair.

Food Overview

This bakery is celebrated for its classic American desserts, with the 'Brooklyn Blackout cake' being a highly recommended standout. They also offer seasonal pies, and a creme brulee with a distinct burnt top. While generally praised, one note mentions the creme brulee is not served warm, suggesting customers ask about warming possibilities.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Brooklyn Blackout cake is frequently highlighted as a must-try. The bakery also offers seasonal pies."

Customer Sentiment

Customers appreciate the bakery's popular cake offerings and seasonal pies. There's a mention of a creme brulee that, while delicious, isn't served warm, prompting a suggestion to inquire about warming options.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MIA'S BROOKLYN BAKERY

This comment highlights Mia's Bakery, a Brooklyn favorite now with a UES location, specifically recommending their standout Brooklyn Blackout cake as a must-try dessert for visitors to NYC.
A user mentions Mia's Brooklyn Bakery's creme brulee, noting its burnt top but that it is not served warm. They suggest inquiring about the possibility of it being warmed or if a fresh batch is available.
The UES location of Mia's is suggested as a good place to pick up pies, making it a convenient option for last-minute needs.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Anywhere I Can Pick Up A Pie Or Two Last Minute

"Mia's, specifically the UES location, is suggested as a place to get pies."

Positive
Nov 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where Can I Get Warm Creme Brulee

"The commenter suggested Mia's Brooklyn Bakery, mentioning they offer creme brulee with a burnt top, though it is not served warm. They also suggested asking the bakery if they would warm it up or if a fresh batch would be available."

Neutral
Sep 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: First Time Going To Nyc Food I Should Try Thats

"The commenter mentions Mia's Bakery, a popular cake bakery from Brooklyn with a UES presence, noting their Brooklyn Blackout cake as a standout item. This was suggested as a UES dessert option for visitors."

Positive
May 10, 2025View Comment →