Quintessential NYC bakery famous for its legendary black and white cookies [1], offering a dense yet light vanilla cake base topped with sweet frosting. Also known for sticky buns and a variety of other baked goods [1].
This Upper East Side bakery, a fixture since 1946, is celebrated for its iconic New York black and white cookies [1]. These cookies boast a perfectly balanced vanilla cake base, dense yet light, crowned with a smooth frosting. Beyond their signature cookie, they also serve the Amerikaner variation, along with a tempting selection of crumb cakes, challah, rugelach, and strudel [1].
Renowned for its classic New York black and white cookies, described as having a dense yet light vanilla cake base and soft frosting [1]. Reviewers note the texture is more cake-like than crispy, with some comparing it to 'donettes' [2, 1]. Other highly recommended items include their addictive sticky buns, known as Schnecken [1], and rugelach [3]. A flourless chocolate cake and strawberry shortcake are also mentioned positively [4, 5].
"The establishment is most famous for its black and white cookies, which are lauded for their soft, chewy, cake-like texture [1, 2]. Other highly recommended items include their addictive sticky buns (Schnecken) [1] and rugelach [3]."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the black and white cookies, with many calling them the best they've ever had and noting their unique cake-like texture [1, 2]. The sticky buns (Schnecken) also receive specific commendation [1].
Important Note
One user expressed doubt about the freshness of black and white cookies after a week [1]. While the Hudson Yards location was mentioned, it has since been confirmed as closed [2].
"This user suggested that William Greenberg Desserts would likely accommodate a request for individually wrapped mini cookies if called, noting their accommodating nature."
Neutral"In response to a query about individually wrapped mini cookies, this commenter suggested checking if Bloomingdales previously sold a tin from William Greenberg Desserts containing such items and recommended calling the store for confirmation."
Neutral"This user inquired if the mini cookies from William Greenberg Desserts are individually wrapped, as they wanted to provide more than one per person."
Neutral"This commenter suggested William Greenberg Desserts for individually wrapped black and white cookies, mentioning they also offer gift boxes of full-size or mini cookies. The cookies reportedly stay fresh for up to 5 days at room temperature or 8 days refrigerated."
Positive"This commenter mentioned Meredith's Bakery at various farmers markets offers individually wrapped cookies and suggested William Greenberg Desserts as a preferred option, though unsure if they offer individually wrapped ones."
Neutral"A user expressed doubt about the freshness of black and white cookies from William Greenberg Bakery after a week."
Negative"A user recommended mini black and white cookies from William Greenberg Bakery as a treat to bring to a West Coast office."
Neutral"The original poster is considering various options for their first beef experience, including burgers and sandwiches, while deliberately excluding steak."
Neutral"This commenter stated that William Greenberg Desserts has chocolate pecan pies."
Positive"The user recommended William Greenberg's for its flourless chocolate cake."
Positive"This establishment is suggested as a place to check for caramel cake."
Neutral"Asks for recommendations on where to find a great Black and White cookie, mentioning Greenberg Bakery as a place to try."
Neutral"Recommends Greenberg Bakery for its Black and White cookies."
Positive"Provided the location of William Greenberg Desserts on the Upper West Side and Upper East Side in Manhattan."
Neutral"William Greenberg Desserts is a place to check for rainbow cookies."
Neutral"The user provided a link to W.M. Greenberg Desserts for seven layer cake."
Neutral"This user suggested William Greenberg Desserts as a likely place to find a good cheesecake brownie, noting that such items might be on a rotating menu and not necessarily a seasonal offering."
Positive"The commenter suggested William Greenberg Desserts as a place to find gingerbread people."
Positive"The original poster thanked the user for the recommendation of William Greenberg Desserts."
Positive"The user recommended William Greenberg Desserts as a place that sells premade gingerbread houses."
Positive
