TLDR
Renowned UES institution famous for its quintessential NYC black and white cookies and nostalgic American-Jewish baked goods.
Reddit Sentiment for WILLIAM GREENBERG JR DESSERTS(based on 34 Reddit opinions)
Details
A staple of the New York bakery scene since 1946, this shop is widely considered the gold standard for quintessential black and white cookies [1], [2]. Beyond its famous cookies, the bakery offers a nostalgic array of American and Jewish treats, including rich flourless chocolate cake, seven-layer cake, and seasonal specialties like gingerbread [1], [2], [3]. Patrons frequent this institution for its consistently high-quality desserts and enduring classic appeal [4], [5].
Food Overview
The bakery specializes in a wide variety of classic American and Jewish desserts, with its black and white cookie serving as the standout item [1], [2]. These cookies are noted for having a dense, vanilla cake-like base and a soft frosting, though the texture can vary based on production [1], [3], [6]. Other popular items include flourless chocolate cake, rainbow cookies, crumb cakes, and seasonal favorites like gingerbread people and chocolate pecan pies [1], [2], [3].
The black and white cookies are the most frequently recommended signature item [2], [4], [5]. Additionally, the flourless chocolate cake and rainbow cookies are highly regarded by frequent visitors [3], [6], [7].
Customers generally view this bakery as a timeless and highly reliable destination for high-quality, classic desserts [4], [5]. While the quality is widely celebrated, some debate exists regarding the ideal texture of the cookies, with some patrons preferring a crunchier bite than what is typically provided [3], [6].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01black and white cookie5 mentions
- 02black and white cookies3 mentions
- 03black & white cookies2 mentions
- 04chocolate cake2 mentions
- 05flourless chocolate cake2 mentions
Caveats
Some users have expressed concern regarding the freshness of the cookies if stored for an extended period, and the texture of the black and white cookies is not consistently perceived as crunchy [3], [6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About WILLIAM GREENBERG JR DESSERTS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"The user dislikes this location specifically on the West Side because the cookies are shrink-wrapped."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"The commenter advises that the east side location is superior to the west side location for their cookies."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"The user recommends sticking to the original black and white cookies rather than holiday variations at this location."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"A simple recommendation of the bakery."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Black White Cookie In Nyc
"The commenter suggests William Greenberg as a top choice for black and white cookies."
Positive