Last Updated: 15 days ago
Phone: (212) 861-1340
Address: 1100 MADISON AVENUE 10028
Iconic UES bakery, famed for its legendary Black and White cookies. A true taste of NYC tradition.
For a taste of old-school New York, this bakery has been a neighborhood staple since 1946. They are particularly renowned for their classic Black and White cookies, which many consider to be among the city's best. Beyond cookies, they also offer a selection of other baked goods and desserts perfect for any occasion.
The star of the show is undoubtedly the Black and White cookie, frequently described as soft, chewy, and among the city's best. Customers also mention a great chocolate cake and sticky buns (Schnecken) as notable items. While the Black and White cookies are highly recommended, one user noted they weren't particularly crunchy, and another found them good but not outstanding compared to their reputation.
"The Black and White cookie is the standout recommendation, frequently lauded for its soft, chewy texture and classic flavor. Sticky buns (Schnecken) and chocolate cake are also mentioned as delicious options."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the bakery, with many highlighting the Black and White cookies as exceptional and a must-try. It's consistently recommended as a classic New York dessert spot.
Important Note
One user mentioned that a Hudson Yards location was closed, so it's best to visit the original Madison Avenue spot. Another user found the black and white cookie to be good but not as exceptional as its reputation might suggest, and noted it wasn't particularly crunchy.
"The original poster thanked the user for the recommendation of William Greenberg Desserts."
Positive"The user recommended William Greenberg Desserts as a place that sells premade gingerbread houses."
Positive"Regarding black and white cookies, this commenter states they are not crispy at all."
Negative"William Greensburg is a few blocks away from Levain and is known for their black and white cookie, though it's not described as crunchy."
Positive"This is a very old-school UES establishment, famous for its strawberry shortcake, which has been a family favorite for decades."
Positive"This comment simply states that William Greenberg Desserts is the place to go."
Positive"This user believes William Greenberg is only on the UES, and suggests Orwasher's might be the place the other user is thinking of, as it has locations on both UES and UWS."
Neutral"This user states Glasers was their favorite black and white cookie place but it closed years ago, and considers William Greenberg Desserts the second favorite."
Positive"This user confirmed that the Hudson Yards location of William Greenberg Desserts is closed."
Negative"This user agrees with recommendations for William Greenberg and Orwashers, and mentions their local deli's cookies were a favorite."
Positive"Following up on a mention of William Greenberg in Hudson Yards, this user recommends the original location on Madison Ave."
Neutral"A user mentions a William Greenberg in Hudson Yards is delicious. Another user recommends going to the original location on Madison Ave."
Positive"This user states that they have not found any black and white cookies that compare to William Greenberg's, calling them in a league of their own."
Positive"This user recommends William Greenberg Desserts, along with Orwashers, Zaro's (if fresh), and Caputo's in Brooklyn for black and white cookies."
Positive"The original poster is seeking confirmation for William Greenberg Desserts, considering buying a large quantity before traveling."
Positive"The user likes William Greenberg Desserts and suggests trying their rugelach as well."
Positive"The user confirmed that the B/W cookie's texture and flavor are cake-like, explaining that the classic recipe uses yellow cake batter baked directly on the sheet."
Positive"The user found the B/W cookie to have an unexpected texture and flavor, comparing it to cake and describing it as very good."
Positive"This commenter recalls Wm. Greenberg's making a simple yet killer chocolate cake and considers it a platonic ideal, though unsure if they still offer it or at what price."
Positive"The user recommended William Greenberg."
Positive
