Stunning ambiance & amazing Italian fare. Incredible fettuccine & a pistachio gelato tower that's out of this world!
Nestled within The Surrey Hotel on the Upper East Side, this Italian restaurant offers a stunning ambiance and an overall amazing experience. The meal begins with a delightful bread basket, followed by appetizers like burrata with sungold tomatoes and a delicious chicken salad. Standout main courses include an incredible fettuccine with mushrooms and truffle, as well as other delicious pasta options like pappardelle bolognese and cacio e pepe. The meal is crowned with a magnificent pistachio gelato tower, a dessert so good it's worth a return visit.
The Italian cuisine here features standout pasta dishes, particularly the fettuccine with mushrooms and truffle, which is highly recommended. Other popular options include burrata with roasted tomatoes, chicken salad, pappardelle bolognese, and cacio e pepe. The pistachio gelato tower is frequently cited as a must-try dessert. However, some diners find the food to be unremarkable, suggesting it's more of a scene-focused establishment.
"The fettuccine with mixed mushrooms, black truffle, parmesan, and fondue is highly recommended, with some calling it the favorite pasta dish. The pistachio gelato tower is also a standout dessert, described as magnificent and worth returning for."
While the ambiance and specific dishes like the fettuccine and pistachio gelato receive high praise, some feedback suggests the food is only moderately good and the restaurant is more about the scene.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that the food may be unremarkable and the establishment is more focused on its ambiance and scene rather than culinary excellence. It's also noted as a mediocre offshoot of its Miami location.
"Casa Tua on the Upper East Side offers a daily risotto special, which sometimes includes truffle."
Positive"This user states Casa Tua has significantly worse food than Le Rock, with its scene offering little else, and notes it's a mediocre offshoot of the Miami location."
Negative"Describing Casa Tua as having only moderately okay food and being mostly about the scene, this user recommends Le Rock instead."
Negative"This commenter found Casa Tua to be unremarkable and primarily a scene for a wealthy crowd, suggesting Le Rock is better."
Negative
