Next.js logo

YE OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW

Updated

Phone: (716) 208-5003

Address: 1664 3 AVENUE 10128

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Philly cheesesteaks & Lionshead beer on tap—a true PA experience. Often ranked as a top choice for cheesesteaks in the city.

Reddit Sentiment for YE OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW(based on 8 Reddit opinions)

88% Positive13% Neutral

Neighborhoods

Upper East Side

Details

This Manhattan eatery offers a taste of authentic Philadelphia cheesesteaks, complete with classic toppings and a genuine PA experience. Patrons can enjoy Lionshead beer on tap, adding to the city's charm. For those seeking a top-tier cheesesteak, this spot is frequently cited as a prime choice, often compared favorably to other well-regarded establishments.

Food Overview

The restaurant is highly recommended for its cheesesteaks, with many patrons considering it a top choice. It also offers Old Bay fries and Lionshead beer on tap, contributing to an authentic Pennsylvania experience. Some reviewers, however, prefer other cheesesteak spots in the city.

Highlights / Recommended

Customers frequently recommend the cheesesteaks, with many considering it a top choice. The Old Bay fries are also a noteworthy mention.

Customer Sentiment

Customers frequently recommend this spot for its authentic cheesesteaks and the availability of Lionshead beer, contributing to a genuine Pennsylvania experience. While highly praised, some find other establishments to be superior.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About YE OLDE CITY CHEESESTEAKS & BREW

cheese steaks
This post highlights multiple recommendations for cheesesteaks in the city, with 'Olde City' on Madison Ave being frequently mentioned as a top choice. Another commenter notes the availability of Lionshead beer on tap, enhancing the authentic PA experience.
cheese steaks
The discussion includes 'Olde City' as a decent option for cheesesteaks, alongside Wogie's in the West Village. This comment positions Olde City as a strong contender in the city's cheesesteak scene.
cheese steaks
A commenter emphatically states that 'Olde City' is their preferred choice for cheesesteaks, indicating a high level of satisfaction. This suggests a strong positive sentiment from at least one regular patron.
cheese steaks
This thread mentions 'Olde City' as one of the top two cheesesteak choices, alongside Federoff's. This ranking places it among the elite options for cheesesteak enthusiasts.
cheese steaks
The commenter notes that the founder of Shorty's now runs 'Olde City,' and mentions the availability of Old Bay fries. This detail adds an interesting layer to the restaurant's history and menu.
cheese steaks
This comment finds 'Olde City' to be a decent cheesesteak option, though they personally prefer Danny & Coop's and Mama's Too. It provides a comparative perspective on the restaurant's offerings.
cheese steaks
This comment suggests 'Olde City' in Chelsea as a good spot to watch Sixers games, in addition to being a place for cheesesteaks. This highlights a potential dual appeal for sports fans and foodies.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Cheese Steaks

"This commenter recommended Olde City in Chelsea, mentioning it's a good place to watch Sixers games."

Positive
Apr 9, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cheese Steaks

"This commenter listed Federoff's and Olde City as their #1 and #2 choices for cheesesteaks."

Positive
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cheese Steaks

"This commenter stated that the founder of Shorty's now runs Olde City, which is good and offers Old Bay fries."

Positive
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cheese Steaks

"This commenter emphatically stated that Olde City is their top choice for cheesesteaks."

Positive
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Cheese Steaks

"The commenter found Olde City decent but preferred Danny & Coop's and Mama's Too for cheesesteaks."

Neutral
Apr 8, 2026View Comment →

More in Upper East Side

See all