TLDR
Authentic NYC-style slices that are good enough for a 'last meal' bucket list. A must-visit spot for pizza enthusiasts craving a perfect, classic slice.
Instagram Posts References
This establishment will offer New York style pizza and is slated to open soon.
Lucia New York is an upcoming NY-style pizza restaurant on the Upper West Side.
Details
A go-to destination for high-quality New York style pizza that leaves a lasting impression on locals [1]. This establishment is so highly regarded that it has been cited as a top contender for a final, perfect meal in the city [1]. With a focus on authentic techniques, the pizzeria continues to build its reputation across Manhattan [2].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic New York style pizza, with the marinara slice earning specific praise for its flavorful garlic base and fresh basil garnish [1], [3]. Customers looking for dairy-free options have found success here by ordering a cheeseless marinara base, often opting to skip extra toppings like parmesan and olive oil [2], [3].
Highlights / Recommended
"The classic marinara slice is highly recommended, noted for its generous garlic profile and fresh basil finish [3]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •spinach slice(2)
Caveats
For those seeking a cheeseless pizza, it is recommended to specifically request a marinara base and clarify preference regarding additional oil or cheese toppings [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About LUCIA OF THE UPPER EASTSIDE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Cheeseless But Not Necessarily
"This user specifically recommends the marinara slice at Lucia's, noting it has a lot of garlic and is typically finished with fresh basil. They also mention skipping the optional fresh grated parmesan and olive oil drizzle."
PositiveFrom post: Best Cheeseless But Not Necessarily
"This user suggested Lucia's of Ave X for a marinara base with added toppings as a cheeseless option."
NeutralFrom post: Best Cheeseless But Not Necessarily
"This user suggested Lucia UES as a place that might be able to accommodate a cheeseless pizza request."
NeutralFrom post: Where Would You Go As Your Last Meal In Nyc
"For lunch as part of a hypothetical 'day of last meals,' the commenter would get a slice from Lucia Pizza (or Johnny's) and eat it on Canal and 6th."
Positive