Authentic Italian market & food hall with rave-worthy prosciutto, prime rib sandwiches, pasta, pizza, cannoli & tiramisu. A must-visit for Italian food lovers!
This Italian market and food hall offers a wide array of authentic Italian dishes and products. Customers rave about the quality of the meats and cheeses, especially the prosciutto. For those seeking a meal, the prime rib sandwich and various pasta dishes are highly recommended, alongside delectable pizza slices. Don't forget to indulge in their renowned cannoli and tiramisu for dessert.
This Italian market and food hall offers a diverse range of authentic Italian cuisine. Highly recommended items include prosciutto, various cheeses, prime rib sandwiches, pasta dishes, pizza slices with fresh mozzarella, and desserts such as cannoli and tiramisu. Customers also enjoy seasonal options like squash ravioli and appreciate the quality of crudi and branzino.
"Customers highly recommend the prime rib sandwich, various pasta dishes, pizza slices with fresh mozzarella, and traditional Italian desserts like cannoli and tiramisu. The prosciutto and cheeses are also frequently praised."
Customers express strong satisfaction with the food, particularly highlighting the quality of Italian meats, cheeses, and classic desserts like cannoli and tiramisu. The prime rib sandwich and pasta dishes are also frequently praised.
Important Note
Some users note that while the cold cuts and cheeses are excellent, they can be pricey. It's also mentioned that the establishment can get crowded.
"Eataly was listed as one of the good food hall options."
Positive"The user recommended "hot chocolate"."
Positive"The user typically buys pastry bites and coffee, occasionally a panini or gelato, finding everything to be high quality and suggesting getting what you like."
Positive"The user simply recommended "Branzino"."
Positive"The user was considering Eataly for a cannoli and confirmed it was an option that filled them to order."
Positive"The user agrees that Eataly's cold cuts and cheeses are excellent, though pricey. They also praise the Prime Rib sandwiches and the sandwich counter in general, suggesting a picnic with these items."
Positive"The user mentioned Eataly as a good option for cannolis."
Positive"The user, who used to work at the cheese/meat counter, highly recommends the prosciutto and cheeses, suggesting asking for samples."
Positive"The user recommends getting slices of pizza with fresh mozzarella, describing them as delectable."
Positive"The user simply stated "Tiramisu" as a recommendation."
Positive"The user stated they like Eataly's crudi."
Positive"The user mentions enjoying a seasonal squash ravioli in the fall and finds Eataly good for trying seasonal items."
Positive"The user used to get a cornetto alla crema on their way to work, finding the amount of custard impressive and delicious."
Positive"The user recommends the prime rib sandwich and cannoli dessert, also stating that the pastas are good."
Positive"The user enjoys the cremespresso and suggests getting familiar Italian items or trying something new, noting Eataly is a grocery store with attached restaurants rather than a specialty shop."
Neutral"Eataly is mentioned as having fast service but can be crowded. It's also noted that on nice days, one can take their lunch to the outdoor seating area in Madison Square Park."
Neutral"Eataly reportedly has good chocolate chip cookies, but they are not served warm and do not contain salt."
Positive"Eataly is suggested as a place to go, with another user agreeing."
Neutral
