TLDR
Michelin-starred modern Indian fine dining in Hudson Yards. Featuring nine-course tasting menus with meat, veg, and vegan options.
Reddit Sentiment for INDIENNE NYC, ELDER, APAS BAR(based on 44 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Indienne is the 2nd restaurant on the list, noted as the first Indian tasting menu experience the author has had and was blown away by the quality. The reviewer highly recommends trying both the veg and non-veg menus to experience everything. It's also mentioned that the original Chicago location has a Michelin star.
Indienne, a highly acclaimed Indian fine-dining establishment from Chicago, has opened its doors in New York City, specifically in the luxury residential tower Henry Hall in Hudson Yards. The restaurant is led by Chef Sujan Sarkar, a recipient of the Wine Spectator Award of Excellence. Indienne offers a sophisticated tasting menu experience focused on refined Indian cuisine, complemented by an impressive wine program designed to enhance the culinary offerings.
Indienne NYC is presented as a Michelin-starred Indian restaurant, recognized as the number one rated Indian restaurant in the country and one of only four Indian restaurants in the US with a Michelin Star. Originally from Chicago, it recently opened its New York location in Hudson Yards, Manhattan, becoming one of the year's most anticipated new openings. The reviewer praises the entire menu as excellent, specifically highlighting the egg curry with caviar and the Katli dessert as favorite dishes, giving the restaurant a high rating of 9.6 on the Beli app.
Chef Sujan Sarkar brings his Michelin-starred Indian fine dining experience from Chicago to New York with the opening of Indienne in Hudson Yards, offering an elevated take on the cuisines of India.
Details
Helmed by Michelin-starred chef Sujan Sarkar, this establishment brings an elevated, modern take on Indian fine dining to Manhattan's Hudson Yards [1], [2]. Guests can choose from three distinct nine-course tasting menus—meat, vegetarian, or vegan—that showcase inventive, globally-inspired culinary techniques [1], [2]. The restaurant's artistic, multi-room space provides a sophisticated setting for its highly anticipated arrival in the New York dining scene [1], [3].
Food Overview
The menu offers a modern, fine-dining approach to traditional Indian flavors, featuring standout dishes like chicken makhani, egg curry with caviar, and naan [4], [5]. While many diners laud the creative, artistic plating, some critics feel certain dishes, such as the use of chicken breast or specific vegetarian options like dhokla, do not quite meet the high expectations set by the fine-dining price point [4], [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"The chicken makhani, egg curry with caviar, and naan are frequently cited as standout favorites [4], [5]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chicken makhani(3)
- •naan(3)
- •egg curry(3)
- •lobster(3)
- •butter chicken(2)
Customer Sentiment
Feedback is largely positive, with guests praising the artistic, high-quality tasting menus and unique culinary perspective [1], [4]. Some patrons have expressed skepticism regarding portion sizes and the performative nature of the presentation, though many report leaving full and satisfied [4], [5].
Caveats
Some diners have found the food presentation to be overly performative or pretentious, and there is ongoing debate regarding whether the portion sizes justify the cost [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About INDIENNE NYC, ELDER, APAS BAR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"Inquiring if the restaurant offers vegetarian menus and wine pairings."
NeutralFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"The user finds the use of chicken breast in the butter chicken offensive and overly pretentious given the price point."
NegativeFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"A brief positive remark about the meal."
PositiveFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"The user enjoyed the meal overall, but found the chicken dish gimmicky and disliked the texture of the reconstituted chicken breast."
NeutralFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"A positive review noting consistent quality across different locations."
PositiveFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"The user really enjoyed the butter chicken, egg curry, and cashew katli, but did not care for the yogurt chaat."
PositiveFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"The user praises the Chicken Makhani, noting it is typically a dish they avoid for being basic, but Indienne did a great job."
PositiveFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"Clarifying that the restaurant rotates its courses, noting that scallop was served in May where lobster was served later."
NeutralFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"A user with a lobster allergy is seeking advice on how to handle potential ingredient substitutions for their upcoming reservation."
NeutralFrom post: Indienne Indian Tasting Menu In Hudson Yards From
"The author praises Indienne as having some of the best dishes they have ever eaten, specifically highlighting the chicken makhani, egg curry, and lobster."
PositiveFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user mentions having a positive experience at Musaafer, an Indian restaurant with two Michelin stars."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user is following up on a previous comment about portion sizes at Indienne, noting that while the food looks good, the naan portion seems small. They are waiting for a report from another user."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user is planning to visit Indienne soon and will provide a report on their experience."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user is expressing doubt about the portion sizes at Indienne, despite the original poster claiming to have left full. They are awaiting a report from another user who plans to visit."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user is defending the original poster against doubts about their claim of leaving full, stating they wouldn't lie about it and will report back after their own visit."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user is responding to a question about the original poster potentially lying about leaving full, stating it's unlikely."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user humorously states they might eat the plate because the first dish resembled a cake."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user is asking for clarification about the third dish presented."
NeutralFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user expresses surprise and mild disappointment about seeing dhokla in a fine dining context."
NegativeFrom post: Opening Night Of Indienne In Nyc 1 Indian Tasting
"This user contrasts Indienne with other restaurants, appreciating Semma for serving authentic Indian food rather than French fine dining with Indian influences."
Negative