A bustling Theater District bistro known for its speedy pre-theater meals and classic American fare [1]. Don't miss the thick burger and famously good banana cream pie [3].
Ciera Velarde reviews Joe Allen, a Theater District bistro known for its pre-theater meals, praising its burger and martinis.
Joe Allen has been a Theater District fixture since 1965, renowned for its efficient pre-theater dining and lively atmosphere [1]. This classic American bistro offers a menu of familiar favorites, with standouts including a thick, customizable burger with crispy shoestring fries and generously portioned martinis served with a sidecar [1, 2]. While the shrimp cocktail is advised against, the banana cream pie is an absolute must-save-room-for dessert [2, 3]. The restaurant's charm is further enhanced by its walls adorned with old Broadway flop posters, creating a unique ambiance for theater enthusiasts and diners alike [1].
Joe Allen serves classic American cuisine with a focus on dishes popular with theatergoers. The Joe Allen Burger, described as thick and satisfying with accompanying crispy shoestring fries, is a frequently recommended item [1, 2]. Similarly, the banana cream pie is highlighted as an epic dessert that is a must-try [2, 3]. While the martinis are also praised for their generous portioning and unique sidecar serving style, the shrimp cocktail is noted as a dish to potentially skip [1, 2]. Other menu staples include Caesar salad and steak frites [1].
"The Joe Allen Burger is a must-try, celebrated for its thick patty and accompanying shoestring fries. For dessert, the banana cream pie is described as epic and not to be missed."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Joe Allen, appreciating its lively atmosphere and family-friendly vibe, particularly its connection to the theater community [1, 4]. The food receives praise, with specific mentions of the burger and banana cream pie being highly recommended.
Important Note
While the restaurant is known for efficient pre-theater service, making reservations is recommended, especially for groups [1]. One reviewer suggests skipping the shrimp cocktail.
"The commenter suggested Joe Allen, noting that people talk about theater there, giving it a lively and friendly feel. They also mentioned it has a very good burger at a reasonable price."
Positive"This user suggests Joe Allen as a pre-show dining option."
Positive"Joe Allen is suggested as a dining option near the theater."
Neutral"The commenter suggests having a steak at Keens and a banana cream pie at Joe Allen."
Neutral"Joe Allen's banana cream pie is specifically recommended."
Positive"A commenter suggested Jo as a possible omakase option, noting its price of exactly $300 per person."
Neutral"Joe Allen was simply mentioned as a suggestion for a pre-Broadway lunch."
Neutral"Joe Allen was suggested as a restaurant option, with a recommendation to make reservations."
Neutral
