TLDR
An iconic, long-standing NYC institution offering a perfect balance of elevated seasonal American cuisine and refined, approachable service. Famous for its exceptional tavern-side burger and a warm, reliable atmosphere that makes every visit feel like a special occasion.
Reddit Sentiment for GRAMERCY TAVERN(based on 440 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Gramercy Tavern serves an upscale tavern burger accompanied by potato chips and smoked-onion aioli, highlighting its status as one of NYC's best-known restaurants.
Gramercy Tavern offers a chocolate chunk cookie that comes with a delightful side of malted chocolate milk. The cookie is known for its gooey center with visible pools of melted chocolate.
Gramercy Tavern's burger, specifically available at The Tavern section of the restaurant, is described as juicy. Adding bacon strips is a recommended topping.
The author details a spontaneous solo lunch at Gramercy Tavern that turned into one of their most memorable dining experiences in New York City. The experience was characterized by exceptional hospitality, from the initial warm welcome to the thoughtful explanations from the server and the sommelier's impressive knowledge. The sommelier's ability to cater to the author's preferences and budget without making them feel intimidated was particularly highlighted. While the food was outstanding, the genuine commitment of every team member to create a comfortable and memorable experience was what truly stood out, defining the essence of true hospitality: gracious, professional, and sincere.
This restaurant is recommended for celebrating a 20th anniversary, indicating a special occasion venue. The image suggests an upscale dining experience, with people holding wine glasses and a romantic ambiance with a candle.
Gramercy Tavern, a well-known New York City establishment, is highlighted for its 'Tavern Burger,' crafted by chefs Mike Anthony and Areta Hettarh, as one of the notable burgers experienced recently.
The post describes a delightful and highly positive experience at Gramercy Tavern, an 'iconic NYC culinary institution' co-founded by Chef Mike Anthony and Danny Meyer. The reviewer enjoyed dining outdoors on a 'lovely Manhattan night' and praised the 'stellar' service and hospitality. The restaurant is noted for holding 'one Michelin star'.
Gramercy Tavern is a quintessential New York City dining experience, offering both a special occasion dining room and a more casual, yet excellent, tavern space.
Gramercy Tavern, a long-standing New York City institution, continues to impress with its dual dining experiences. From its à la carte tavern to its elegant back dining room tasting menu, it offers a classic New York dining experience.
Details
A long-standing New York City institution, this destination offers two distinct experiences: a casual, lively tavern section for à la carte dining and a refined, white-tablecloth dining room focused on a formal tasting menu [1]. The restaurant is widely recognized for its consistent, high-quality New American cuisine and warm, professional hospitality [2]. Its ability to cater seamlessly to both intimate special occasions and casual business lunches has solidified its status as an iconic staple of the city's dining scene [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on elevated, seasonal New American cuisine, with the tavern section serving favorites like a renowned burger, roasted oysters, and seasonal vegetable dishes [1], [4]. Guests frequently highlight the exceptional desserts, particularly the sundaes and chocolate chunk cookies, while the dining room offers sophisticated tasting menus featuring ingredients like Arctic char and roasted duck [2], [3].
Highlights / Recommended
Mentioned Dishes:
- •burger(48)Widely considered one of the best burgers, reviewers praise its juiciness, flavo...
- •chocolate chip cookie(12)Highly recommended and described as one of the city's finest desserts, this cook...
- •desserts(7)Reviewers consistently describe the desserts as amazing and memorable, with spec...
- •tasting menu(5)The tasting menu is frequently praised as a great, luxurious option, with one re...
- •mango upside down cake(5)Described as wildly delicious and bomb, these upside-down cakes are highlighted ...
- •chicken(5)Described as consistently good, with one reviewer calling it the best chicken th...
- •passion fruit sundae(5)Ranked as a top dessert and a consistently favorite option, with one reviewer hi...
- •brick chicken(3)
- •chicken liver mousse(3)
- •broccolini salad(3)
- •beef carpaccio(3)
- •beignets(3)
- •lumache(3)
- •braised beef sandwich(3)
- •grilled oysters(3)
- •chocolate flan(3)
- •cavatelli(2)
- •lemon cake(2)
- •seasonal soup(2)
- •pan-seared halibut(2)
- •lamb(2)
- •flat bread(2)
- •pasta(2)
- •food(2)
- •hanger steak(2)
- •cocktails(2)
- •ravioli(2)
- •bok choy(2)
Customer Sentiment
Diners consistently praise the restaurant for its exceptional, non-stuffy hospitality and reliable excellence, making it a top recommendation for celebrations and business meals [1], [2]. While the overwhelming majority of feedback is positive, a small minority has occasionally noted inconsistencies in food execution or found the pricing higher than desired [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GRAMERCY TAVERN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Michelin Star Option Worth It For Both The
"A meat-eater praises the vegetarian menu as outstanding."
PositiveFrom post: Michelin Star Option Worth It For Both The
"Notes that the restaurant is very accommodating and currently offers intriguing vegetarian options on their prix-fixe menu."
PositiveFrom post: Manhattan Restaurant That Is Worth The Money And
"Suggested to check for late reservation availability or call directly."
PositiveFrom post: Gramercy Tavern Lunch In The Tavern Great Burger
"The dining room Restaurant Week menu was underwhelming, but the desserts were excellent and there is interest in returning for the burger."
NeutralFrom post: Gramercy Tavern Lunch In The Tavern Great Burger
"The user frequently visits for post-race meals and notes the staff tracks their patronage."
PositiveFrom post: Gramercy Tavern Lunch In The Tavern Great Burger
"Service was great, but the burger was just okay, while the desserts were excellent."
NeutralFrom post: Gramercy Tavern Lunch In The Tavern Great Burger
"The commenter specifically highlights the amazing desserts."
PositiveFrom post: Gramercy Tavern Lunch In The Tavern Great Burger
"The commenter notes the restaurant maintains an atmosphere that feels like stepping back into 2006."
PositiveFrom post: Gramercy Tavern Lunch In The Tavern Great Burger
"The burger is highly recommended and service is praised."
PositiveFrom post: Gramercy Tavern Lunch In The Tavern Great Burger
"The commenter expresses appreciation for the restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Restaurant Week Where Have You Gone And Was It
"The user finds everything there great, especially the desserts."
PositiveFrom post: New York Food Adventures During The World Cup
"A significant disappointment compared to previous visits due to execution issues and high cost."
NegativeFrom post: Recommendations For A Couple Of Country Folk
"Noted for its great vibe."
PositiveFrom post: Summer Food Highlights As An Intern A Wide Array
"The burger is phenomenal, though the user admits they are not a burger snob."
PositiveFrom post: In Honor Of National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day 84
"The commenter enjoyed the additional milk served with their cookie."
PositiveFrom post: In Honor Of National Chocolate Chip Cookie Day 84
"The author noted the cookie was served warm, giving it an unfair advantage, but rated it highly."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For A Couple Of Country Folk
"Recommended for a casual Michelin-star experience."
PositiveFrom post: Jojo By Jeangeorges Nyc Restaurant Week Review 82
"The commenter recommends the restaurant as an exception to general negativity toward Restaurant Week, noting it made them a loyal customer."
PositiveFrom post: Any Recommendations On What To Get At Gramercy
"The user lists four standouts from a recent meal."
PositiveFrom post: Any Recommendations On What To Get At Gramercy
"The user reinforces the recommendation for the lumache."
Positive