Iconic NYC dining w/ 1 Michelin star. Offers 2 experiences: upscale dining room & lively tavern. Seasonal American cuisine, known for hospitality.
Gramercy Tavern is a quintessential New York City dining experience, offering both a special occasion dining room and a more casual, yet excellent, tavern space.
Gramercy Tavern is a celebrated New York City institution that offers two distinct dining experiences: the formal dining room for special occasions and a lively tavern area for more casual dining. The menu features creative, seasonal American cuisine with approachable flavors and impeccable ingredients. It's a place that consistently delivers a memorable experience, making it a top choice for a wide range of diners and occasions.
Gramercy Tavern serves creative, seasonal New American cuisine. While many dishes receive high praise, including their famous burger, seasonal vegetables, and desserts like the passion fruit sundae and chocolate chip cookie, some diners have noted inconsistency, with occasional mentions of overly salty or bland dishes. The restaurant is also noted for its vegetarian-friendly options and use of fresh, seasonal produce.
"The Tavern Burger is frequently highlighted as exceptional, with many calling it one of the best they've ever had. Other recommended items include seasonal vegetable dishes, the passion fruit sundae, and the chocolate chip cookie."
Overall, customers have a highly positive sentiment towards Gramercy Tavern, frequently praising its excellent food, stellar service, and inviting ambiance, making it a reliable choice for special occasions and memorable meals.
Important Note
Some diners have reported inconsistency in food quality, with occasional mentions of dishes being too salty or bland. There are also differing opinions on whether the restaurant lives up to its hype and price point, with some finding it a bit too 'stuffy' compared to other establishments.
"This commenter considers Gramercy Tavern to be one of the best restaurants in NYC and a more reasonable alternative to Monkey Bar. They note it has maintained its Michelin star and is relatively easy to get a reservation."
Positive"The user recommended Gramercy Tavern when asked about places to eat fluke crudo."
Positive"This commenter advised against Gramercy Tavern, stating it was not good."
Negative"A commenter suggested Gramercy Tavern for a special anniversary dinner."
Neutral"This commenter recommends Gramercy Tavern as a non-Asian option in NYC for a great meal."
Positive"This commenter confirmed that Gramercy Tavern has one Michelin star and called it an excellent restaurant."
Positive"This commenter suggested Gramercy Tavern, noting it has a Michelin star."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern also has private rooms available, mentioned as a follow-up to a suggestion for Union Square Cafe."
Positive"The author enjoys the ambiance of Gramercy Tavern and had a positive interaction there previously. They found the tomato soup okay, the kale pasta great, the meatball good, and the sundae (grape and hazelnut) to be a highlight. They would not reserve a table in the tavern area again."
Positive"The user suggested checking Gramercy Tavern for private dining options for 10-13 people. However, the cost for dinner is now $4500, which is likely above the preferred budget."
Neutral"Gramercy Tavern is recommended as a classic New York restaurant."
Neutral"Gramercy Tavern is described as a more formal restaurant, contrasting with other recommendations."
Neutral"Gramercy Tavern is listed as a restaurant that the commenter has really enjoyed for ball-out meals."
Positive"The private dining room at Gramercy Tavern is suggested as a nice space for a party of 10, with its current minimum spend fitting within the specified budget."
Positive"This is recommended as a place to lean into New York vibes for a single night."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern is mentioned as a possibility, noting that while it might not have red meat, it does feature a famous burger that is considered good, though not the best."
Positive"The user strongly agrees with the recommendation for Gramercy Tavern and enjoys it annually."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern is suggested as a solid choice for the described dinner occasion."
Positive"This commenter also suggested Gramercy Tavern, stating it aligns with the user's described preferences."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern is recommended as a suitable option."
Positive
