Iconic NYC spot w/ 1 Michelin star. Offers refined American cuisine in a classic setting; perfect for special occasions or a high-end casual meal.
Gramercy Tavern is a quintessential New York City dining experience, offering both a special occasion dining room and a more casual, yet excellent, tavern space.
Gramercy Tavern is a celebrated New York City institution that offers a quintessential dining experience, catering to both special occasions and more casual outings. It features two distinct spaces: a formal dining room with a seasonal tasting menu and a lively tavern area with à la carte options. The restaurant is known for its attentive service, high-quality ingredients, and creative, approachable American cuisine, making it a reliable choice for various dining needs.
Gramercy Tavern serves creative, seasonal American dishes with a focus on high-quality ingredients. While most reviews are highly positive, with specific praise for the Tavern Burger, seasonal vegetables, and desserts like the Passion Fruit Sundae, a few diners have found some dishes to be too salty or bland.
"The Tavern Burger is frequently praised as one of the best in the city. Seasonal vegetable dishes and desserts like the Passion Fruit Sundae and Chocolate Chip Cookie are also highly recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Gramercy Tavern for its consistently excellent food, impeccable service, and charming ambiance, making it a reliable and highly recommended choice for various occasions.
Important Note
Some diners have found certain dishes to be overly salty or bland. Service at the bar has been noted by some as occasionally aloof, contrasting with the generally excellent service in the dining room.
"Gramercy Tavern has unfortunately gone downhill."
Negative"The Kitchen Table experience at The Modern is suggested as a memorable option that provides a similar-ish sort of food to Gramercy Tavern."
Neutral"The user states they liked Gramercy Tavern."
Positive"The original poster decided to go with Gramercy Tavern for their mother's birthday celebration, expressing gratitude for the help received."
Positive"This user was able to get a seat at the bar and have a great meal at Gramercy Tavern without a reservation, though they note that timing is important."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern is mentioned as being famous for its experience, but now only offers a tasting menu. The commenter notes that the Tavern Room is à la carte but more casual."
Neutral"Gramercy Tavern offers great value, especially during restaurant week. The commenter was very pleased with their experience."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern is suggested as a place offering a martini and fries combination."
Positive"This commenter recommends Gramercy Tavern and suggests emailing them in advance with the celebration details. They noted the restaurant staff is very helpful and often does something extra for special occasions."
Positive"This commenter has been going to Gramercy Tavern for 10 years and always had a perfect experience. They consider it their top choice for birthdays and celebrations because of its reliability."
Positive"This commenter states that any Michelin-starred restaurant costing $150+ will have fantastic service. They suggest doing a tasting menu for the best service experience."
Neutral"Gramercy Tavern is listed among several other restaurant recommendations."
Neutral"The ambiance at Gramercy Tavern is preferable to The Bar Room at The Modern, although The Modern's bar area is noted as being nicer."
Positive"The user notes that Gramercy Tavern has a fantastic dessert menu and that it's hard to go wrong with any choice."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern is recommended to check out, especially in conjunction with visiting the USQ green market."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern is listed as a place of interest."
Positive"If Gramercy Tavern is unable to help, they might suggest their sister restaurants like Union Square Cafe."
Neutral"The commenter believes Gramercy Tavern will likely be able to find a table for four people."
Positive"It is advised to contact Gramercy Tavern first. If they cannot accommodate, checking reservation apps like Resy or Open Table for cancellations or last-minute openings is recommended. The user also advises against purchasing reservations."
Positive"The user suggests calling Gramercy Tavern directly to explain the situation, as they might be able to accommodate a last-minute reservation for four."
Positive
