A New York institution offering both casual and fine dining with seasonal American cuisine, impeccable service, and a consistently appealing ambiance.
Gramercy Tavern is a celebrated New York institution that offers a dual dining experience, from its casual tavern to its more formal dining room. Known for its creative and seasonal American cuisine, the restaurant consistently receives high marks for its impeccable ingredients and approachable yet sophisticated flavors. Whether seeking a relaxed meal or an elegant evening, patrons consistently praise the attentive service and inviting ambiance, making it a reliable choice for various occasions.
Gramercy Tavern is praised for its seasonal American cuisine, with many customers highlighting the quality of ingredients and the comforting yet refined flavors. Specific dishes like the burger and various desserts, such as the chocolate chip cookie and passion fruit sundae, receive frequent praise. While most find the food excellent, a few reviewers noted issues with certain dishes being over-salted or not meeting their expectations.
"The burger at Gramercy Tavern is frequently highlighted as a must-try, with several users praising it as exceptional. Desserts, particularly the chocolate chip cookie and passion fruit sundae, are also highly recommended."
Overall, customers have a very positive sentiment towards Gramercy Tavern, frequently recommending it for various occasions due to its consistent quality, excellent service, and appealing ambiance. While most reviews are highly favorable, a few dissenters found certain dishes, like the burger, to be mediocre or the overall experience to be less exceptional than expected.
Important Note
One user found the burger to be mediocre and not worth the hype, while another had a negative experience with overly salty food and poor service at the bar. There are mixed opinions on whether it lives up to its hype, with some finding it consistently good and others finding it underwhelming.
"The user found the dining room at Gramercy Tavern to have excellent food and lovely service. They dined there for their husband's birthday and found it consistently great, despite being hard to please."
Positive"This commenter recommended Gramercy Tavern as a classic one-star spot."
Positive"This commenter simply stated Gramercy Tavern all day as their choice for a final meal."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern was mentioned as a place the commenter plans to try for the first time, though the $60 lunch price is slightly above their preferred budget."
Neutral"This commenter highly recommended Gramercy Tavern, stating it's not a steakhouse but is worth the visit."
Positive"This commenter suggests that the original poster is aware the restaurant week deal is only in the dining room and is questioning if it's a better value than the typically cheaper tavern. They express mild frustration with others seeming to show off their knowledge."
Neutral"This commenter recommends the tavern at Gramercy Tavern."
Neutral"Gramercy Tavern (tavern side) is recommended."
Positive"This user would go to Gramercy Tavern alone."
Positive"This commenter found both Gramercy Tavern and Gage & Tollner to be mediocre for their price point."
Neutral"This commenter suggested that Gramercy Tavern might be less impressive for carnivores, as experiences can vary and may depend on a preference for fruits and vegetables."
Neutral"This commenter expresses a negative opinion about restaurant week menus in general, stating their past experiences at Gramercy Tavern were mediocre."
Negative"This commenter felt Gramercy Tavern was a significantly better choice over Gage & Tollner."
Positive"In contrast to another commenter, this user had an amazing food experience at Gramercy Tavern's main dining room."
Positive"A simple recommendation for Gramercy Tavern."
Positive"This commenter recommends the dining room, noting that Gramercy Tavern's restaurant week menu is typically quite good, unlike many others that offer uninspired dishes."
Positive"This commenter strongly recommended Gramercy Tavern, noting it is not a steakhouse."
Positive"This commenter recommends choosing the dining room for Gramercy Tavern's restaurant week menu."
Positive"This commenter advised booking whichever restaurant has availability, indicating both are good options."
Neutral"This commenter recommended Gramercy Tavern and suggested Harry's if a better steakhouse experience is desired."
Positive
