Iconic NYC fine dining spot w/ 2 vibes: a buzzy tavern & an elegant dining room. Known for stellar service & seasonal American dishes.
Gramercy Tavern is a quintessential New York City dining experience, offering both a special occasion dining room and a more casual, yet excellent, tavern space.
Gramercy Tavern is a classic New York City establishment that offers two distinct dining experiences: the lively tavern for more casual lunches and the elegant dining room for special occasions. It's celebrated for its consistently excellent New American cuisine, attentive service, and warm, comfortable atmosphere, making it a reliable choice for various diners and events.
Gramercy Tavern is celebrated for its seasonal New American cuisine. While many rave about dishes like the Tavern Burger, tasting menus, and desserts such as the chocolate pudding cake and seasonal sundaes, a few diners found some offerings, like the burger or hanger steak, to be bland, salty, or underwhelming.
"The Tavern Burger is frequently praised as one of the best in the city. Other highly recommended items include the seasonal vegetable dishes and desserts like the chocolate pudding cake and seasonal sundaes. The tasting menu in the dining room is also a popular choice for special occasions."
Customers overwhelmingly praise Gramercy Tavern for its exceptional food, warm service, and classic NYC ambiance, making it a top choice for celebrations and business occasions. While most experiences are highly positive, a minority found the food, particularly the burger, to be underwhelming or overpriced.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest that while Gramercy Tavern offers an excellent overall experience, the food might be considered bland or overpriced by some, and reservations are highly recommended, especially for popular times.
"Gramercy Tavern is described as incredible and the reason this commenter became a fan of chef Tom Colicchio."
Positive"Responding to a disagreement about Union Square Cafe, this commenter respects differing opinions but reiterates their own positive experience."
Neutral"This commenter expressed that they absolutely loved Union Square Cafe, contrasting with another user's negative experience."
Positive"This commenter is impressed by the food at Gramercy Tavern, specifically mentioning the ravioli and cocktails, and expresses envy over the complimentary items and excellent guest treatment."
Positive"This commenter highlights Gramercy Tavern's exceptional hospitality, noting how the staff created a lovely experience despite disruptive nearby customers."
Positive"The original poster found the hospitality at Gramercy Tavern to be top-tier, especially enjoying easy conversation with the waiters."
Positive"Gramercy Tavern provides excellent hospitality, giving complimentary items like scones for the next morning and bonbons after the meal. The commenter appreciated the staff's ability to manage difficult neighboring customers."
Positive"This commenter provided the price for the prix fixe menu at Gramercy Tavern, stating it is $175 per person, excluding alcohol."
Neutral"A very brief positive reaction to the post about Gramercy Tavern."
Positive"This commenter inquired about the reason Gramercy Tavern provided complimentary items in a bag."
Neutral"This commenter makes a humorous remark about Frog Club possibly being a social experiment, in response to a discussion about overrated places."
Neutral"This commenter enjoyed Gramercy Tavern's meal and mentioned enjoying the bar menu, specifically the burger, broccolini salad, beef carpaccio, and beignets, and also noted a delicious mango upside down cake."
Positive"This commenter believes Gramercy Tavern and Union Square Cafe stand out for their service and consistency, offering excellent food with care at modest prices compared to newer establishments."
Positive"This commenter notes that Gramercy Tavern still offers a soup & sandwich combo for $29 on weekdays at lunch in the tavern, though the sandwich is not the burger."
Positive"A simple question about the price of the meal at Gramercy Tavern."
Neutral"A simple expression of strong liking for Gramercy Tavern."
Positive"This commenter politely corrected the spelling of 'prix fixe' in the original post."
Neutral"This commenter also dined at Gramercy Tavern the same night as the original poster and confirms it was a special evening, specifically praising the chocolate flan as insanely good."
Positive"This commenter inquired if the burger and soup special at Gramercy Tavern had been removed, as they could not find it online."
Neutral"A commenter expresses strong affection for Gramercy Tavern, mentioning it is available on a platform called 'inkind'."
Positive
