TLDR
Mediterranean delights & outstanding borscht above the Comedy Cellar. Underrated gem frequented by comedians.
Reddit Sentiment for OLIVE TREE CAFE & COMEDY CELLAR(based on 7 Reddit opinions)
Details
Nestled above the legendary Comedy Cellar, this spot offers a surprisingly delicious experience that often flies under the radar. It's praised for its solid Mediterranean fare and even better borscht, making it a worthwhile stop before a show [1]. Comedians themselves are known to frequent the back booths, adding to the unique atmosphere.
Food Overview
The Mediterranean cuisine here is considered underrated by many, with specific praise for the borscht [1]. While most feedback is positive, one user described the food as mediocre, contrasting with the popular notion of it being surprisingly good for its unfancy nature [4]. The cafe also offers Sunday brunch, which is noted as underappreciated.
Caveats
One user felt the food at The Olive Tree Cafe was mediocre, contrasting with generally positive feedback about its surprising quality and deliciousness [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLIVE TREE CAFE & COMEDY CELLAR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Would You Recommend Grabbing Dinner Solo
"This user commented that while The Olive Tree Cafe is a cool spot to see comedians, the food is considered mediocre."
NegativeFrom post: Where Would You Recommend Grabbing Dinner Solo
"The Olive Tree Cafe, located above the Comedy Cellar, was suggested as a place to eat, with a note that comedians are often seen there."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Best Mozzarella Sticks
"Olive Tree was mentioned in response to a request for mozzarella sticks."
NeutralFrom post: Middle Eastern Places
"This user added that the food quality at The Olive Tree Cafe, including their Sunday brunch, is underappreciated."
PositiveFrom post: Middle Eastern Places
"This user suggested The Olive Tree Cafe above the Comedy Cellar, noting it's surprisingly delicious for its unfancy nature."
PositiveFrom post: Affordable Dinner Options In Lower Midtown
"The Olive Tree Cafe, located above The Comedy Cellar, is described as incredibly underrated for its Mediterranean food. The commenter also notes that comedians often frequent the back booths."
PositiveFrom post: Going To The Comedy Cellar Would Like To Eat
"The Olive Tree Cafe is highly recommended for its delicious Mediterranean food and surprisingly outstanding borscht, noting its convenient location directly above the Comedy Cellar."
Positive