Next.js logo

ANTONIO'S PIZZERIA

Updated

Phone: (718) 398-2033

Address: 318 FLATBUSH AVENUE 11238

TLDR

Unhyped neighborhood pizza joint w/ consistently great pies. Owners are grumpy but nice; a true local gem.

Reddit Sentiment for ANTONIO'S PIZZERIA(based on 1 Reddit opinion)

100% Positive

Tags

italian 6italian-american 4pizza 7View All

Neighborhoods

Park Slope

Details

This Brooklyn pizzeria is a beloved local gem, serving up consistently great pizza that locals hope remains unhyped. The owners are described as endearingly grumpy yet nice, adding to the authentic neighborhood feel. It's a spot that consistently delivers quality, making it a surprising standout in the crowded NYC pizza scene.

Food Overview

The food at this establishment is primarily pizza, which receives high praise for its quality and consistency. It's considered a standout by locals who hope it remains a hidden gem.

Highlights / Recommended

"While specific dishes are not mentioned, the pizza itself is consistently recommended and praised."

Customer Sentiment

Customers have a very positive sentiment, appreciating the consistently great pizza and the unique character of the owners.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About ANTONIO'S PIZZERIA

A commenter gave a shoutout to Antonio's on 7th Ave, praising the spot as 'consistently great' and describing the owner as 'grumpy and nice at the same time'.
A commenter praised Angelo's Pizza on Flatbush as much better than their previous local spot, noting the owners seem to care.
A user expressed appreciation for Antonio's on Flatbush, hoping they stay open without getting overly popular lines or prices.
This user loves Antonio's on Flatbush and is surprised it's not talked about more often.
A user identifies their favorite old school pizza shop as Antonio's on Flatbush Ave.
The user recommends Antonio's on Flatbush for its great exterior and pizza.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: I Painted A Dozen Brooklyn Pizzerias Storefronts

"The user recommends Antonio's on Flatbush for its great exterior and pizza."

Positive
Jul 3, 2025View Comment →