TLDR
Hearty, stuffed Tex-Mex staples and vegan-friendly options in the heart of Hell's Kitchen. A long-time favorite for quick, filling lunches near Midtown.
Details
A long-standing Hell's Kitchen staple, this Tex-Mex spot has been a favorite for decades, known for offering hearty, stuffed burritos [17]. While it was once considered a top-tier choice by many, recent feedback suggests a shift in perception, with some diners noting a decline in flavor and quality over the years [14], [15], [16]. Despite these mixed reviews, it remains a popular and accessible lunch destination for those in the Midtown area [12].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on Tex-Mex essentials, particularly burritos and burrito bowls, which are noted for being impressively large and filling [17]. While the guacamole is frequently praised [18] and the spinach and portabello quesadilla is a recommended item [20], recent feedback has trended negatively, with several diners labeling the food as bland or mediocre compared to its former glory [14], [15], [16].
The spinach and portabello quesadilla is specifically recommended [20], and the guacamole is described as great [18].
Customer reception is highly polarized; while many long-time patrons cherish the establishment as a reliable, fun lunch spot [12], [20], newer reviews frequently complain of declining food quality, bland flavors, and higher pricing [7], [8], [14], [15], [16].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01carnitas burrito2 mentions
Caveats
Multiple recent reports indicate a significant decline in food flavor and quality over the past six years, with some customers finding it overpriced [8], [14], [15], [16].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BURRITO BOX
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Are A Few Of Your Fav Restaurantseateries
"The user mentioned the restaurant as a favorite closed spot."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burrito In Nyc Right Now Is It Still
"A long-time favorite for over two decades; also recommends the spinach and portabello quesadilla."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burrito In Nyc Right Now Is It Still
"The author highly recommends this place."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For The Best Burritomexican Food In Hells
"The taste and quality of burritos at Burrito Box have significantly declined over the past six years."
NegativeFrom post: Looking For The Best Burritomexican Food In Hells
"The food at Burrito Box is described as having lost its flavor and gone downhill."
Negative