TLDR
Exceptional Mexican seafood, esp. aguachiles, w/ fresh, citrusy & spicy tacos & tostadas. Standouts: aguachile negro & grilled shrimp.
Details
This Mexican seafood spot is lauded for its exceptional and reasonably priced offerings, particularly its aguachiles [1]. The restaurant consistently delivers high-quality dishes, with recent praise for its fresh, citrusy, and spicy Tacos El Gobernador and Tostadas La Sicaria [2]. Standout items include the refreshing aguachile negro and the highly recommended grilled shrimp [3], [4].
Food Overview
Mariscos El Submarino is celebrated for its authentic Mexican seafood, with aguachiles being a frequently recommended dish, praised for its bright, refreshing, and acidic flavors [1], [2]. While tacos like the Tacos El Gobernador are highlighted for their fresh ingredients and balanced spice, other taco preparations have received mixed reviews [3], [4]. The grilled shrimp is another consistently praised item, noted for its quality and flavor [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"The Tacos El Gobernador and Tostadas La Sicaria are highly recommended for their fresh, citrusy, and spicy profiles. Aguachile negro and grilled shrimp are also standout dishes that customers frequently praise."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •grilled shrimp(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customers consistently praise Mariscos El Submarino for its exceptional Mexican seafood and reasonable prices, with specific commendations for its aguachiles and fresh, zesty tacos and tostadas [1], [2]. The grilled shrimp is also frequently highlighted as a must-try dish, underscoring the restaurant's enduring quality.
Caveats
One reviewer noted that while the aguachiles were a pleasant surprise, the tacos were not as well-received, particularly for someone accustomed to West Coast preparations [1]. Additionally, a related restaurant from the same team, Mitica, received mixed reviews, with issues like an incorrectly cooked expensive rib-eye and forgettable cocktails, though their aguachile negro was praised [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MARISCOS EL SUBMARINO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Can I Find Good Seafood Preferably Seafood
"Mariscos El Submarino is included in a list of general seafood recommendations for NYC."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Dish Youve Had In 2026 And Where
"This user confirmed they had the grilled shrimp at Mariscos El Submarino today and found it very good."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Best Dish Youve Had In 2026 And Where
"This user mentioned the grilled shrimp at Mariscos El Submarino as a great dish from 2026."
PositiveFrom post: What Is Your Most Frequented Restaurant
"This user states that all locations of Mariscos El Submarino are consistently good and frequently visited."
PositiveFrom post: 4 Days Eating Through Nyc
"Coming from LA, the user did not love the tacos at Mariscos Submarino but found the aguachiles to be a pleasant surprise and well done."
NeutralFrom post: 5 Days Of Eating My Way Through The City
"The author highlighted Mariscos El Submarino's Tacos El Gobernador and Tostadas La Sicaria as a top bite. The dishes were described as fresh, citrusy, and having the right amount of heat."
PositiveFrom post: Hamido Seafood Astoria
"This commenter recommended Mariscos El Submarino in Greenpoint as an excellent seafood restaurant option for those in Williamsburg, stating it can satisfy a seafood craving."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are You Going Out To Eat These Days Without
"Mariscos El Submarino was suggested as a place to eat, suitable for those looking for options outside of home-cooked meals and concerned about high prices."
NeutralFrom post: Restaurants For Vinegaracid Lovers
"This user recommends Mariscos El Submarino for their aguachiles, noting that these should satisfy a craving for acidic dishes."
PositiveFrom post: 30th Birthday Dinner Ideas For Group
"This user recommends Mariscos El Submarino for Mexican seafood, noting it's not too expensive and exceptional. They are unsure if it accommodates large parties."
Positive