Next.js logo

PISTICCI RESTAURANT

Updated

Phone: (212) 932-3500

Address: 125 LA SALLE STREET 10027

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Cozy date night spot in West Harlem w/ highly praised pasta dishes & a delightful coconut cake [1], [8]. Known for its cozy vibe, it's a place to never have a bad meal [4].

Reddit Sentiment for PISTICCI RESTAURANT(based on 13 Reddit opinions)

85% Positive15% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

italian 7italian 2View All

Neighborhoods

Morningside Heights

Details

Pisticci, a West Harlem Italian restaurant, is lauded for its cozy ambiance, making it a popular choice for date nights and intimate gatherings [1], [4]. Patrons consistently praise the quality of their pasta dishes, with the Lamb Ragu pasta being a standout [1], [9]. The restaurant also offers a private area suitable for larger parties, further enhancing its appeal for various occasions [7].

Food Overview

Pisticci is celebrated for its Italian cuisine, with a particular emphasis on its pasta dishes, including a highly recommended Lamb Ragu pasta [9]. The coconut cake has also received specific praise [8]. While generally well-regarded, one reviewer found the Italian food to be average [5].

Highlights / Recommended

"Highly recommended dishes include the pasta, particularly the Lamb Ragu pasta, and the Lemon Ricotta pancakes. The coconut cake is also a praised dessert option [8], [9], [6]."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards Pisticci, frequently recommending it for its cozy atmosphere and quality Italian food, particularly pasta dishes [1], [4], [7], [9]. While most feedback is positive, one user described the Italian food as average [5].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About PISTICCI RESTAURANT

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1nj4syp/best_italian_spot_on_the_uws/
This thread features multiple recommendations for Pisticci as a great Italian spot in West Harlem, highlighting its cozy atmosphere and overall positive dining experience.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1o5vqsb/restaurant_recommendation_around_harlemuws/
Pisticci is recommended as a cozy and reliable Italian restaurant, with one user stating they've never had a bad meal there. Another comment notes it as average Italian food.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1tj6pr0/looking_for_pancake_recommendations_with_not/
A user specifically recommends the Lemon Ricotta pancakes at Pisticci, noting them as a must-try dish.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1o2c9e3/16th_bday_restaurant_recommendations/
Pisticci is recommended for its great pasta and its cozy vibe, with a mention of a private area suitable for about 25 guests.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1t26zhb/recommendations_for_out_of_town_guest_uws_or_west/
A user recalled loving Pisticci in the past and specifically mentioned the Lamb Ragu pasta as fabulous.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1o6gw5o/what_is_the_best_dessert_youve_doordashed_in_nyc/
The coconut cake from Pisticci is specifically recommended by a user in this discussion about favorite desserts.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Bestgood Places To Eat Around 125th In Harlem

"Pisticci is listed as a restaurant to consider."

Positive
May 23, 2026View Comment →

From post: Looking For Pancake Recommendations With Not

"The user recommended Pisticci for Lemon Ricotta pancakes, suggesting it's a good option."

Positive
May 21, 2026View Comment →

From post: Good Italian Near United Palace Theatre 4140

"This user recommended Pisticci, stating it is a great place located one block south of 125th Street off Broadway."

Positive
May 8, 2026View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Out Of Town Guest Uws Or West

"This commenter recalled loving Pisticci in the past and enjoyed it before a show at Lenfest prior to the pandemic."

Positive
May 3, 2026View Comment →

From post: Food Near Hamilton Grange

"Pisticci is an Italian restaurant option on 125th street."

Neutral
Apr 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Is The Best Dessert Youve Doordashed In Nyc

"This user recommends the coconut cake from Pisticci."

Positive
Oct 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurant Recommendation Around Harlemuws

"Pisticci is described as average Italian food."

Neutral
Oct 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurant Recommendation Around Harlemuws

"The user recommends Pisticci, mentioning they haven't been in a while but love the place."

Positive
Oct 14, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurant Recommendation Around Harlemuws

"The user loves Pisticci, stating they've never had a bad meal and find it very cozy."

Positive
Oct 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: 16th Bday Restaurant Recommendations

"Pisticci on West 125th St was recommended for its great pasta and a private area suitable for approximately 25 guests, highlighting its cozy vibe."

Positive
Oct 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Italian Spot On The Uws

"This user recommended Osteria Accademia and also mentioned Pisticci as a good option."

Positive
Sep 18, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Italian Spot On The Uws

"This user recommended Pisticci's. The restaurant is located in west Harlem."

Positive
Sep 17, 2025View Comment →

From post: Cozy Date Night Uws

"Pisticci's, located on La Salle St. in West Harlem, was recommended for a cozy date night."

Positive
Jun 4, 2025View Comment →