Last Updated: 3 months ago
Phone: (212) 926-3155
Address: 1747 AMSTERDAM AVENUE 10031
Underrated neighborhood gem serving amazing pizza, especially the Grandma and regular slices.
Discover a true neighborhood gem in Harlem, P & M CLASSIC PIZZA & RESTAURANT, a spot that consistently delights with its fantastic pizza. This establishment has earned a reputation for serving up some of the city's best, often flying under the radar but delivering exceptional quality. Whether you're craving a classic regular slice or a perfectly executed Grandma slice, P & M is a must-visit for pizza aficionados seeking authentic, unhyped flavors.
P & M CLASSIC PIZZA & RESTAURANT is highly regarded for its pizza, with customers specifically recommending the Grandma slice and the regular slice. The cuisine is primarily Italian-American. Reviewers often highlight these pizzas as being excellent, sometimes calling them underrated neighborhood favorites.
"Customers rave about the Grandma slice and the regular slice, both considered excellent choices."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards P & M CLASSIC PIZZA & RESTAURANT, with many praising their pizza. Specific mentions include their grandma slice and regular slice being highly recommended for their quality. The restaurant is often cited as an underrated or unhyped neighborhood gem.
"Suggests checking out P & M Classic Pizza and Restaurant for their Sicilian slice."
Neutral"Agrees P and M Classic is a great pick, noting the regular slice is also really solid for a classic neighborhood slice."
Positive"Recommends P&M Classic Pizza's grandma slice in Harlem as amazing."
Positive"In response to a request for recommendations in Hamilton Heights, a user simply suggested 'P&M'."
Positive"This user lists P and M, their local spot in Harlem, as one of their favorite pizza places that isn't often mentioned."
Positive
