Next.js logo

MARIO'S RESTAURANT

Updated

Phone: (718) 584-1188

Address: 2342 ARTHUR AVENUE 10458

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Old-school Italian charm w/ classic red sauce dishes & a historic vibe. A true Arthur Ave gem.

Reddit Sentiment for MARIO'S RESTAURANT(based on 10 Reddit opinions)

80% Positive10% Neutral

Achievements and Accolades

Achievement logo

Tags

italian 9italian-american 2italian 6pasta 2seafood 2View All

Neighborhoods

Belmont

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
New York's Oldest Restaurants: A Guide to the City's Timeless Establishments
positive

Over a century old, Mario's on Arthur Avenue remains an old-school Italian gem, family-owned and preserving its original charm with classic dishes and a memorable dessert trolley.

undefined • Date unknown
Read More →
Eater

Details

Steeped in over a century of history, this family-owned Italian restaurant on Arthur Avenue is a genuine old-school gem. It proudly preserves its original charm, offering classic dishes that evoke a sense of nostalgia. From traditional red sauce fare to elegant entrees and a memorable dessert trolley, it provides a truly timeless dining experience.

Food Overview

This restaurant offers a classic Italian menu with a focus on traditional red sauce dishes. Popular recommendations include linguine with red clam sauce and veal Marsala, reflecting the old-school Italian-American cuisine. The establishment also features a notable dessert trolley.

Highlights / Recommended

"Linguine with red clam sauce and veal Marsala are highlighted as particularly recommended dishes, embodying the classic Italian-American fare offered."

Customer Sentiment

Customers consistently praise this establishment for its traditional Italian experience and nostalgic ambiance. Feedback highlights its authentic old-school charm and classic dishes, making it a beloved spot on Arthur Avenue.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MARIO'S RESTAURANT

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1sms971/spots_for_italian_seafood_dishes/
Highly recommended for its linguine with red clam sauce, offering generous portions typical of old-school spots. Walk-ins are welcome, and the interior is described as beautiful.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1mqpukn/bayridge_or_arthur_ave_for_old_school_italian_red/
Described as very old school and a filming location for The Godfather, this spot is suggested as a good option on Arthur Avenue, with many pastry shops nearby.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jzyav6/bronx_arthurs_ave_recommendation/
Simply listed as a recommendation for an Italian restaurant in the Arthur Ave area, indicating its recognized status among locals.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1pxtmxz/red_sauce_italian/
This restaurant is among the recommended choices for Italian dining on Arthur Ave, suggesting it's a solid option for classic red sauce cuisine.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1kwy79t/my_brother_wants_to_eat_like_tony_soprano_in/
The commenter recommends this restaurant for a more traditional Italian dining experience on Arthur Avenue.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1lahftp/arthur_avenue_restaurants_dress_code/
The user suggests this restaurant as a viable option on Arthur Avenue and assures that a casual dress code, like shorts and a polo, is acceptable.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Spots For Italian Seafood Dishes

"Mario's on Arthur Ave is highly recommended for its linguine with red clam sauce, offering a generous portion typical of old-school spots. Walk-ins are welcome. It is also noted for its beautiful interior, pleasant staff, and complimentary garlic carrots."

Positive
Apr 16, 2026View Comment →

From post: Nyc Traditional Italian Recommendations

"This user mentioned that old-school Italian places are hard to find and gatekept, suggesting Arthur Ave is the closest a tourist can get to the past experience."

Neutral
Mar 17, 2026View Comment →

From post: Red Sauce Italian

"The commenter went to Roberto's (not Luigi's) on Arthur Ave for a classic red sauce dinner, which cost $500 for 10 people."

Positive
Dec 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Red Sauce Italian

"The commenter went to Roberto's (not Luigi's) on Arthur Ave for a classic red sauce dinner, which cost $500 for 10 people."

Positive
Dec 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Red Sauce Italian

"Mario's on Arthur Ave is among the recommended choices for Italian dining."

Positive
Dec 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Red Sauce Italian

"Mario's on Arthur Ave is among the recommended choices for Italian dining."

Positive
Dec 28, 2025View Comment →

From post: Bayridge Or Arthur Ave For Old School Italian Red

"Mario's on Arthur Ave is described as very old school and was a filming location for The Godfather. The user suggests it's a good option along with plenty of pastry shops nearby."

Positive
Aug 15, 2025View Comment →

From post: Arthur Avenue Restaurants Dress Code

"The user suggests Mario's as a viable option on Arthur Avenue, assuring that the proposed casual dress code (shorts, polo) is acceptable there."

Positive
Jun 13, 2025View Comment →

From post: My Brother Wants To Eat Like Tony Soprano In

"The commenter recommends Mario's for a more traditional experience on Arthur Avenue."

Positive
May 28, 2025View Comment →