Next.js logo

MARIO'S RESTAURANT

Updated

Phone: (718) 584-1188

Address: 2342 ARTHUR AVENUE 10458

View on Google Maps

TLDR

A century-old, family-owned Italian gem on Arthur Avenue known for its authentic, old-school atmosphere and classic dishes.

Reddit Sentiment for MARIO'S RESTAURANT(based on 12 Reddit opinions)

58% Positive17% Neutral17% Negative

Tags

italian 10italian 6pasta 3View All

Neighborhoods

Belmont

Other Article Mentions

Lists, round-ups, and guides where this restaurant is featured.

Mentioned In
New York's Oldest Restaurants: A Guide to the City's Timeless Establishments
positive

Over a century old, Mario's on Arthur Avenue remains an old-school Italian gem, family-owned and preserving its original charm with classic dishes and a memorable dessert trolley.

undefined • Date unknown
Read More →
Eater

Details

An authentic, family-owned institution on Arthur Avenue, this century-old establishment preserves the charm of classic Italian dining with its original interior, featuring oil paintings and Michelangelo statuettes [1]. Guests can enjoy a timeless experience that includes a memorable dessert trolley and complementary anisette with espresso [1]. It has even served as a notable filming location for iconic mafia-themed media [2].

Food Overview

This restaurant specializes in classic Italian-American cuisine and is highly regarded for its pasta dishes, particularly the linguine with red clam sauce [2], [3]. Customers frequently recommend the garlic carrots [3], though mixed reviews exist regarding other items like the pizza and antipasto [4].

Highlights / Recommended

The linguine with red clam sauce and the complimentary garlic carrots are consistently highlighted as standout options [3].

Customer Sentiment

Feedback is generally positive, with guests appreciating the charming atmosphere, professional service, and reliable pasta [2], [3]. While most enjoy the experience, some diners have found the overall food quality to be disappointing despite the aesthetic appeal [4].

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About MARIO'S RESTAURANT

https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1sms971/spots_for_italian_seafood_dishes/
This post highlights the restaurant as a go-to spot for linguine with red clam sauce, noting that walk-ins are welcome.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1mqpukn/bayridge_or_arthur_ave_for_old_school_italian_red/
The discussion identifies the restaurant as a very old-school option on Arthur Avenue, famously known as a filming location for The Godfather.
https://www.reddit.com/r/FoodNYC/comments/1uq3l9d/what_are_some_restaurants_and_bars_that_tony/
A detailed thread where a frequent visitor praises the consistency of the pasta and garlic carrots, while another diner offers a contrasting opinion on the food quality.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: What Are Some Restaurants And Bars That Tony

"The food overall was below par, though the linguine with clams was enjoyable."

Negative
Jul 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Restaurants And Bars That Tony

"The author visits frequently and finds their pasta and garlic carrots reliable."

Positive
Jul 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Restaurants And Bars That Tony

"The atmosphere is great, but the food was disappointing."

Negative
Jul 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: What Are Some Restaurants And Bars That Tony

"Mentioned the restaurant was a filming location for a Sopranos episode."

Neutral
Jul 7, 2026View Comment →

From post: Spots For Italian Seafood Dishes

"Mario's on Arthur Ave is highly recommended for its linguine with red clam sauce, offering a generous portion typical of old-school spots. Walk-ins are welcome. It is also noted for its beautiful interior, pleasant staff, and complimentary garlic carrots."

Positive
Apr 16, 2026View Comment →

More in Belmont

See all

More Italian in NYC

See all