TLDR
Upscale Greek gem w/ authentic flavors & cozy, pottery-adorned ambiance. A long-time favorite for classic dishes & date nights.
Instagram Posts References
Pylos, located in the East Village, is an authentic Greek restaurant highly recommended for date nights. The establishment offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere, enhanced by its unique clay pot ceiling and warm ambiance. The reviewer had an incredibly positive experience, noting that every dish was beautifully plated, unique, and rich in flavor, making it one of their favorite Greek spots in NYC.
Details
This East Village Greek restaurant evokes a sunny Aegean atmosphere with its whitewashed walls, terra-cotta pots, and modern lapis-blue accents. Pylos is celebrated for its consistently good and tasty classic Greek dishes, with many patrons having enjoyed its quality for over a decade [1]. Standout items include delicate meatballs, baked giant beans in a honey-tomato sauce, and a vegetarian moussaka made with artichokes [2].
Food Overview
Pylos offers a range of authentic Greek dishes, with patrons consistently recommending its classic fare. Highlights include lamb chops, lemon potatoes, grilled octopus, and horiatiki salad [3]. The pistachio sea bass is particularly noted as a standout, described as buttery and delicate. Other appreciated items include saganaki, dips, and phyllo triangles [4]. While most feedback is positive, one user found a pictured dish to be 'mid' [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"Patrons highly recommend the lamb chops, lemon potatoes, grilled octopus, and horiatiki salad. The pistachio sea bass is also a notable standout dish."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •lamb chops(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customers overwhelmingly praise Pylos for its consistently delicious and authentic Greek cuisine, with many patrons returning for years. The restaurant is frequently recommended for its excellent food and inviting atmosphere, making it a favored spot for both casual dining and date nights.
Caveats
One user found a pictured dish to be 'mid', and another user recalled visiting in 2010, noting its long-standing operation [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About PYLOS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: If You Could Have Just One Dish From One
"The commenter recommended the Greek salad at Pylos."
PositiveFrom post: Casual Greek Food Like Crossrhodes Evanston Il In
"This user suggested Pylos in the East Village as a casual-ish Greek option in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter considers Pylos to be one of the best Greek restaurants in all of NYC, even better than some in Astoria."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter briefly stated that the food pictured looked 'mid'."
NegativeFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter inquired about a pink sauce shown in a dish, questioning if it was a seafood pasta with tomato sauce."
NeutralFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter made a humorous observation that the first dish pictured at Pylos looks like it could awaken one's inner cave person."
NeutralFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter expressed their love for Pylos, noting they haven't visited in years."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter expressed happiness that Pylos is still around, reminiscing about trading dinners there when they worked at Crif Dogs. They described the people as great and the food as superb."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter praises the grilled octopus at Pylos, calling it stellar."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter specifically enjoys the lamb chops, lemon potatoes, and horiatiki salad at Pylos."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter states that Pylos serves really great food."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter was unaware Pylos was still open and recalled its distinctive decor, featuring pottery hanging from the ceiling."
NeutralFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter recognized Pylos as a throwback restaurant, having not visited since 2010 and was surprised it was still in operation."
NeutralFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter enjoys Pylos and visits with their father when he comes to town."
PositiveFrom post: Pylos East Village
"The commenter visited Pylos and found the food to be amazing."
PositiveFrom post: Greek Food Near Or Around Midtown
"Pylos is listed among several Greek restaurant recommendations in the Midtown area."
NeutralFrom post: Greek Restaurant With A Funmemorable Atmosphere
"This user recommends Pylos for its interesting atmosphere and slightly better food compared to another mentioned restaurant."
PositiveFrom post: Greek Restaurant With A Funmemorable Atmosphere
"This user provided a link to a thread discussing the best Greek restaurants in Manhattan."
NeutralFrom post: Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants
"This commenter agreed that Pylos is great."
PositiveFrom post: Best Manhattan Greek Restaurants
"Pylos was recommended alongside Nerai and Kiki's."
Positive