Underrated East Village gem serving elevated Italian-American fare for over 20 years. Known for honest, delicious food & a welcoming vibe.
This East Village gem has been a reliable go-to for discerning New Yorkers for over two decades, consistently delivering exceptional Italian-American cuisine. Known for its approachable fine dining and commitment to seasonal ingredients, it offers a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for any occasion. From their celebrated tasting menus to comforting classics, expect a dining experience that prioritizes substance and flavor.
This restaurant offers Italian-American cuisine with a focus on seasonal ingredients. While many dishes receive high praise, including the tasting menu, roasted chicken, and a notable burger, some find it to be 'just fine.' The brodo, made from utilizing all scraps, is also a highlight.
"The tasting menu, a pressed sandwich with taleggio and roasted mushrooms, and the Roasted Spatchcock chicken are frequently recommended. The burger is also highlighted as a long-time favorite."
Customers overwhelmingly praise this restaurant as a reliable and consistently excellent choice, often describing it as underrated and a long-standing favorite. Many appreciate its honest, high-quality food and approachable fine dining experience.
Important Note
One user found the restaurant to be outdated and disappointing with poor service, suggesting a veal stew sandwich was not suitable for summer brunch. Another felt it was 'just fine' and comparable to options in other mid-size cities.
"Hearth was mentioned as a potential dining option for a special occasion lunch in NYC."
Neutral"Hearth is recommended for a traditional Thanksgiving dinner with solid food and a chill environment."
Positive"This user seconded the recommendation for Hearth, stating it is amazing and suitable for a special occasion."
Positive"This restaurant was recommended for a warm vibe and authentic atmosphere for Thanksgiving dinner in NYC."
Positive"Suggests Hearth, noting it has a nice semi-private setup but is unsure about the price per person."
Positive"Hearth is suggested as a restaurant that sources consciously and seasonally, and can accommodate dietary needs."
Positive"The commenter highly recommends Hearth, stating it's as good as other difficult-to-get-into Italian places."
Positive"Hearth is mentioned as a well-regarded European restaurant in the East Village for which same-day reservations have been secured."
Positive"This user suggested Hearth as a potential restaurant that could accommodate the original poster's dietary needs."
Neutral"This user simply stated "Hearth" in response to the original post asking for ribollita."
Neutral"This user simply stated "Hearth !!!" in response to the original post asking for ribollita."
Neutral"The user recommended searching for "ribollita restaurant nyc" or "ribollita restaurant menu nyc" and suggested Hearth as a place that might have the dish. They advised checking the current menu to confirm availability."
Neutral"The user mentioned Hearth as a potential place for ribollita, although they haven't tried that specific dish there. They also suggested making Italian dishes at home by following online tutorials."
Neutral"This restaurant is recommended."
Positive"Hearth is confirmed to have great food but is noted as not being Italian."
Neutral"Hearth is suggested as a reliable option with great food, though it's not Italian."
Positive"Hearth is recommended for long catch-ups, with the commenter having had several multi-hour meetings there."
Positive"This commenter suggests that Hearth is one of the NYC restaurants doing fine dining the right way by making it more approachable."
Positive"This user enjoyed their Thanksgiving experience at Hearth, noting it offered a good mix of classic and original dishes."
Positive"This restaurant is recommended."
Positive
