A long-standing East Village favorite known for its honest, high-quality American-Italian cuisine & cozy, unpretentious vibe.
This East Village gem has been a reliable favorite for nearly two decades, consistently offering a warm and inviting atmosphere. While its cuisine is often described as American with Italian influences, it's celebrated for its honest, high-quality cooking that prioritizes substance over fleeting trends. The dining experience here is particularly notable for its cozy decor and friendly service, making it a go-to for both intimate dinners and special occasions.
The food is primarily American with Italian influences, praised for its honest, high-quality preparation and seasonal ingredients. Dishes like the Roasted Spatchcock chicken, Pressed Sandwich with taleggio, and the off-menu Cacio e Pepe receive high marks. Broth, a key element from their associated company Brodo, is also a notable offering.
"Highly recommended dishes include the Roasted Spatchcock chicken, the Pressed Sandwich with taleggio and mushrooms from the lunch menu, and an off-menu Cacio e Pepe. Their 'Brodo' (broth) is also a notable item."
Customers consistently praise this restaurant as a reliable, high-quality establishment with a warm atmosphere and friendly service, often calling it an "oldie that still got it."
Important Note
One user found the restaurant outdated with poor service and a dated atmosphere, though they noted some dishes were good. Another user felt it was only "just fine" and unremarkable.
"Hearth is mentioned as an option with a candlelit vibe that might be easier to get a reservation for."
Neutral"Hearth still offers a 'pretty bomb' off-menu cacio e pepe."
Positive"The user recommends Hearth in Manhattan, describing it as a lovely restaurant with a large dining room suitable for special occasions."
Positive"Hearth is mentioned as a well-known classic NYC establishment that typically participates in Restaurant Week annually. The user advises evaluating its value on a case-by-case basis."
Neutral"This user simply mentioned "Hearth" in response to a request for meatball recommendations."
Neutral"The commenter recommended Hearth as a longtime neighborhood staple that leans older and quieter, suitable for someone looking for a low-key dining experience on a Saturday night."
Positive"Hearth is mentioned as a place for a date night."
Positive"Hearth is suggested as a date night option."
Positive"The kitchen seats at Hearth are described as really great, with only two seats available, placing diners literally inside the kitchen area, not just an open kitchen style."
Positive"Hearth is mentioned as a restaurant near Sophie's, a dive bar that Anthony Bourdain visited."
Neutral"The user is considering Hearth for dinner."
Neutral"This is a third recommendation for the restaurant."
Positive"This is a restaurant suggestion."
Neutral"This restaurant is recommended as it meets all the criteria mentioned in the original post and is not difficult to get into."
Positive"This is a restaurant suggestion."
Neutral"Hearth is recommended for its numerous vegetarian options, quiet atmosphere, and classic appeal."
Positive"Hearth is suggested as a dining option, offering plenty of vegetarian choices and quiet tables."
Positive"The commenter agrees with the recommendation for Hearth."
Positive"This is a recommendation for Hearth."
Positive"The Ribollita at Hearth is great."
Positive
