An East Village staple serving elevated Italian-American home cooking, renowned for its exceptional tasting menu and highly-praised Roasted Spatchcock chicken.
This East Village establishment is a reliable choice for those seeking high-quality Italian-American cuisine, having been a local favorite for nearly two decades. It's particularly noted for its exceptional tasting menu and a highly recommended Roasted Spatchcock chicken. Beyond its main dining, Hearth is also recognized for its popular 'Brodo' broth, showcasing a commitment to utilizing ingredients fully.
Hearth is celebrated for its Italian-American cuisine, with particular praise for its tasting menu and the Roasted Spatchcock chicken. The Pressed Sandwich with taleggio and mushroom pesto is a standout lunch item. The restaurant is also known for its 'Brodo' (broth), made with high-quality techniques. While most feedback is positive, one user found it to be 'just fine' and another felt it was outdated with poor service.
"Standout dishes include the tasting menu, Roasted Spatchcock chicken, and the Pressed Sandwich with taleggio and mushroom pesto. Their 'Brodo' (broth) is also a highly-regarded item."
Overall, customers have a very positive sentiment towards Hearth, frequently recommending it for its reliable quality, delicious food, and long-standing reputation. Many consider it an underrated gem and a go-to spot for various occasions, from casual lunches to special dinners.
Important Note
One user found the restaurant to be 'just fine' and another mentioned a dated atmosphere and poor service during a brunch visit.
"Hearth is a restaurant the author frequently revisits when hosting guests, highlighting its reliability."
Positive"This is a reliable, long-standing restaurant that created Brodo."
Positive"This user simply states that Hearth fits the criteria for a place to catch up with an old friend."
Positive"This user suggested checking Hearth, mentioning their gazpacho is available on the lunch menu."
Positive"Hearth was suggested as a place the user loves for special occasions. This is a personal recommendation without further context on how it fits the specific graduation dinner requirements."
Positive"During a previous winter restaurant week, Hearth allowed diners to order from both the prix fixe and a la carte menus at the same table."
Positive"This commenter recommended Hearth, noting it's not a Michelin-starred restaurant but a well-regarded New York Times two-star establishment that has consistently delivered quality for two decades."
Positive"The user found Hearth's Restaurant Week lunch and dinner deals to be very good value, noting the promotion lasts through the end of August."
Positive"Hearth is mentioned as having a lovely brunch."
Positive"The user found Hearth to be outdated and disappointing after visiting, citing poor service and a dated atmosphere. They specifically mentioned that the veal stew sandwich, while good, was not suitable for a summer brunch menu."
Negative"This user recommended Hearth as a brunch spot similar to Prune, noting its understated vibe and good food."
Neutral"Hearth was mentioned as a potential private dining location."
Neutral"Hearth is recommended as a delicious Italian restaurant where it is easy to get a table, contrasting with the difficulty of other popular spots."
Positive"A user noted that Hearth might not meet the original poster's outdoor dining requirement for dinner."
Neutral"A user expressed renewed affection for Hearth as an East Village dinner option."
Positive"The commenter recommended Hearth, implying it would be a suitable choice for the original poster's Italian relatives, as they themselves are of Italian descent."
Positive"The commenter strongly recommended Hearth, believing it is an underrated establishment that deserves more recognition."
Positive"The original poster confirmed their positive prior experience with Hearth, stating they already knew it was great."
Positive"The commenter stated that Hearth is the only good restaurant among the options provided by the original poster."
Positive"The commenter simply stated 'Hearth,' indicating their strong recommendation for the restaurant."
Positive
