Wood-fired Pan-Mediterranean w/ dry-aged seafood. Michelin-recognized & a 2024 top-ranked hotspot.
Discover Theodora, a highly-rated Fort Greene restaurant specializing in live-fire cooking and dry-aged fish, with the Whole Butterflied Trout being a standout dish.
This Fort Greene gem, helmed by Tomer Blechman, is a celebrated Pan-Mediterranean spot specializing in wood-fired dishes and dry-aged seafood. It has quickly garnered acclaim, even earning a spot in the Michelin Guide, and was ranked #1 on Beli Eats in 2024. Diners rave about the fresh, flavorful food and the vibrant atmosphere, making it a must-visit, though be prepared for a challenging reservation.
The Pan-Mediterranean cuisine shines with a focus on wood-fired cooking and dry-aged seafood. Standout dishes include the Hiramasa Crudo, Whipped Ricotta Toast, and various grilled fish preparations. While most dishes receive high praise, some find certain items like the lamb or the baklava sundae to be less successful.
"The Whipped Ricotta Toast, various crudos and grilled fish dishes, and the sourdough bread are frequently praised. The 'two color fish' is also specifically recommended."
Overwhelmingly positive, with many describing it as a top-tier, "life-changing" meal and one of the best in NYC.
Important Note
Reservations are notoriously difficult to secure, and some diners have found specific dishes like the lamb or certain desserts to be less impressive.
"Theodora in Brooklyn was recommended as amazing."
Positive"This user corrects the previous comment, stating that Theodora often has meat dishes like lamb and that the menu changes frequently, contradicting the notion that only chicken is available."
Neutral"The user recommends Theodora for its fantastic and innovative food, and great dining experience, highlighting the love put into the food and craft."
Positive"The user recommends Theodora for its fantastic and innovative food, and great dining experience, highlighting the love put into the food and craft."
Positive"This commenter recommends Theodora for a great seafood dinner, noting their dry-aged seafood cooked on an open fire, fantastic service, and awesome cocktails. They had a great dinner there previously."
Positive"This user explicitly states that Theodora's whipped ricotta toast is superior to any other option, indicating a very high level of satisfaction."
Positive"Theodora is recommended for whipped ricotta toast, though the user slightly prefers Miss Ada's version."
Positive"Theodora is mentioned as a restaurant with excellent whipped ricotta toast, with one user strongly recommending it above others."
Positive"Theodora is mentioned as a restaurant that comes to mind for reliable food."
Positive"The user recommended booking a table at Theodora a month in advance, stating that 4 Charles is not worth the effort."
Neutral"Sailor, Place de fettes, and Theodora were mentioned as recommendations."
Neutral"Theodora is recommended for food, along with Miss Ada."
Neutral"Theodora was mentioned as a recommendation."
Neutral"Theodora is on the user's radar as a place to try."
Neutral"The original poster was asking for restaurant recommendations in Williamsburg and mentioned Theodora as a possibility."
Neutral"Theodora is recommended by the commenter. They also suggest K'far as an alternative from the same chef."
Positive"Theodora is listed as one of the commenter's favorites for fresh middle eastern bread."
Positive"Theodora is recommended as an upscale restaurant focusing on Mediterranean cuisine, particularly seafood."
Positive"Theodora in Brooklyn is highly recommended for its food."
Positive"The author shared an update about a brief appearance of a bar seat reservation for The Corner Store on Resy, indicating a potential opportunity."
Neutral
