Wood-fired Mediterranean, exceptional dry-aged fish & breads. A top-tier Brooklyn gem, tough reservation.
Discover Theodora, a highly-rated Fort Greene restaurant specializing in live-fire cooking and dry-aged fish, with the Whole Butterflied Trout being a standout dish.
THEODORA offers a standout Mediterranean dining experience, celebrated for its mastery of live-fire cooking and dry-aged seafood. This Fort Greene hotspot, recognized by Michelin and lauded in food blogs, consistently delivers exceptional dishes, from creative crudos and wood-fired breads to perfectly grilled fish and unique desserts. While reservations can be challenging, the overall consensus points to a memorable and highly recommended culinary journey.
THEODORA specializes in Mediterranean cuisine with a strong emphasis on live-fire cooking and dry-aged fish. Popular dishes include crudos, wood-fired breads (especially sourdough), various fish preparations like trout and black cod, and unique desserts like the Camembert cheesecake. While most feedback is highly positive, a few reviewers found certain dishes, such as the lamb or some desserts, to be overly salty or not to their taste. Reservations are notoriously difficult to obtain.
"The 'two color fish' dish, Hiramasa Crudo, Whipped Ricotta Toast, sourdough, pita, trout, Camembert Cheesecake, and various ceviches are frequently recommended."
Customers overwhelmingly praise THEODORA for its innovative and delicious Mediterranean cuisine, particularly its expertly prepared seafood and wood-fired dishes. While some note the difficulty in securing reservations, the dining experience is consistently described as outstanding and worth the effort.
Important Note
Reservations are notoriously difficult to secure, and some diners have found certain dishes, like the lamb, to be excessively salty. The price-to-portion ratio has also been a point of contention for some.
"The user mentioned Theodora as a potential option for a birthday dinner, indicating it appealed to them as a nice restaurant that would likely serve delicious food, though they were seeking a more unique experience."
Neutral"The original poster expressed cold feet about going to Theodora again, describing it as another 'hipster spot' after a negative experience at Da Toscano."
Negative"After waiting in line for about 30 minutes before opening, the commenter was seated at the bar with a group of four at Theodora and found it to be excellent."
Positive"One commenter stated that Theodora is amazing."
Positive"The commenter successfully walked into Theodora with a party of 4 for dinner on a Tuesday before an event, indicating it's feasible for walk-ins."
Positive"The commenter expressed skepticism about Theodora's existence as a restaurant, questioning if it was more than just reviews and an unavailable reservation page."
Negative"Inquiring about Theodora, the commenter learned that people typically start lining up at 4:30 PM for a 5:00 PM seating."
Neutral"This user recommends Theodora and Potluck Club for their amazing crudo, noting its suitability for those who appreciate acidity."
Positive"The commenter mentioned that the trout dish from Theodora was one of their favorite dishes of the year."
Positive"The commenter recommends collaborations at Theodora's bakery (Thea), mentioning that previous ones have been pricey but outstanding."
Positive"The original poster reiterated that they had a great experience at Theodora, specifically mentioning the bronzino, and enjoyed watching other dishes being served."
Positive"The original poster mentioned lobbying for Theodora, as their experience was great, but it was considered too casual for the occasion. They will consider other options."
Positive"This user added Theodora to their previous recommendations, after learning the user was willing to consider Brooklyn."
Positive"Great things have been heard about Theodora, though the commenter has not personally visited."
Neutral"Theodora is an incredible restaurant and definitely worth the trip."
Positive"Theodora is a new favorite restaurant that the commenter absolutely loved."
Positive"Theodora is recommended as a place to visit."
Positive"Theodora is highly recommended, with specific praise for the Xotimatl Martini, ricotta toast, yellowtail crudo, and fish dishes like whole trout and black cod. Even the vegetable options are noted as worthwhile."
Positive"The user lists Theodora as a place they are considering visiting."
Neutral"The commenter was charmed by their entire experience at Theodora."
Positive
