Famous Irish soda bread & incredible scones w/ potential weekend lines.
This beloved spot is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Irish baked goods, with their famous Irish soda bread and incredibly delicious scones being the stars of the show. Expect a cozy atmosphere that draws in crowds, especially on weekends, so be prepared for a potential wait to snag these highly sought-after treats. It's the kind of place that leaves a lasting impression, making you want to return for just one more bite.
This establishment is renowned for its exceptional Irish soda bread and scones. Many customers rave about the quality and taste, with the scones often described as 'fantastic' and the soda bread as 'the best.' Some patrons have noted potential long wait times, especially on weekends, and one comment expressed that the $30 price for soda bread was excessive.
"The Irish soda bread and scones are consistently recommended and highly praised by customers."
Customers consistently praise the scones and Irish soda bread, often referring to them as "famous" and "the best." While the food receives generally positive feedback, there are some comments about long wait times, particularly on weekends, and one mention of a high price for soda bread.
Important Note
Wait times can be significant, especially on weekends, and they may sell out by early afternoon. One user found the price of soda bread to be excessively high.
"The scones at Mary O's in the East Village are a treat this commenter would return for."
Positive"Mary O's is praised for its great Irish food."
Positive"The user points out that Mary O’s also serves soda bread, but criticizes its price of $30 as excessive."
Negative"Mary O’s is believed to serve only one main item."
Neutral"Arrived at 9:50am on Thursday, there was a short 5 minute wait to order, and then a 15 minute wait for the scone."
Positive"On Thursday, March 27th around 10am, the wait time was 20-30 minutes."
Neutral"They sometimes sell out before 11:30am, other times around 1pm. At 9:30am there was barely a line, but it may be longer by 10am."
Neutral"Provides operational details for Mary O’s scone shop, stating they are open Thursday to Sunday from 7am until they sell out."
Neutral"Recommends getting a scone at Mary O’s scone shop."
Positive"Recommends Mary O’s in the East Village for scones with butter and jam."
Positive"User shares their experience at Mary O's where the butter was served on the scone, not on the side, on two visits. However, they believe a request for no butter would likely be honored."
Neutral"User curtly states that requesting a scone without butter at Mary O's is not possible due to a process issue."
Negative"User describes Mary, presumably the owner of Mary O's, as very sweet and accommodating, suggesting she would likely fulfill the request for no butter. They also mention the butter is usually served on the side."
Positive"User believes the staff at Mary O's are nice and would likely accommodate a request for a scone without butter served alongside it."
Positive"User points out that scones inherently contain butter as an ingredient, regardless of whether extra butter is added when served at Mary O's."
Neutral"User confirms the butter is served on the side with the scones at Mary O's and praises the scones as amazing."
Positive"The original poster notes that Mary O's is known for its famous Irish soda bread loaf while seeking alternative locations."
Positive"Definitely before 10. When I arrived slightly after on a weekend day, it took almost an hour and a half from end of line to receiving the order. (Yes, I know, and no, I wouldn’t do it again.)"
Negative"I've been a few times at around 8 and it was usually 5-10 min wait to place order, then 10 min wait for a single one or 30 min wait for a box. I think they usually sell out around noon-ish."
Neutral