A cozy Irish bakery famous for its legendary scones and soda bread. Don't miss out on these delightful, melt-in-your-mouth treats!
This East Village gem is a must-visit for its authentic Irish baked goods, particularly its renowned scones and Irish soda bread. Customers rave about the quality and taste, often comparing it to cherished childhood memories. While the focus is on these baked staples, some reviews also mention other Irish pub fare like shepherd's pie and pot pies, suggesting a broader appeal beyond just baked goods.
This establishment is celebrated for its exceptional Irish baked goods, with a particular emphasis on scones and Irish soda bread. Many patrons highlight the freshness and authentic flavor, often describing them as some of the best they've ever had. While primarily known for its bakery items, some patrons also enjoy the pub fare, such as shepherd's pie and pot pies.
"The scones, particularly when served with Irish butter and homemade jam, are a highly recommended item. The Irish soda bread is also a celebrated specialty. Shepherd's pie and pot pies are mentioned as other enjoyable options."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the quality and taste of the baked goods, especially the scones and Irish soda bread, often describing them as nostalgic and delicious. There are also positive mentions of other Irish pub fare.
Important Note
There can be long wait times, especially on weekends, and items can sell out early in the day. Some users have reported issues or confusion regarding requests for scones without butter.
"The commenter suggests Mary O's for mushy peas, which are soft and suitable for someone with a wired jaw."
Positive"Mary O's is noted for making a mean scone."
Positive"States that they still dream about the scones purchased from Mary O's during the pandemic."
Positive"Considers Mary O's to have the best Irish Soda Bread, but also notes that Orwashers offers a solid option for those who enjoy raisins and caraway seeds."
Positive"Agrees that the scones from Mary O's are very good but advises getting there early."
Positive"Declares Mary O's as the best place for Irish Soda Bread in the city, significantly better than other options."
Positive"Recommends Mary O's for Irish Soda Bread and suggests trying their scones with Kerrygold butter and homemade blackberry jam."
Positive"Mentions Mary O's as an option for Irish Soda Bread when really in the mood for it, alongside grocery stores."
Positive"Mary-O Scone is suggested as a breakfast option for weekdays."
Positive"Mary O's Irish Pub on Ave A is known for making great Irish soda bread. They also reportedly make killer pot pies."
Positive"This commenter loves Mary O's, emphasizing that they excel at their single offering: Irish butter and homemade jam on a warm scone, advising to go early as it gets busy on weekends."
Positive"This commenter clarifies that Mary O's soda bread is more like a muffin in consistency and sweetness, but is delicious and worth trying."
Positive"The original poster notes that Mary O's has been mentioned multiple times and is being added to their list."
Neutral"This commenter notes that Mary O's, like Sunday Morning, focuses on a single item. They find Mary O's soda bread to be really good."
Positive"This commenter suggests adding Mary O's to the list."
Positive"The scones from Mary O's brought back cherished childhood memories of working with a pastry chef father."
Positive"The warm scone with Irish butter and jam from Mary O’s was highly praised."
Positive"The commenter shares a personal connection to Mary O's owner, describing her as a great person and her family as amazing."
Positive"The author suggests Mary O's as a place that makes a limited amount of goods daily and sells out, implying high quality."
Positive"The author highly recommends Mary O's, emphasizing that a place only selling one item with 5 stars is usually excellent. They describe the homemade soda bread with homemade jam and butter as incredibly good."
Positive
