TLDR
Flaky, buttery scones and authentic Irish soda bread served in a cozy, small-batch bakery setting. A must-visit destination for those craving comfort.
Instagram Posts References
The first stop was Mary O's, a small Irish soda bread shop. The author highlights their gorgeous, steamy warm, and freshly baked blueberry scones, which are their sole offering. The scones were described as having a crispy top, a deliciously rich and fruity blackberry jam filling, and sweet raisins throughout, all complemented by salty Irish butter.
Mary O's Irish Soda Bread Shop is highlighted for its Irish Soda Bread Scones, which are shown as a hearty and comforting baked good. The scone is served split with a generous filling of clotted cream and a vibrant berry jam, suggesting a rich and fruity flavor combination.
Details
Renowned for its dedicated focus on high-quality Irish baked goods, this charming spot has gained a reputation for its exceptional scones and traditional soda bread [1]. Many visitors find the treats nostalgic and well worth the wait [2], with the small-batch production ensuring a consistently delicious experience [3]. While the food is widely celebrated, some diners have noted that service can occasionally be inconsistent [4].
Food Overview
This establishment specializes in Irish-inspired bakery items, most notably their signature scones and soda bread [1]. The scones are frequently described as flaky, soft, and buttery, served with accompaniments like Kerrygold butter and homemade jam [2], while the soda bread is often cited as the best in the city [3]. Beyond baked goods, the menu occasionally features savory options like chicken pot pie [4].
The scones, often served with Irish butter and homemade jam, are the standout recommendation [1]. Customers also highly suggest trying the traditional Irish soda bread [2].
Visitors consistently praise the high quality of the baked goods and the welcoming, nostalgic nature of the food [1]. While the vast majority of feedback is glowing, there have been rare reports of rude or inefficient service [2].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01scones14 mentions
- 02irish soda bread4 mentions
- 03scone3 mentions
- 04soda bread3 mentions
Caveats
The bakery is known for selling out, so visitors are strongly advised to arrive early, ideally before 9 am, to avoid long lines [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MARY O'S
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Im Craving A Good Pot Pie Plz Send
"A pub in the Lower East Side serving highly recommended chicken pot pie."
PositiveFrom post: Best Foodrestaurants With No Gluten Free Options
"Recommended as a bakery with gluten-abundant items."
PositiveFrom post: Salt Hank Phenomenal Sandwich But Very Rude Staff
"Criticized the cashier for being rude and rolling eyes while taking orders."
NegativeFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Scones In
"The user mentions this as one of their winners following a personal scone crawl."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Best Scones In
"The user describes the scones as flaky, soft, buttery, and notes the jam is not too sweet."
Positive