Next.js logo

LITTLE ITALY PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (212) 227-7077

Address: 11 PARK PLACE 10007

TLDR

A reliable NYC-style pizza joint, known for its unique panko crust and late-night availability.

Reddit Sentiment for LITTLE ITALY PIZZA(based on 51 Reddit opinions)

18% Positive65% Neutral18% Negative

Tags

italian 24american 20new york style 4pizza 24sushi 2View All

Neighborhoods

Tribeca

Details

This establishment is a go-to for late-night cravings and quick bites, with a crust that some find particularly appealing due to its panko texture. While opinions are divided, with some lamenting a decline in quality over the years or dismissing it as merely 'drunk food,' others praise specific items like the buffalo chicken pizza and the grandma slice. It's recognized as a reliable option for a New York-style pizza experience, especially in a pinch.

Food Overview

Primarily serving New York-style pizza, this eatery garners mixed reviews. Some patrons appreciate the panko crust and specific offerings like the buffalo chicken pizza and grandma slice, noting it as a reliable option for a quick bite or late-night sustenance. However, others consider it a mediocre choice, with some even referring to it as 'trash' or a '$0.99 shitpost slice,' with a few comments suggesting a decline in quality over time or that it primarily caters to tourists.

Highlights / Recommended

"The buffalo chicken pizza and the grandma slice have been specifically recommended by customers. The panko crust and mozzarella sticks are also noted positively by some."

Customer Sentiment

Customer opinions are mixed, with some praising its consistency and late-night convenience, while others find it to be average or only suitable as a drunk food option.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About LITTLE ITALY PIZZA

This thread discusses the pizza quality, with some commenters praising the panko crust and specific slices like the buffalo chicken pizza. Others find it to be average or only good for late-night consumption.
One commenter specifically highlights the Park Place location as serving some of the best NYC-style takeout pizza, while another user notes its independent ownership predates the chain's expansion.
A notable comment describes the pizza, mozzarella sticks, and garlic knots as surprisingly good when consumed late at night and under the influence. The panko crust texture is also mentioned as a positive attribute.
A debate ensues regarding the correct terminology for a plain cheese pizza slice, with various commenters offering their preferred terms like 'plain' or 'regular' versus 'cheese'.
Some users express a general dissatisfaction, with one calling all locations 'terrible' and another criticizing the use of panko bread crumbs and the impact on neighborhood businesses.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This user used to like the Little Italy Pizza on the Upper West Side for a decent plain slice, but notes that prices have increased and quality seems to have decreased."

Neutral
Aug 31, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"The commenter expresses love for the Park Place Little Italy Pizza, noting its consistency and reliability since 1999."

Positive
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This user states that the Park Place Little Italy Pizza is independently owned and has been in business long before the chain started competing."

Positive
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This user confirms understanding of the sushi deal, initially mistaking it for Chinese takeout combo deals."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter stopped going to Little Italy Pizza after they initially tried to charge $15 for two plain slices late at night, then reduced it to $10 after being questioned."

Negative
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"The commenter clarifies that the Little Italy Pizza on Park Place is a few blocks from Pace but is distinct from another location on Church street, reiterating that the Park Place owners are legitimate."

Positive
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This user states that Little Italy Pizza in Lenox Hill is no better or worse than other options in the area, expressing a desire for better pizza."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"The commenter explains that '3 for $15' refers to deals at sushi places offering three maki rolls for a set price, often including a miso soup, and contrasts this with Chinese takeout combos."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This user asks for clarification on what '3 for $15' refers to in the context of food deals."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"In response to a comment about the Park Place location, this user asks for clarification about whether it's the one by Pace University."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter asserts that no New Yorker calls a cheese pizza slice a 'cheese slice,' preferring 'plain' or 'regular.'"

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter considers Little Italy Pizza to be one of the better options for 'regular street pizza,' acknowledging that while often overpriced, its presence in heavily populated areas is understandable."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter from South Brooklyn notes that while they call it 'plain,' menus usually list it as 'cheese' pizza."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter asserts that 'regular' or 'plain' are the correct terms for a cheese pizza slice."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter expresses confusion about the negative sentiment towards Little Italy Pizza in this subreddit, noting that there are multiple independently owned 'Little Italy Pizzas' and that some people are overly critical of chain restaurants or those in tourist areas."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter dislikes Little Italy Pizza because its 24/7 operation drove out a long-standing neighborhood spot with a better classic slice, and they also dislike the use of panko bread crumbs on the bottom of the pies."

Negative
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This user states that both 'regular' and 'plain' are acceptable terms for a cheese pizza slice in NYC, but 'cheese' is not used."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter specifically likes the Little Italy Pizza on Park Place near the WTC, calling it some of the best takeout NYC-style pizza."

Positive
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This user used to like the Little Italy Pizza on 3rd & 58th, but feels the toppings have declined in quality over the past three years, though the crust remains good."

Neutral
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Anyone Else Feel Like Little Italy Is A Really

"This commenter expresses enjoyment of Little Italy Pizza for late-night delivery."

Positive
Aug 30, 2025View Comment →

More in Tribeca

See all

More italian in NYC

See all