Staten Island's go-to for iconic bar pies & Italian-American classics. A beloved, long-standing spot known for its authentic flavors and welcoming vibe.
Step into a Staten Island institution renowned for its classic American fare with a strong Italian influence. This long-standing establishment is a beloved local spot, often praised for its authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere. It's the kind of place that feels like home, serving up hearty dishes that keep patrons coming back for more.
This Staten Island gem is celebrated for its exceptional pizza, with a strong emphasis on 'bar pies' and 'clam pies' receiving frequent recommendations. While pizza is the main draw, other Italian-American dishes like calamari are also noted. The food generally garners high praise for its authentic taste and quality.
"The bar pie and clam pie are highly recommended, with the calamari also receiving positive mentions. The pizza in general is considered a must-try."
Customers overwhelmingly praise the restaurant for its delicious pizza, particularly the bar pies and clam pies. The overall sentiment is highly positive, highlighting a consistent and enjoyable dining experience.
Important Note
One user noted that while Lee's Tavern's pies are great, Denino's pies might be more consistent.
"This user inquired about the draft Italian Pilsner at Lee's Tavern, indicating it's a crucial part of the experience."
Positive"Following a recommendation for the clam pie, this user expressed eagerness to try it, having previously held out for a New Haven trip for this specific dish."
Positive"The user praised the clam pie at Lee's Tavern, expressing a strong desire to try it."
Positive"This user made a special trip to Lee's Tavern and described it as an entire vibe, noting the excellent pizza and cold beer. They also mentioned a memorable experience during Ozzy Osbourne's death."
Positive"The user has only tried the bar pie at Lee's Tavern and plans to return for a full-size pizza."
Neutral"This user recommends trying the clam pie at Lee's if it's chosen."
Positive"This user recommends Lee's as a great pizza option in Staten Island."
Positive"Lees Tavern on Staten Island was recommended for its calamari, offering a spicy tomato sauce and generous portions, similar to Deninos."
Positive"The user lists Lee's Tavern as one of the definitive answers for good pizza."
Positive"The user praises Lee's Tavern on Staten Island, emphasizing Staten Island's consistently strong pizza scene for decades."
Positive"The user simply recommends Lees Tavern."
Positive"The user recommends Lee's Tavern as a good pizza spot."
Positive"Considers Denino's pies more consistent than Lee's Tavern, but thinks both are great."
Positive"Recommends Lee's Tavern in Staten Island for bar pies."
Positive
