TLDR
A historic Halal Jewish deli serving tender, classic brisket and corned beef since the 1960s. A unique Brooklyn gem known for its authentic, old-school flavor profiles.
Reddit Sentiment for DAVID'S BRISKET HOUSE(based on 17 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
David's Brisket House Deli, established in the 1960s on Nostrand Ave, is highlighted as one of New York's oldest delis. Despite the passage of time, the deli has maintained its original recipes. The reviewer praises their classic Reuben sandwich, which features tender cuts of corned beef. They also offer a delicious brisket sandwich served on rye bread with a side of gravy. A standout is their unique Brooklyn Cheese sandwich, which is made with brisket chopped in a Philly-style, combined with peppers and onions, and then topped with their gravy and cheese whiz, served in a sub roll.
Details
Operating since the 1960s, this historic Brooklyn institution is celebrated as one of the city's oldest delis, uniquely blending tradition as a Halal Jewish deli [1], [2]. While long-time fans praise its classic, tender brisket and corned beef recipes [1], [3], recent years have seen mixed reports regarding shifts in management and service consistency [4], [5]. Despite these fluctuations, the menu remains a valued destination for authentic, high-quality deli staples [6], [7].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic deli meats, specifically celebrated for its tender brisket, flavorful pastrami, and corned beef sandwiches [1], [3]. While many items are highly recommended, the 'Brooklyn Cheese' sandwich—a unique Philly-style brisket creation with gravy and cheese whiz—is a standout, though concerns about food safety and consistency have been raised by some patrons in recent times [1], [5].
Highlights / Recommended
"The classic corned beef sandwich and the unique 'Brooklyn Cheese' sandwich—which features chopped brisket, peppers, onions, and cheese whiz—are highly recommended by patrons [1]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •pastrami sandwich(2)
- •brisket sandwich(2)
Caveats
Some customers have reported a decline in the overall experience and raised concerns regarding management and food safety following changes in the restaurant's operations [4], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DAVID'S BRISKET HOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Best Pastrami In Brooklyn Help
"The commenter confirms it remains reasonably good."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Best Pastrami In Brooklyn Help
"The commenter enjoyed it in the past but has not visited recently."
NeutralFrom post: Where Would You Go As Your Last Meal In Nyc
"A corned beef sandwich with a Dr. Brown's cream soda from David's Brisket House was a close second for lunch in the commenter's 'last meal' plan."
PositiveFrom post: Brisket For Passover
"This commenter inquired about David's Brisket House potentially being closed by the health department, but later updated that it appears to have an 'A' rating."
NeutralFrom post: Brisket For Passover
"The original poster expressed unfamiliarity with David's Brisket House after it was recommended."
NeutralFrom post: Brisket For Passover
"This commenter suggested David's Brisket House as an option for brisket."
NeutralFrom post: How Is This Sandwich 27 At Pastrami Queen
"This user recommended David's Brisket House as a good value option for pastrami sandwiches."
NeutralFrom post: How Is This Sandwich 27 At Pastrami Queen
"This user inquired about David's Brisket House, noting it's a halal Jewish deli and seemed like good value."
NeutralFrom post: Recommendations For Jewish Diners Across All The
"This commenter emphatically agrees with the recommendation for David's Brisket House."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Jewish Diners Across All The
"This user expresses being a big fan of David's."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Jewish Diners Across All The
"This comment recommends David's Brisket House."
PositiveFrom post: The Best Food With The Worst Vibes
"This user reports that David's Brisket House's quality decreased after new management took over and the family became less involved, leading to food safety concerns and illness."
NegativeFrom post: The Best Food With The Worst Vibes
"The commenter feels the service at David's Brisket House declined after the family operating it stopped being as involved."
NegativeFrom post: The Best Food With The Worst Vibes
"This commenter lists David's Brisket House as a place with good food but potentially bad vibes."
NeutralFrom post: Halalkosher Food Nyc
"David's Brisket house in Bed Stuy is mentioned as a Halal Jewish Deli option."
PositiveFrom post: The Tiktokification Of Nyc Restaurants
"The user observed food critic Robert Sietsema at David's Brisket House, recognizing him as a legitimate NYC food critic."
Positive