Unique regional finds & out-of-this-world sandwiches; a must-try Brooklyn spot.
This Brooklyn eatery is a standout for its exceptional sandwiches, offering unique regional finds like IT'S-IT ice cream sandwiches that customers rave about. While praised for consistent quality, some note the sandwiches can be on the pricier side. Despite minor criticisms about value, the overall consensus points to delicious and memorable sandwich experiences, with a notable return to form after past quality concerns.
The restaurant is highly praised for its sandwiches, with specific mentions of a great BLT and 'out of this world' sandwich quality. They also carry unique regional items like IT'S-IT ice cream sandwiches. While most reviews are positive, some find the sandwiches pricey, and a few haven't been overly impressed, though quality is reported to have improved.
"The BLT is specifically mentioned as being great, and any sandwich that catches your eye is likely a good choice. The restaurant also carries IT'S-IT ice cream sandwiches."
Customers generally praise the unique regional items and sandwiches, with some noting they are expensive but high quality. While some recent reviews indicate a return to quality after a dip during COVID, a few find it doesn't live up to the hype.
Important Note
Some customers find the sandwiches to be on the expensive side, with prices around $17-$20. One reviewer noted a dip in quality during COVID regarding stale bread, but has since found it has improved.
"The poster tried 'Uncle Chucky' from Court Street Grocers in Williamsburg."
Neutral"Court Street Grocers was listed among several other sandwich shops and bakeries as a recommended spot."
Positive"A commenter recommended Court Street Grocers, stating that whatever sandwich sounds appealing is likely a good choice."
Positive"This commenter briefly recommended Court Street Grocers."
Positive"Court Street Grocers was recommended with a specific mention of their roast beef sandwich."
Positive"Court Street Grocers is mentioned as a great sandwich spot."
Positive"This user had previously stopped visiting Court St Grocers due to stale bread during Covid but happily reported that the quality has bounced back and recent visits have been great."
Positive"This user stated that Court St Grocers has been their favorite city sandwich spot for years and offers great options for vegetarians."
Positive"This user found Court St Grocers' sandwiches to be very solid and consistent, but felt the restaurant didn't belong on the NYT list."
Neutral"This user, living near Court St, noted that everyone raves about Court St Grocers, but they personally weren't blown away by the sandwich they tried and felt they needed to visit again."
Neutral"Highly recommended ('no doubt') for bagels on the Brooklyn side."
Positive"User recommends checking out Court Street Grocers, stating their sandwiches are 'out of this world'."
Positive"The sandwiches are good but expensive, costing around $17-$20."
Neutral"Recommends Court Street Grocers in Carroll Gardens."
Positive"Court Street grocer in Brooklyn has IT'S-IT ice cream. Banging sandwiches too."
Positive"Court Street Grocers have some of the best weird regional stuff"
Positive"Found IT'S-IT ice cream cookie sandwiches at Court Street Grocer in Carroll Gardens."
Positive"Court Street Grocers has a great BLT, but tomatoes are gonna be trash until August."
Positive
