TLDR
Classic, authentic Italian pasticceria featuring superior cookies, heavenly cheesecakes, and custom cakes in an old-school Brooklyn setting.
Details
This quintessential Brooklyn bakery is highly regarded for its authentic pasticceria and old-school Italian atmosphere [10]. Patrons consistently praise the high quality of their artisanal cookies, cheesecakes, and specialty custom cakes [4], [6], [10], [13]. It serves as an excellent, value-conscious alternative to other local shops, offering a wide array of treats that make a trip to Carroll Gardens well worth the effort [5], [6], [10].
Food Overview
Specializing in traditional Italian baked goods, this spot is a favorite for its wide selection of cookies, including pignoli, almond, and sesame varieties [6], [9]. Customers specifically recommend the pistachio balls, amaretti di assello, and their rich, classic cheesecakes [4], [10]. Additionally, the shop is praised for its delicious custom cakes and provides a budget-friendly option for high-quality key lime pie [5], [13].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended treats include the pistachio balls, amaretti di assello, diverse Italian cookies, cheesecakes, and custom cakes [4], [6], [10], [13]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •amaretti di assello(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customer feedback is overwhelmingly positive, with visitors frequently highlighting the bakery's high-quality desserts and authentic, nostalgic charm [4], [6], [10]. While some suggest calling ahead to confirm the availability of specific items, the overall reputation is that of a reliable and top-tier neighborhood institution [12].
Caveats
Patrons are advised to call ahead before visiting if they are seeking a specific pastry to confirm its current availability [12].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MONTELEONE BAKERY CAFE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Can I Find Good Italian Bakery Cookies In
"Recommended as a top spot for cookies if one is willing to travel to Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Is There A Bakery Who Can Make This Kind Of Cake
"The user suggested this bakery for custom cakes and mentioned that their cakes are delicious."
PositiveFrom post: Does Anyone Know Where In Nyc Or Staten Island I
"A commenter suggested checking Montelleone in Carroll Gardens, advising to call ahead to confirm availability of the pastry."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For The Best Classic Cheesecake In Nyc
"This user listed Pasticceria Monteleone as one of several recommended cheesecake places."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For The Best Classic Cheesecake In Nyc
"This user recommended Monteleone's in Carroll Gardens for its heavenly cheesecakes and old-school Brooklyn Italian atmosphere."
PositiveFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"In response to a recommendation for Monteleone, the commenter praised their sesame cookies, especially when paired with espresso."
PositiveFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter noted that if cookies have the same price per pound, they can be mixed and matched, and customers don't need to buy a full pound. They mentioned getting just three rainbow cookies from Court Street Bakery and that other bakeries like Circo's and Monteleone allow custom assortments by weight."
NeutralFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter recommended Monteleone as an alternative to Court Street Bakery, noting it has better Italian cookies, especially those with marzipan or almond flour like pignoli."
PositiveFrom post: How Do You Order Those Little Italian Cookies At
"The commenter suggested walking down the street to Monteleone as another option."
NeutralFrom post: Best Key Lime Pie In Nyc
"This user noted that Pasticceria Monteleone BK on Court St makes a good Key Lime Pie for $18, contrasting it with Steve's $45 price."
PositiveFrom post: Cobble Hill Carrol Gardens Food Crawl 104 At 4 Pm
"The commenter recommended Monteleone's as a superior bakery option. They specifically praised their pistachio balls and amaretti di assello."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Cannoli Recommendations Had An
"Recommends Monteleone's in Carroll Gardens, noting it might not be near the visitor's likely location."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Cannoli Recommendations Had An
"Recommends Monteleone's on Court St in Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Give Me Your Favorite Pasticceria Or Place With
"This user suggests Monteleone for pasticceria, implying it's an option if not wanting to go to Brooklyn."
Positive