TLDR
Authentic, old-school Brooklyn Italian bakery specializing in heavenly cheesecakes and exceptional assorted cookies. A go-to destination for high-quality, traditional pasticceria.
Details
A cornerstone of the Carroll Gardens community, this authentic, old-school Brooklyn Italian bakery is widely celebrated for its high-quality desserts and traditional atmosphere [7]. Visitors consistently praise the establishment for its superior selection of pastries, cheesecakes, and custom cakes [7], [10]. It is frequently cited as a top-tier destination for Italian cookies, offering excellent value and flexibility for custom assortments [3], [5].
Food Overview
This bakery specializes in authentic Italian baked goods, with rave reviews for its pistachio balls, amaretti di assello, and various almond-based cookies like pignoli [1], [3]. Customers also highly recommend their cheesecakes and delicious custom cakes, noting that the shop allows for convenient custom assortments of cookies by weight [3], [5], [7], [10]. Additionally, the shop is a notable spot for affordable options like their key lime pie [2].
Highly recommended items include the pistachio balls, amaretti di assello, and a variety of almond-based Italian cookies [1], [3]. Patrons also frequently praise the cheesecake and custom cakes [7], [10].
Feedback for this bakery is overwhelmingly positive, with patrons frequently recommending it as a superior choice for authentic Italian treats [1], [3]. Customers appreciate the high quality of the food and the traditional, old-school atmosphere of the shop [7], [10].
Most Mentioned Dishes
- 01amaretti di assello2 mentions
Caveats
Patrons are advised to call ahead to confirm the availability of specific pastries before visiting [9].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MONTELEONE BAKERY CAFE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Longing For Chicken Riggies And Utica Greens
"A bakery in Carroll Gardens recommended for finding seasonal baked goods."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find Good Italian Bakery Cookies In
"Recommended as a top spot for cookies if one is willing to travel to Brooklyn."
PositiveFrom post: Is There A Bakery Who Can Make This Kind Of Cake
"The user suggested this bakery for custom cakes and mentioned that their cakes are delicious."
PositiveFrom post: Does Anyone Know Where In Nyc Or Staten Island I
"A commenter suggested checking Montelleone in Carroll Gardens, advising to call ahead to confirm availability of the pastry."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For The Best Classic Cheesecake In Nyc
"This user listed Pasticceria Monteleone as one of several recommended cheesecake places."
Neutral