Next.js logo

SULLIVAN STREET BAKERY

Last Updated: 3 months ago

Phone: (212) 929-5900

Address: 236 9 AVENUE 10001

TLDR

Authentic Italian & American bakery - known for amazing, affordable pizza slices & incredible bomboloni. A true gem!

Sentiment Overview(Based on 8 Reddit comments)

100% Positive

Achievements and Accolades

Next.js logo

Tags

italian 5american 3pizza 5bakery 2bread 2View All

Neighborhoods

Chelsea

Details

This beloved bakery is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Italian and American baked goods. Renowned for its exceptional pizza slices, affordable and filling, it also offers delightful pastries like bomboloni. The atmosphere is praised for its unique charm, making it a standout spot for a casual yet delicious meal.

Food Overview

The bakery specializes in Italian and American baked goods, with a strong emphasis on their pizza, which is frequently recommended for its taste and value, with two slices making a filling meal around $5 each. Pastries, specifically bomboloni, are also highly praised as excellent. The food is consistently described as delicious and authentic.

Highlights / Recommended

"The pizza slices are highly recommended for their great taste and affordability, with two slices often being a filling and satisfying meal. Additionally, the bomboloni are noted as being excellent pastries."

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise the bakery for its delicious and authentic Italian-American offerings, particularly highlighting the pizza and pastries. The affordability and quality of the food contribute to a very positive customer experience.

Reddit References

Highlighted Posts

This post highlights the bakery's affordable pizza slices, noting that two slices for around $5 each make a filling meal. It's a strong recommendation for a quick and satisfying lunch.
In this discussion about donut delivery, the bakery is recommended, and their bomboloni are specifically praised as excellent. It suggests this as a great alternative for delicious pastries.
This post includes the bakery in a list of recommendations for casual solo dining in the West Chelsea/Hudson Yards area, suggesting it as a solid option for bakery items and bread.
The bakery is directly recommended in this thread for its pizza, with a specific mention of 'Sullivan St Pizza in Chelsea'.
This post includes a suggestion for the bakery, mentioning both pizza slices and a connection to a 'Halal cart experience', indicating its versatility.
This comment recommends the bakery as a favorite spot for both pastries and pizza within the context of planning a bakery crawl.

Recent Mentions

From post: Donut Delivery Thats Not Doughnut Plant

"The commenter inquired whether Sullivan St Bakery in Chelsea delivers and praised their bomboloni as excellent."

Positive
Oct 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Casual Solo Eats West Chelseahudson Yards

"Sullivan St Bakery is listed as a recommendation."

Positive
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: 24 Hrs In Nyc Whats Your Favorite Spot In This

"The commenter suggests trying a couple of pizza slices from this bakery."

Positive
Aug 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: 24 Hrs In Nyc Whats Your Favorite Spot In This

"This bakery is suggested for a Halal cart experience and also mentions pizza slices."

Positive
Aug 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Focaccia Or Stecca Based Sandwiches In Nyc

"Sullivan St Pizza in Chelsea is recommended."

Positive
Apr 10, 2025View Comment →

From post: Quick Lunch Hudson Yards

"User strongly agrees with the recommendation for Sullivan Street Bakery."

Positive
Apr 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Quick Lunch Hudson Yards

"Recommends Sullivan Street Bakery for its affordable pizza slices, noting that two slices for around $5 each make a filling meal."

Positive
Apr 7, 2025View Comment →

From post: Planning A Bakery Crawl

"Recommends Sullivan Street Bakery for pastries and pizza as a favorite spot."

Positive
Mar 30, 2025View Comment →