Vintage vibes meet killer Tex-Mex! Standout tacos, house-made tortillas, and a legendary Texas sheet cake.
This East Village spot, despite its Texas-inspired name, offers a distinctive vintage atmosphere with weathered wood and stained-glass chandeliers. It's a bustling eatery specializing in Tex-Mex cuisine, particularly renowned for its tacos and creative cocktails. The house-made flour tortillas are a standout, forming the base for delicious fillings, and the Texas sheet cake is a must-try dessert.
The restaurant excels in Tex-Mex cuisine, with many patrons highlighting the tacos and house-made flour tortillas. The Texas sheet cake is frequently recommended, with some even considering it a 'death row dessert.' Other popular items include queso, weekend donuts, and their Caesar salad with a tomatillo dressing. However, some diners have found certain tacos, like the bean and cheese, to be mediocre or too salty, and one commenter noted a perceived decline in quality over the years.
Customers generally praise the unique atmosphere and the quality of Tex-Mex offerings, especially tacos and desserts. While many find it delicious and a great spot for a good time, a few have noted inconsistencies or found it not quite living up to the hype compared to Tex-Mex from its home state.
"This user reassured that Yellow Rose is not upscale and has incredible food."
Positive"This commenter confirmed that Yellow Rose serves very good mole enchiladas, having tried them about a month prior."
Positive"This commenter stated that Yellow Rose is not that upscale and is a good spot for casual drinks."
Positive"This Texan commenter found Yellow Rose to be mediocre compared to Javelina."
Negative"The original poster considered Yellow Rose but was concerned it might be too upscale based on online photos."
Neutral"Yellow Rose is suggested as a potential place for mole enchiladas."
Neutral"Yellow Rose is recommended as a spot in the East Village (EV) for great Tex Mex, suggested as an alternative for someone looking for a place similar to Tortilla Flats."
Positive"Responding to a critique, this commenter believes Yellow Rose's food 'fucking slaps' and asks about their salsa."
Positive"This commenter enjoys Yellow Rose for its breakfast tacos and fresh tortillas, noting it doesn't have an 'authentic' Mexican vibe but is still a great spot for specific items."
Positive"In response to disappointment, this commenter asks what was ordered and praises the steak fajita and queso at Yellow Rose."
Positive"Having grown up with Tex-Mex, this commenter was very disappointed with Yellow Rose."
Negative"The commenter reiterates that Yellow Rose has excellent tacos and criticizes Redditors for being pedantic about food authenticity."
Positive"This commenter suggests Yellow Rose, stating it surpasses other listed options and defends Tex-Mex as a valid form of Mexican cuisine."
Positive"The user recommended the skillet cornbread from Yellow Rose."
Neutral"Yellow Rose in the East Village is described as Tex-Mex and noted for doing many corn dishes, both savory and sweet."
Neutral"This user recommended Yellow Rose in response to a query about queso."
Positive"This commenter listed Yellow Rose as one of the Tex Mex places in the city that are often recommended, suggesting it might have items similar to what the original poster is looking for."
Positive"After considering various options, the author chose Yellow Rose for Mexican food. While the bean and cheese tacos were not as good as previous experiences, the guacamole and enchiladas tejanas were great."
Positive"This commenter noted a decline in quality at Yellow Rose over the past few years, finding it overpriced and not as good. They still enjoy the vegan queso, despite not being vegan themselves."
Negative"This commenter stated they only enjoy the breakfast tacos at Yellow Rose."
Neutral
