TLDR
A divisive pizza joint known for its ultra-rich Artichoke slice – love it or hate it, it's unforgettable. Also try the Vodka or Crab slices!
Reddit Sentiment for ARTICHOKE BASILLE'S PIZZA(based on 19 Reddit opinions)
Details
Artichoke Basille's Pizza is a unique spot in New York City that sparks intense debate among pizza lovers. While some dismiss their signature Artichoke slice as an overpriced, soupy mess, others champion it as an incredibly rich and satisfying experience, perfect for those who love artichoke dip. It's a place where opinions are strong, with many suggesting that the Vodka or Crab slices are the safer, more universally appealing bets. Beyond the polarizing pizza, adventurous eaters might also find delight in their meatballs, which come with a recommendation, albeit with a potential wait. It's a culinary adventure, and you'll likely know if you're a fan after just one bite.
Food Overview
This Italian and American cuisine restaurant is known for its unique pizza offerings. The signature Artichoke Pizza slice receives a wide range of reactions, with many finding it an acquired taste, comparing it to soup or a bread bowl filled with artichoke dip, and deeming it overrated. However, a strong contingent of customers genuinely enjoy its richness and unique flavor profile. The Vodka Pizza slice and Crab Pizza slice are frequently recommended as better options, with the Vodka slice being described as "pretty fucking good." The Margherita slice also garners some positive mentions. For those seeking non-pizza options, the meatballs are highly recommended, though may involve a wait. Some reviews note a decline in quality over the years and a very sweet red sauce on some pies, while white pies are considered unremarkable by some.
Highlights / Recommended
"The Artichoke slice is a polarizing signature, but many recommend trying the Vodka slice or Crab slice. The meatballs are also highly recommended."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •artichoke slice(6)
- •vodka slice(2)
- •margherita slice(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customer feedback on Artichoke Basille's Pizza is highly polarized, with a significant portion finding it overrated and describing it as "gross" or like "soup" or a "bowl of artichoke dip." Some criticize the sweetness of the red sauce and find the white pies unremarkable for the price. Conversely, a notable number of customers find the Artichoke slice to be "insanely good" and rich, with some even considering it a "last meal" slice. The Vodka slice and Crab slice also receive positive mentions, with one user calling the Vodka slice "pretty fucking good." The quality is sometimes described as "hit-or-miss" and potentially influenced by late-night consumption.
Caveats
Some customers feel the quality has declined over the years and that the pizza can be messy or too saucy. The experience may also be influenced by the time of consumption, with some finding it better when drunk.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter finds Artichoke Basille's overrated, criticizing the very sweet red sauce and unremarkable white pies for the price."
NegativeFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"Labeling it 'abomination pizza', this commenter still eats Artichoke sometimes for a 'worthwhile shameful sin', comparing it to a bread bowl soup."
NegativeFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter thinks Artichoke pizza is overrated due to having too much sauce and being messy to eat."
NegativeFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This user really likes Artichoke's vodka square slice and crab slice, but finds their other offerings mediocre ('meh')."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This user suggests getting the Vodka slice at Artichoke, calling it the only decent one and actually 'pretty fucking good' (at least historically)."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This user considers Artichoke underrated because people order the wrong slice (Artichoke) and should get the Vodka slice instead, claiming it's good."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This user agrees the Artichoke slice is insanely good and incredibly filling, almost a 'last meal' kind of slice due to its richness."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"A commenter suggests eating inside the Brooklyn Artichoke location and asking for well-done makes the pizza perfect. They also highly recommend the meatballs, despite the wait."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter agrees that the Margherita slice at Artichoke Basille's is pretty good."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"Even when drunk, this commenter doesn't want to eat what they describe as a bowl of artichoke dip served like pizza."
NegativeFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"A commenter finds Artichoke Basille's Staten Island slice 'decent' and the Margherita slice also good."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This user also likes the Artichoke pizza and was surprised to learn many people dislike it, thinking it was very popular."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"Acknowledging it's different from traditional pizza like Scarr's, this commenter finds the Artichoke slice fantastic, questioning how one couldn't enjoy bread with cream and cheese."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This user agrees with the description of Artichoke pizza being like eating soup."
NegativeFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This user feels Artichoke pizza has declined over the past decade, now being 'hit-or-miss', though admits their past enjoyment might have been influenced by late-night, drunken visits."
NeutralFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"Defying the negative sentiment, this commenter admits to actually liking the Artichoke slice, finding it satisfying ('slaps') if you enjoy artichoke dip."
PositiveFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"Eating Artichoke pizza is compared to eating soup by this commenter."
NegativeFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"This commenter describes Artichoke pizza as the worst when sober but the best when drunk."
NeutralFrom post: The Most Underrated And Overrated Pizza In Nyc
"User deems Artichoke Basille the most overrated pizza, calling it 'gross' but acknowledging its tourist appeal."
Negative