Where is Pizza Secret located?

Park Slope, 5 AVENUE, New York City

PIZZA SECRET

Name: Pizza Secret
Address: 72 5 AVENUE, New York City, 11217, US
Telephone: 9293376245
Rating: 3.7

Updated 6 months ago

Phone: (929) 337-6245

Address: 72 5 AVENUE 11217

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, with a pasta dish that's a local favorite. Brooklyn's hidden gem.

Reddit Sentiment for PIZZA SECRET(based on 3 Reddit opinions)

33% Positive67% Neutral

Neighborhoods

Park Slope

Details

This Brooklyn pizzeria offers a unique Italian dining experience, with a focus on authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas. While the pizzas are highly regarded, some patrons lean towards their flavorful pasta dishes, particularly the pesto pasta, as a standout option.

Food Overview

The restaurant is known for its pizzas, particularly those in the Neapolitan style. However, one popular recommendation is the pasta with pesto, which some find even more appealing than the pizzas. The cuisine is primarily Italian.

Highlights / Recommended

The quick take

The pasta with pesto is a highly recommended dish, with some customers preferring it over the pizzas.

Customer Sentiment

What diners are saying

Customers generally have a positive view of the restaurant, with a particular fondness for their pasta dishes over their pizzas.

Caveats

The restaurant may have been closed for repairs at one point.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Question Wheres The Best Neapolitanstyle Pizza

"This user's favorite is Pizza Secret in Brooklyn, though they are currently closed for repairs."

Positive

Mar 31, 2026View Comment →

From post: Need A Rec For Saturday Dinner Les Looking For

"User recommended Pizza Secret."

Neutral

Dec 19, 2025View Comment →

From post: Restaurants Near Barclays

"Pizza Secret is considered good, though the commenter personally prefers their pasta with pesto over their pizzas."