Next.js logo

GOOEY ON THE INSIDE COOKIES

Updated

Phone: (917) 651-7581

Address: 163 CHRYSTIE STREET 10002

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Warm, gooey cookies w/ happy hour specials. A must-try for cookie lovers, though pricey.

Reddit Sentiment for GOOEY ON THE INSIDE COOKIES(based on 9 Reddit opinions)

33% Positive44% Neutral22% Negative

Tags

bakery 4american 4cookies 6baked goods 2View All

Neighborhoods

Lower East Side

Details

Indulge in the warm, gooey, and utterly decadent cookies from this beloved bakery. While some find the regular price a bit steep, a happy hour special offers a more affordable way to enjoy these highly-rated treats. They're known for their soft, baked-from-warmth cookies, a perfect stop for a sweet craving.

Food Overview

The bakery specializes in cookies, with a particular emphasis on a warm, gooey, and soft texture. While many enjoy the rich flavor, some find the cookies to be slightly underbaked for their preference. The regular price of $8.15 per cookie is noted as expensive, but a happy hour special offers them for around $5.

Highlights / Recommended

While specific dishes aren't highlighted, customers rave about the warm, gooey cookies. The happy hour special is recommended as a more budget-friendly way to enjoy them.

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the cookies, often highlighting their warm and gooey texture. Some find the regular price to be high, but acknowledge the value of the happy hour deal.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About GOOEY ON THE INSIDE COOKIES

Ranking 15 NYC Chocolate Chip Cookies
This post ranks the chocolate chip cookie from Gooey on the Inside at #8, praising its thickness but noting its high price and slightly raw interior.
Best Cookies in New York City
Commenters enjoyed the cookies, specifically mentioning how the warmth on a cold day enhanced the experience and texture.
Help me dial down my list for my trip
This comment mentions the cookies are expensive at $8 each but offers a happy hour special around $5. It's suggested as a good option if you're nearby, but not necessarily a destination on its own.
Crunchy/hard cookies recs?
This discussion mentions Gooey on the Inside as a popular cookie spot, noting their cookies are soft and gooey, which might not appeal to those seeking a crunchy texture.
Where can I get a Lotus Biscoff stuffed cookie in NYC?
A brief mention of Gooey on the Inside in the LES in response to a query about Lotus Biscoff stuffed cookies.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Crunchyhard Cookies Recs

"The commenter previously visited Gooey on the Inside when it was near MacDougal and found the cookies soft and gooey, which was not to their father's liking."

Negative
Nov 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Crunchyhard Cookies Recs

"Gooey on the Inside is a popular cookie spot not too far from Chinatown and is worth a try, though it's not a crunchy cookie."

Positive
Nov 12, 2025View Comment →

From post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip

"This commenter noted that Gooey on The Inside Cookies is expensive at $8 per cookie, but offers a happy hour special for around $5. They felt it's not worth planning a tourist trip around the savings but is good to know if nearby."

Neutral
Sep 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Help Me Dial Down My List For My Trip

"This commenter noted that Gooey on The Inside Cookies is expensive at $8 per cookie, but offers a happy hour special for around $5. They felt it's not worth planning a tourist trip around the savings but is good to know if nearby."

Neutral
Sep 9, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where Can I Get A Lotusbiscoff Stuffed Cookie In

"Gooey on the Inside in LES"

Neutral
Feb 28, 2025View Comment →

More in Lower East Side

See all

More Bakery in NYC

See all