TLDR
Late-night bakery w/ vast cake selection, known for Berry Napoleon & vegan treats; some critique quality/atmosphere.
Reddit Sentiment for MARTHA'S COUNTRY BAKERY(based on 64 Reddit opinions)
Details
This Brooklyn bakery is a popular spot known for its wide array of cakes and desserts, often recommended for late-night treats [1]. While many rave about specific items like the Berry Napoleon, chocolate mousse cake, and vegan options [2], [3], some diners find the quality inconsistent, with occasional dry cakes or stale cookies [4]. The atmosphere is described as very bright, possibly more suited for children's celebrations [5].
Food Overview
Martha's Country Bakery offers a wide variety of cakes and desserts, with particular highlights including the Berry Napoleon, chocolate mousse cake, and vegan options [2], [3]. However, some customers report issues with dryness and staleness [4], with one user comparing the quality to supermarket baked goods [5]. It's also noted for having many chocolate cake choices and a recommended Neapolitan cake [6].
Caveats
Some customers have reported a decline in quality over time, with criticisms focusing on dry cakes, stale cookies, and the use of what's perceived as cheap ingredients. It's advised to inquire about the freshness of specific items, such as the cherries on chocolate cake.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MARTHA'S COUNTRY BAKERY
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Red Velvet With Cream Cheese Frosting
"A user recommended Martha's Country Bakery as the most reliable place they've found recently for red velvet slice."
PositiveFrom post: Best Red Velvet With Cream Cheese Frosting
"A user stated that while Martha's might not be the absolute best, they do offer cream cheese frosting and the cake isn't stale, noting it's their favorite and hard to find elsewhere, with a dislike for buttercream."
PositiveFrom post: Best Homemade Chocolate Coulant In New York City
"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery as a place with a good chocolate coulant."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Classic Black Forest Cake
"A user noted that Martha's Country Bakery has solid chocolate cake, but the cherries can be dry, suggesting to ask about the freshness of the day's batch."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For Classic Black Forest Cake
"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery."
NeutralFrom post: Best Not Too Sweet Strawberry Shortcake In Nyc
"This bakery was mentioned as a place to consider for a cake."
NeutralFrom post: Best Carrot Cake In The City
"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery's carrot cake, stating it's so good."
PositiveFrom post: Best Carrot Cake In The City
"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery's carrot cake, calling it very good."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Find The Most Fudgy And Dense Cake
"Marthas Country Bakery was recommended in response to a query about cake."
PositiveFrom post: I Wish There Were More Cute Nonalcoholictreat
"This user expressed a negative opinion about Martha's, describing their products as supermarket quality and the decor as faux country."
NegativeFrom post: I Wish There Were More Cute Nonalcoholictreat
"The Martha's location in Bayside is open until 1 AM."
PositiveFrom post: I Wish There Were More Cute Nonalcoholictreat
"This user commented that Martha's has delicious cake."
PositiveFrom post: I Wish There Were More Cute Nonalcoholictreat
"The original poster finds Martha's Country Bakery to be a good option for late-night, non-alcoholic treats, appreciating its location, quality of goods, portion sizes relative to price, and weekday specials. They specifically note its value as a charming spot open late for post-event relaxation."
PositiveFrom post: Best Place To Get A Strawberry Shortcake That Is
"This user suggests that Martha's Country Bakery might have old-school strawberry shortcake."
PositiveFrom post: Cheesecake Factoryesque Cheesecake In Manhattan
"User agreed with the Martha's Country Bakery suggestion and specifically praised their peanut butter cheesecake."
PositiveFrom post: Cheesecake Factoryesque Cheesecake In Manhattan
"Martha's Country Bakery in Williamsburg or Astoria was suggested for its layered cake and cheesecake slices, including flavors like brownie and Oreo."
PositiveFrom post: Best Slice Of Cake Youve Ever Had In Nyc
"Martha's Bakery cheesecake is a favorite of this user."
PositiveFrom post: Best Slice Of Cake Youve Ever Had In Nyc
"The triple chocolate mousse cake from Martha's Country Bakery is recommended and enjoyed by the slice."
PositiveFrom post: Best Slice Of Cake Youve Ever Had In Nyc
"Martha's Country Bakery chocolate fudge cake is highly praised."
PositiveFrom post: Dessert Spots With Spacious Indoor Seating In
"The commenter recommended Martha's Country Bakery, noting that both of its Williamsburg locations offer ample indoor seating."
Positive