Last Updated: 28 days ago
Phone: (718) 599-0900
Address: 263 BEDFORD AVENUE 11211
Beloved Brooklyn bakery w/ polarizing reviews: some rave about stellar cheesecake & strawberry shortcake, others critique as overly sweet & low-quality.
This Brooklyn bakery is a popular spot for desserts, with a notable reputation for its cakes and other baked goods. While many customers appreciate the wide variety and specific items like their strawberry shortcake and cheesecake, a significant portion of feedback suggests that the desserts can be overly sweet and of inconsistent quality. Some reviews even go as far as to call the offerings subpar and lacking in quality ingredients.
This bakery is known for its wide selection of desserts and cakes. While some customers rave about items like their strawberry shortcake and cheesecake, others find the baked goods to be too sweet, dry, and of poor quality, with some speculating the use of oil instead of butter. The Neapolitan cake and crumb cake have been specifically recommended by some.
"Customers have specifically recommended the crumb cake, Neapolitan cake, strawberry shortcake, and cheesecake."
Customer opinions on this establishment are highly divided. While some praise specific items like their strawberry shortcake and cheesecake, others are highly critical, describing the desserts as overly sweet, dry, and made with low-quality ingredients.
Important Note
Some customers find the baked goods to be overly sweet and of questionable quality, with one user suggesting the use of oil instead of butter.
"The user recommended Harbs and Little Cupcake Bakeshop. They also mentioned Martha's Country Bakery if a location is convenient."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery was suggested as an option for a delicious red velvet birthday cake."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is recommended for its late hours (until 1 AM) and entertainment, noting it's a large venue."
Positive"The user reiterates their negative experience with Martha's, noting that their cupcakes and cakes lacked buttercream and instead used oil."
Negative"Martha's Country Bakery is described as bad, with cakes often being dry and cookies stale."
Negative"Martha's Country Bakery is suggested as a place open late with entertainment."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is criticized for using cheap ingredients and having a very bright atmosphere, suggesting it's more suitable for children's cakes than a destination experience."
Negative"Martha's Country Bakery is another option open until midnight or 1 AM, with many chocolate cake choices. The Neapolitan cake is specifically recommended."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is recommended for crumb cake, with an additional note that they also offer great bread pudding and rice pudding."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is recommended to be added to the list."
Positive"The commenter advises skipping Martha's Country Bakery, stating it is "nothing special" and also states that 7th Street Burger is "nothing special.""
Negative"The commenter advises dropping Martha's Country Bakery, finding it generic and lacking uniqueness, comparable to bakeries found outside of NYC."
Negative"The user's consideration for Martha's Country Bakery is based solely on its convenient proximity to Sunday in Brooklyn."
Neutral"The commenter expresses surprise at Martha's popularity, finding their desserts to be mediocre at best, overly sweet, and unmemorable after several visits."
Negative"Although not explicitly Dutch, Martha's is suggested as a bakery that might offer items similar to what the user is looking for from a Dutch bakery."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery's lemon cake, possibly a lemon coconut cake, is described as overwhelmingly and ridiculously tart to the point of causing jaw ache, suggesting it is best consumed one slice at a time."
Neutral"The original poster found the dessert from Martha's Country Bakery to be phenomenal and chose it for a friend's birthday, indicating high satisfaction."
Positive"The user expresses a strong preference for Martha's Bakery, describing its cheesecake as 'otherworldly rich and creamy.'"
Positive"Describes Martha's products as "so bad," suspecting the use of cheap oil instead of butter in their desserts. Despite discounted prices at a Bedford location, the author states they will never return due to the poor quality."
Negative"Strongly criticizes Martha's as a "fraud," reiterating that its dessert products are commissary-made, supermarket-quality, and worse than typical Greek diner desserts."
Negative
