Last Updated: 24 days ago
Phone: (718) 599-0900
Address: 263 BEDFORD AVENUE 11211
Brooklyn's go-to for classic American desserts, esp. cakes & pies. Known for generous portions and a wide selection that makes it a celebration favorite.
This beloved Brooklyn bakery is a go-to spot for classic American desserts, particularly its cakes and pies. With a reputation for generous portions and a wide selection, it's often cited as a great place for celebrations or a sweet treat. While some find it a bit too sweet, many praise its rich and creamy cheesecakes and the surprising delight of its strawberry shortcake.
This bakery specializes in American-style desserts, with a particular focus on cakes and pies. While many customers enjoy the generous portions and a wide variety of options, some find the items to be overly sweet. Specific recommendations include the strawberry shortcake and Neapolitan cake, while the tres leches and lemon cake have received mixed reviews.
"Notable recommendations include the Berry Napoleon, strawberry shortcake, blueberry pie, pistachio cheesecake, and Neapolitan cake. They are also noted for their chocolate cake selection."
Customer feedback is notably divided, with praise for its wide dessert selection and rich cheesecakes, but strong criticism regarding excessive sweetness and perceived lower quality ingredients by some.
Important Note
Some customers find the baked goods excessively sweet, and there are criticisms regarding the quality of ingredients and a perception of being a 'mid chain' rather than a unique establishment.
"This commenter recommended Martha's Country Bakery."
Positive"The commenter suggests Martha's apple crumble pie warmed a la mode."
Positive"The commenter disagrees with the praise for Milk Bar and Martha's Country Bakery, calling the latter a 'mid chain'."
Negative"The commenter recommends Martha's Country Bakery for its blueberry pie and pistachio cheesecake."
Positive"The commenter agrees with the negative sentiment towards Martha's, stating they were unimpressed after visiting once."
Negative"Martha's is mentioned, and the commenter disagrees with anyone who says they have terrible taste for liking it."
Positive"Martha's!!! is recommended."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery in Williamsburg is recommended, especially the Berry Napoleon, which one user ate almost entirely in one sitting."
Positive"The user recommended Harbs and Little Cupcake Bakeshop. They also mentioned Martha's Country Bakery if a location is convenient."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery was suggested as an option for a delicious red velvet birthday cake."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is recommended for its late hours (until 1 AM) and entertainment, noting it's a large venue."
Positive"The user reiterates their negative experience with Martha's, noting that their cupcakes and cakes lacked buttercream and instead used oil."
Negative"Martha's Country Bakery is described as bad, with cakes often being dry and cookies stale."
Negative"Martha's Country Bakery is suggested as a place open late with entertainment."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is criticized for using cheap ingredients and having a very bright atmosphere, suggesting it's more suitable for children's cakes than a destination experience."
Negative"Martha's Country Bakery is another option open until midnight or 1 AM, with many chocolate cake choices. The Neapolitan cake is specifically recommended."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is recommended for crumb cake, with an additional note that they also offer great bread pudding and rice pudding."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is recommended to be added to the list."
Positive"The commenter advises skipping Martha's Country Bakery, stating it is "nothing special" and also states that 7th Street Burger is "nothing special.""
Negative"The commenter advises dropping Martha's Country Bakery, finding it generic and lacking uniqueness, comparable to bakeries found outside of NYC."
Negative
