Last Updated: 4 days ago
Phone: (718) 599-0900
Address: 263 BEDFORD AVENUE 11211
Williamsburg staple for desserts, known for cakes & late hours. Divisive, but a go-to for many.
Martha's Country Bakery is a beloved Williamsburg institution known for its extensive dessert selection and ample seating. While some find it to be a reliable spot for cakes and pastries, others critique its sweetness and perceived use of lower-quality ingredients. Despite mixed reviews on consistency, it remains a popular choice for late-night treats and custom cakes.
Martha's Country Bakery offers a vast array of desserts, with cakes and pastries being the main focus. While some customers rave about specific items like the Berry Napoleon, cheesecake, and chocolate mousse cake, others find the baked goods too sweet, dry, or comparable to supermarket quality. There's a notable disagreement on whether the bakery uses butter or oil in its recipes. Some positive mentions include bread pudding, cannolis, and even vegan options like carrot cake.
"The Berry Napoleon is frequently cited as an outstanding item. Other praised desserts include chocolate mousse cake, cannolis, bread pudding, and Neapolitan cake. Pistachio cheesecake and blueberry pie are also recommended."
Customer opinions are sharply divided, with some praising the rich desserts and late hours, while others criticize the overly sweet flavors and perceived lack of quality ingredients.
Important Note
Some customers find the desserts excessively sweet or question the quality of ingredients used, with one common speculation being the use of oil instead of butter.
"In response to criticism, this user stated they love the Nutella and peanut butter combination."
Positive"This user strongly disagreed with the recommendation for Martha's Bakery, finding their hot chocolate excessively sweet."
Negative"Martha's Bakery's Nutella peanut butter hot chocolate was recommended."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery in Williamsburg was mentioned for its Mexican hot chocolate."
Positive"This user listed Martha's bakery as a potential place for bread pudding."
Neutral"This user commented that Martha's bakery is decent."
Neutral"This user states that the triple chocolate mousse cake from Martha's Country Bakery is so good they would devour a whole slice even when not high."
Positive"This user agrees Martha's quality has decreased, but finds their vegan carrot cake to be surprisingly good."
Positive"This user speculates that Martha's Country Bakery might use oil instead of butter."
Neutral"This user agrees that Martha's Country Bakery has declined, but confirms the berry napoleon is still very good."
Neutral"This user finds the Napoleons and fruit tarts from Martha's Country Bakery to be solid."
Positive"This user finds that cake from Martha's Country Bakery often tastes like the cardboard box it came in."
Negative"This user feels Martha's Country Bakery has declined in quality, with only the berry Napoleon being worth getting; other items taste like grocery store cake."
Negative"The Oreo cheesecake from Martha's Country Bakery is described as the type of gluttonous dessert that is especially enjoyable while high."
Positive"The chocolate chunk chewy cookie from Martha's Country Bakery is found to be incredible."
Positive"Responding to disappointment, this user clarifies that Martha's is a mid-tier bakery, good for convenience but not worth a special trip. They dislike the cookies but find the cake slices satisfying and rich, and the cannolis very sweet and delicious."
Neutral"This user has been disappointed with Martha's Country Bakery on multiple occasions."
Negative"This user enjoyed the Ekmek from Martha's Country Bakery, noting they also serve Greek/Turkish desserts."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery is recommended as the go-to for late-night dessert in Williamsburg, with the chocolate mousse cake and cannolis being good options."
Positive"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery for vegan cheesecake."
Positive
