Late-night bakery with a massive dessert selection, esp. cakes. Known for being a charming, casual spot, open till 1 AM.
This Brooklyn bakery is a popular spot for a wide variety of desserts, particularly cakes. While many praise their extensive selection and late-night hours, some find the offerings overly sweet or reminiscent of supermarket quality. It's noted for being a charming place open late, suitable for casual indulgence or celebratory cakes.
This bakery offers a vast array of desserts, with a particular emphasis on cakes. While many customers enjoy the extensive selection, including specific mentions of strawberry shortcake, chocolate mousse cake, and Neapolitan cake, some find the desserts to be too sweet or of mediocre quality, likening them to supermarket baked goods. There are also positive mentions of bread pudding, crumb cake, and vegan options like carrot cake.
"The Berry Napoleon, chocolate mousse cake, cannolis, and Neapolitan cake are frequently recommended. Vegan carrot cake and pistachio cheesecake also receive positive mentions."
Customer opinions are divided, with some calling it a beloved staple and others criticizing the quality and sweetness. It's frequently recommended for its wide variety of cakes and late operating hours.
Important Note
Some reviews suggest the bakery can be overly sweet and that the quality may not be consistent, with some comparing it unfavorably to Parisian bakeries or calling it 'supermarket quality'.
"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery's carrot cake, stating it's so good."
Positive"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery's carrot cake, calling it very good."
Positive"Marthas Country Bakery was recommended in response to a query about cake."
Positive"This user expressed a negative opinion about Martha's, describing their products as supermarket quality and the decor as faux country."
Negative"The Martha's location in Bayside is open until 1 AM."
Positive"This user commented that Martha's has delicious cake."
Positive"The original poster finds Martha's Country Bakery to be a good option for late-night, non-alcoholic treats, appreciating its location, quality of goods, portion sizes relative to price, and weekday specials. They specifically note its value as a charming spot open late for post-event relaxation."
Positive"This user suggests that Martha's Country Bakery might have old-school strawberry shortcake."
Positive"User agreed with the Martha's Country Bakery suggestion and specifically praised their peanut butter cheesecake."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery in Williamsburg or Astoria was suggested for its layered cake and cheesecake slices, including flavors like brownie and Oreo."
Positive"Martha's Bakery cheesecake is a favorite of this user."
Positive"The triple chocolate mousse cake from Martha's Country Bakery is recommended and enjoyed by the slice."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery chocolate fudge cake is highly praised."
Positive"The commenter recommended Martha's Country Bakery, noting that both of its Williamsburg locations offer ample indoor seating."
Positive"This commenter stated they tried Martha's but found a hair in their strawberry cake, and it was not their favorite."
Negative"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery, specifically mentioning their Berry Napoleon."
Positive"This user strongly recommends the vegan cakes from Martha's Country Bakery, noting that their picky fiancée loves them."
Positive"Martha's in Williamsburg is listed as a dessert option for late-night eating."
Neutral"This user stated they still think about the berry napoleon from Martha's Country Bakery almost two years later, finding it so good."
Positive"The author and their parents found the berry napoleon at Martha's Country Bakery to be unreal."
Positive
