A go-to for late-night sweets & massive dessert selection; known for cakes & pies, but some find it too sweet.
This Brooklyn bakery is a beloved spot for dessert lovers, offering a vast array of cakes, pastries, and pies. While many customers rave about the extensive selection and comfortable seating, some find the sweetness level to be overpowering or the quality inconsistent. It's a popular choice for special occasions and late-night cravings, with specific mentions of their strawberry shortcake, berry Napoleon, and various cheesecakes.
This bakery is known for its wide variety of cakes, pies, and other baked goods, with many customers highlighting their impressive dessert selection. Specific items like the strawberry shortcake, berry Napoleon, and various cheesecakes are frequently mentioned. However, a notable portion of feedback suggests that many items can be overly sweet, and some users have found the quality to be inconsistent, with criticisms of dryness or the use of cheap ingredients.
"Customers frequently recommend the Berry Napoleon, various cheesecakes (including pistachio and Oreo), strawberry shortcake, crumb cake, and chocolate mousse cake. The Neapolitan cake and vegan carrot cake have also received positive mentions."
Customer opinions are divided, with some praising the extensive dessert selection and comfortable seating, while others criticize the excessive sweetness and inconsistent quality of the baked goods.
Important Note
Some customers find the desserts to be excessively sweet, and there are opinions that the quality can be inconsistent or comparable to supermarket baked goods.
"User agreed with the Martha's Country Bakery suggestion and specifically praised their peanut butter cheesecake."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery in Williamsburg or Astoria was suggested for its layered cake and cheesecake slices, including flavors like brownie and Oreo."
Positive"Martha's Bakery cheesecake is a favorite of this user."
Positive"The triple chocolate mousse cake from Martha's Country Bakery is recommended and enjoyed by the slice."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery chocolate fudge cake is highly praised."
Positive"The commenter recommended Martha's Country Bakery, noting that both of its Williamsburg locations offer ample indoor seating."
Positive"This commenter stated they tried Martha's but found a hair in their strawberry cake, and it was not their favorite."
Negative"This user recommended Martha's Country Bakery, specifically mentioning their Berry Napoleon."
Positive"This user strongly recommends the vegan cakes from Martha's Country Bakery, noting that their picky fiancée loves them."
Positive"Martha's in Williamsburg is listed as a dessert option for late-night eating."
Neutral"This user stated they still think about the berry napoleon from Martha's Country Bakery almost two years later, finding it so good."
Positive"The author and their parents found the berry napoleon at Martha's Country Bakery to be unreal."
Positive"In response to criticism, this user stated they love the Nutella and peanut butter combination."
Positive"This user strongly disagreed with the recommendation for Martha's Bakery, finding their hot chocolate excessively sweet."
Negative"Martha's Bakery's Nutella peanut butter hot chocolate was recommended."
Positive"Martha's Country Bakery in Williamsburg was mentioned for its Mexican hot chocolate."
Positive"This user listed Martha's bakery as a potential place for bread pudding."
Neutral"This user commented that Martha's bakery is decent."
Neutral"This user states that the triple chocolate mousse cake from Martha's Country Bakery is so good they would devour a whole slice even when not high."
Positive"This user agrees Martha's quality has decreased, but finds their vegan carrot cake to be surprisingly good."
Positive
