Classic NY pizza & Italian ice joint. Busy, bustling, with a reputation for honest, crisp slices. A go-to for a quick, satisfying bite.
This midtown pizza joint offers a classic New York slice experience, with a variety of pizza styles and Italian ice. While some diners recall it being better pre-pandemic, it remains a popular spot for a quick and satisfying bite. The atmosphere is described as bustling, with limited seating that can lead to customers eating outside.
This establishment is primarily known for its pizza, offering various styles such as Margherita, Grandma, and Upside Down Sicilian. It also serves Italian ice. While many recommend the pizza, with one reviewer rating a pepperoni and white pizza slice a 9/10, one comment suggests it might have been better before COVID-19. The pizza is often described as having a crisp crust and a good balance of cheese and sauce.
"The Margherita, Grandma, and Upside Down Sicilian pizza slices are frequently mentioned and recommended. The Italian ice is also noted as a complementary offering."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards the pizza, often recommending it for its classic New York style. Some patrons recall it being better before recent years, and it's noted to be quite busy.
Important Note
Some customers feel the quality may have declined since before the COVID-19 pandemic. Seating is limited, and sometimes customers resort to eating outside.
"A commenter expressed their love for Vito's Slices & Ices and noted that it has become very crowded."
Positive"A commenter stated that the pizza from Vito's Slices & Ices looked awful, despite the original poster's positive review."
Negative"A commenter advised staying away from Vito's Slices & Ices, calling it a 'hidden gem'."
Neutral"In response to a compliment on the pizza, the author confirmed it was very good."
Positive"A commenter remarked that the pizza from Vito's Slices & Ices in the original post looked perfect."
Positive"The author had pepperoni and white pizza from Vito's Slices & Ices, rating it 9/10."
Positive"This user listed Vito's as one of their top picks for pizza near the US Intrepid."
Positive"This user recommended Vito's Slices and Ices as a by-the-slice pizza option near the US Intrepid."
Positive"Vito's slices and ices is recommended."
Positive"Agrees with the recommendation for Vito's."
Positive"Vito's is highly regarded by this user, considered a winner among the pizza options."
Positive"This user specifically calls out Vito's as a winner among the pizza recommendations."
Positive"Vito's slices and ices in Hell's Kitchen is mentioned as a place that feels like a classic New York pizzeria."
Positive"Vito's on 9th & 35th Street is recommended for its honest, crisp crust."
Positive"Vito's is listed as an 'other consideration' for pizza."
Neutral"Vito's is listed as an 'other consideration' for pizza."
Neutral"Vito's is listed as an 'other consideration' for pizza."
Neutral"Has not experienced long waits at Vito's on 9th avenue and considers it an accurate representation of a New York slice. Notes that seating is limited, and customers might eat outside."
Positive"Lists Vitos slices and ices as a recommended pizza place in Midtown."
Positive
