Consistently great bagels & schmears, even with long lines. A true NYC bagel staple.
A go-to spot for authentic New York bagels, this establishment has earned a reputation as a staple for its consistently high-quality bagels and an array of delicious schmears. Despite often having long lines, the service is noted for its speed, ensuring a quick turnover even during peak hours. It's a place that aims to be everything one could hope for in a bagel shop, with many patrons finding it a reliable and satisfying choice for breakfast or a quick bite.
This American bagel shop is highly recommended for its bagels, with the 'House special' being a particular favorite. Customers appreciate the consistent quality and variety of schmears available. It's noted that the bagels are best enjoyed earlier in the day. While generally well-regarded, one opinion suggests the quality is only 'ok', despite the long lines.
"The 'House special' is highly recommended, along with the general quality of the bagels and the variety of schmears."
Customers generally have a positive sentiment towards this bagel shop, with many praising the consistent quality of the bagels and the efficiency of the service, even during busy periods. Some compare it favorably to other well-known establishments in the city.
Important Note
The bagels are noted to be best enjoyed earlier in the day. One review suggests the quality might be just 'ok' despite the persistent long queues.
"Bagels & Schmear is recommended as a good place for bagels."
Positive"This bagel shop is recommended as a dining option located within a 20-minute walk of Gramercy Park."
Neutral"This user finds Bagels and Schmear to be only "ok", noting it always has a massive line."
Neutral"This user recommends Bagels & Schmear."
Positive"This user recommends Bagels and Schmear as a good option."
Positive"Notes that Bagels & Schmear is significantly better earlier in the day, based on their experience of having them at different times of day."
Positive"Mentioned they've only been to Russ & Daughters once but thinks they are known more for lox than bagels."
Neutral"Considers Bagels & Schmear a staple and everything they could hope for in a bagel shop."
Positive"Expresses interest in trying Bagels & Schmear and asks how it compares to Russ & Daughters."
Neutral"Recommends the House special and praises the consistent bagel quality and service, noting that the line moves fast despite the wait."
Positive
