Classic NYC bagel shop w/ a huge variety of bagels & spreads. Known for consistent quality & fast service, a true bagel staple.
Since 2000, this Kips Bay establishment has been a reliable brunch destination, drawing weekend crowds with its extensive selection of bagels and spreads. While the space is small, it compensates with a broad array of options, from classic to unique flavors like garlic and strawberry cream cheese. The bagels are noted for being large with an average consistency, making it a go-to spot for a dependable bagel experience.
This establishment is celebrated for its consistently high-quality bagels and an impressive variety of schmears, including unique options like strawberry and garlic cream cheese. Customers regard it as a staple, appreciating the broad selection and dependable preparation. It's recommended for a classic New York bagel experience.
"The 'House special' is specifically recommended, and the general consensus is that all bagels and their various spreads are a must-try."
Customers consistently praise the quality and consistency of the bagels and the efficiency of the service, even during busy periods. It's considered a reliable staple for a great bagel experience.
Important Note
The restaurant is significantly better earlier in the day. Some customers find it to be only 'ok' and note that it always has a massive line.
"Bagels & Schmear is recommended as a good place for bagels."
Positive"This bagel shop is recommended as a dining option located within a 20-minute walk of Gramercy Park."
Neutral"This user finds Bagels and Schmear to be only "ok", noting it always has a massive line."
Neutral"This user recommends Bagels & Schmear."
Positive"This user recommends Bagels and Schmear as a good option."
Positive"Notes that Bagels & Schmear is significantly better earlier in the day, based on their experience of having them at different times of day."
Positive"Mentioned they've only been to Russ & Daughters once but thinks they are known more for lox than bagels."
Neutral"Considers Bagels & Schmear a staple and everything they could hope for in a bagel shop."
Positive"Expresses interest in trying Bagels & Schmear and asks how it compares to Russ & Daughters."
Neutral"Recommends the House special and praises the consistent bagel quality and service, noting that the line moves fast despite the wait."
Positive
