Reliable, classic NYC pizza slices w/ long-standing quality. Known for Sicilian red slice & vodka chicken parm.
Step into a classic New York pizza joint that's been a favorite for years. With a long-standing reputation, this spot is known for its reliable and satisfying pizza offerings. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or a full pie, you can expect a consistently good experience that locals have come to trust.
This establishment is primarily known for its pizza, with specific mentions of a well-regarded Sicilian red slice and a popular vodka chicken parm. While generally praised, one comment humorously noted a Caesar salad pizza as potentially very high in sodium. The menu also appears to include chicken wings.
"The Sicilian red slice and the vodka chicken parm are highlighted as particularly recommended dishes. The 'Grandma' pizza has also been previously enjoyed."
Customers express a long-standing high opinion of the restaurant's offerings, particularly highlighting the Sicilian red slice and vodka chicken parm as consistent favorites.
Important Note
There is some debate among customers about whether the reopened Rosa's is the same as the original, and one comment humorously notes that a Caesar salad pizza might be very high in sodium.
"Station Pizza is remembered as a place that used to make stuffed slices, but the commenter hasn't seen them there in over 20 years."
Neutral"The commenter, who used to work at 1 Penn Station, recalls that while Rosa's Pizza wasn't the best, it was acceptable, especially during bad weather. They also jokingly question if it only served drinks."
Neutral"States that there is another location of Rosa's Pizza situated directly across the street."
Neutral"Mentions that there's debate about whether the reopened Rosa's is the same as before. Suggests Suprema as a comparable alternative for a throwback pizza experience."
Neutral"Confirms that Rosa's, also referred to as Rose's, is back in business."
Positive"The commenter was happy to hear that Rosa's Pizza, which they thought was gone, is back in operation."
Positive"This user recommended Rosa's pizza for its vodka chicken parm."
Positive"Recommends NY Pizza Suprema for its pizza, but notes it lacks atmosphere."
Neutral"This user mentioned Rosa's in the context of a Caesar salad pizza, humorously noting its likely high sodium content."
Neutral"The user mentioned having a BBQ slice from Rosa's Pizza."
Neutral"Rosa's is listed among pizzerias in Queens or Brooklyn that serve chicken wings, contributing to a conversation about common menu items in NYC pizza spots."
Neutral"Rosa's is noted as a pizzeria that serves chicken wings, mentioned in the context of discussions about pizzerias with broader menus."
Neutral"Expresses a long-standing high opinion of Rose’s Sicilian red slice available at Penn Station, indicating consistent quality."
Positive
